pairing: henry creel x fem!reader
tags/warnings: slow burn, teacher/student dynamic, power imbalance, dark undertones, tension, no smut (yet)
You’re not early this time.
The realization settles in as you glance briefly at your phone, more out of habit than necessity, before slipping it back into your pocket. The time is exact, neither rushed nor delayed, and yet the walk here hadn’t felt measured in the same way it had before. If anything, it had felt deliberate. Like each step had been taken with more awareness than usual, your thoughts trailing just slightly ahead of you the entire way.
You slow as the house comes into view, your gaze lifting instinctively toward it.
Quiet. Still. Set apart in that subtle way you noticed the first time, like it exists just slightly outside the rhythm of everything around it. The windows reflect more than they reveal, the curtains drawn just enough to keep the inside private without fully shutting it away. Nothing about it has changed, and yet standing here now, it doesn’t feel unfamiliar. If anything, it feels known.
And that’s what makes you hesitate. Not for long. Not the same uncertain pause as before, where you questioned whether you should even be here. This time, it’s shorter. Sharper. Less about doubt and more about awareness of where you are, of what you’re walking into. Of who’s inside.
Your fingers curl slightly at your side before you lift your hand and knock. The sound lands against the quiet street, echoing faintly in the stillness. This time, you don’t have to wait long.
The door opens almost immediately.
Henry Creel stands in front of you, composed as ever, his expression unreadable in that way you’ve come to expect.
“You’re not early today.”
His voice is even, but the observation lands with a quiet precision that makes it feel like more than a passing comment.
You tilt your head slightly, a faint hint of something more confident settling into your tone than the last time you stood here. “I figured I’d try being on time for once.”
There’s a brief pause as his gaze moves over you, not lingering anywhere specific, but thorough in a way that makes you aware of it anyway. It’s not new, you’ve felt it before. This time you don’t look away as quickly. If anything, you hold it for just a second longer. Just to see.
Something shifts — it’s subtle, almost imperceptible but you catch it.
“Good,” he says finally, stepping aside. “Come in.”
Crossing the threshold feels easier now, familiar in a way that settles quickly. You don’t hesitate in the doorway this time, your steps carrying you inside with more certainty as the quiet of the house closes in around you again.
It’s the same as before. Controlled. Minimal. Everything in its place.
And yet, you notice more.
Not because anything has changed, but because you’re looking differently now. Your attention lingers just a fraction longer on the details, the shelves along the wall, the careful absence of clutter, the way the space feels intentionally contained rather than empty.
You’re aware of him behind you as you move further inside. Closer than the distance suggests.
“There,” he says, gesturing toward the chair.
The guitar is already waiting.
You glance at it briefly before sitting, your fingers brushing lightly along the edge of the instrument as you pick it up. The motion is smoother now, more familiar, your body settling into position without the same stiffness as before.
But your awareness doesn’t settle as easily, especially not when you can feel him watching.
The question isn’t softened, but it’s not as sharp as it had been the first time either. There’s something more measured in it now, like he already expects the answer.
“I did,” you say, adjusting your grip slightly.
A small pause follows. You glance up and he’s already looking at you.
You nod faintly, positioning your fingers against the strings. There’s less hesitation this time, less uncertainty in where your hands should go, but that doesn’t mean you’re unaffected. If anything, the awareness is worse now because it’s not unfamiliar. Because you know exactly how close he can stand. How his voice sounds when it’s quieter. How his hand feels over yours.
You press into the first chord. It rings out clean. You hold it for a moment, letting the sound settle before shifting your fingers into the next position.
There’s still a slight hesitation but it’s not as noticeable as before. Yet you feel it immediately. You wonder if he does too.
You continue anyway, moving through the progression more carefully, more deliberately than last time. Your fingers adjust as you go, correcting small mistakes before they fully form, your focus sharper, not entirely where it should be though. Not on the guitar.
You finish and let your hand rest lightly against the strings, your breathing steady but just slightly more controlled than usual.
There’s a pause. You look up.
He hasn’t moved, but something about his attention feels different. Less distant. More direct.
You start again before he has to tell you.
Not out of confidence but because the silence between instruction and action feels more noticeable now, heavier in a way that makes you want to fill it before it stretches too far. Your fingers settle into position, pressing into the strings with more certainty than they had the first time you sat in this chair, and for a moment, it almost feels easy.
The first chord rings out clean. You shift, slower than you need to, making sure the placement is right before moving on.
The second follows with only the slightest hesitation — small enough that a week ago, you might have convinced yourself it didn’t matter.
You continue anyway, moving through the progression with careful focus, your attention fixed more deliberately on your hands than before. It works, for a moment. The transitions are smoother, the pauses less obvious, your fingers moving with a steadiness that almost feels natural. Almost.
Then you make the mistake of thinking about it. Your fingers falter which throws off the timing, causing the chord landing a fraction too late, the sound slightly uneven.
You exhale softly under your breath, already adjusting, already trying to correct it before–
The words cut through the room cleanly. Not raised. Not sharp. Just direct enough that your hands still against the strings anyway.
You glance up, your fingers still hovering where they’d stopped. “I am,” you say, the response coming a little too quickly to sound entirely convincing.
He doesn’t move. But his gaze sharpens, just slightly.
It’s not dismissive, it’s certain.
Your grip tightens faintly against the guitar, something defensive settling in your chest before you can stop it. “I just messed up one–”
“You’re anticipating again.”
The interruption is calm and controlled, yet it lands heavier than it should.
You look at him properly now, your brows pulling together slightly. “You said that last time.”
“And you’re still doing it.”
A pause settles between you, not long, but long enough that you feel it. You glance back down at the guitar, adjusting your fingers even though you’re not playing.
The response comes immediately and for a second it disarms you. You look up again. He’s watching you in that same way as before, focused, attentive, but there’s something more deliberate in it now. Less distant. Like he’s not just observing the mistake, but the reaction to it.
“Then what am I doing wrong?” you ask, quieter this time.
His gaze drops briefly to your hands, then lifts again.
“You’re not paying attention to what you’re doing.”
You let out a small breath, somewhere between a laugh and frustration. “That doesn’t make sense.”
You shake your head slightly, your fingers pressing absently into the strings without forming a chord. “I’m literally looking at my hands.”
“That’s not the same as focusing.”
There’s something in the way he says it that makes you pause instead of arguing again.
“Then what am I focusing on?” you ask.
The question hangs there. For a moment, he doesn’t answer. And in that moment, you become aware of it.
The way your attention had shifted earlier. The way it keeps drifting, even now.
His gaze doesn’t leave yours.
Your breath catches slightly. It’s not the words, it’s the way he says them. Like he already knows the answer.
“I don’t know,” you say, quieter now, your voice losing some of its earlier edge.
You nod faintly, adjusting your grip again as you press your fingers into position. This time, you don’t rush. You take a second longer before starting, trying to force your attention back to something solid, something controllable.
The first chord rings out. Clean.
The second, you hesitate, again.
You close your eyes briefly, exhaling through your nose. “Sorry, Mr Creel, I–”
“You don’t need to apologize.”
“And don’t call me that.”
You blink, looking up at him. “What?”
There’s a small pause, like he’s considering how to phrase the next part, though his expression doesn’t change.
The words land heavier than they should. You stare at him for a second, caught slightly off guard by the shift. It’s small, just a name, just a correction, but it changes something. The distance. The formality. The structure you hadn’t realized you were still holding onto.
Your fingers shift slightly against the strings, your attention no longer entirely on the guitar.
Saying it feels different, more familiar than it should. Something in his expression flickers, subtle enough that you might’ve imagined it, but he doesn’t comment on it.
You swallow faintly and look back down at the guitar, your fingers pressing into position again. This time, your focus feels split in a different way. Not scattered, but heightened. More aware of everything at once.
The first chord rings out clean.
The second, once again you hesitate.
You do immediately this time, your fingers stilling without argument.
“You’re doing it again,” he says.
You let out a quiet breath, your shoulders dropping slightly. “I know.”
“No,” he replies, and there’s something firmer in his voice now — not harsh, but more deliberate. “You’re not just anticipating it.”
Another pause. His gaze holds yours, longer this time.
The word settles between you. You don’t answer right away. Because this time, you know he’s right.
Your grip on the guitar tightens slightly before you force it to relax, your gaze dropping back to your hands.
“I said I’m trying,” you murmur, quieter now, less defensive than before.
“I didn’t say you weren’t.”
The response is calm, measured, but it doesn’t let you off the hook. You swallow faintly, your fingers shifting against the strings again, though you don’t start playing.
“Then what do you want me to do?” you ask.
Simple. You almost laugh. But you don’t. Instead, you nod slightly, your fingers pressing into position once more.
You don’t rush this time.
Not because you’re suddenly more confident, but because you’re frustratingly aware of everything you’re trying not to focus on.
Your fingers settle into place more carefully than before, pressing into the strings with deliberate precision as if control alone might be enough to steady your thoughts.
The first chord rings out clean, the sound grounding in a way that helps, if only for a moment. You hold it, letting the note settle before shifting your fingers into the next position. This time, you force yourself not to anticipate it, not to think ahead, just to move when you need to.
The second chord follows. Smoother. Not perfect, but close enough that you feel it.
A small flicker of relief settles in your chest, but it doesn’t last. Because the moment you notice it, your focus shifts again — not fully, not enough to completely lose control, but enough that the awareness creeps back in.
Of him. Of how close he’s standing. Of the fact that he hasn’t stepped back since correcting you.
You move into the next transition and hesitate.
The word is quiet, but it lands immediately.
Your fingers still against the strings, your shoulders tightening slightly as you let out a controlled breath.
“I didn’t even–” you start, but trail off when you realize there’s no point finishing it.
There’s no judgment in it. Just certainty.
You glance up at him, your brows pulling together faintly. “I barely hesitated.”
A pause settles between you, and for a second, you just look at him, something caught somewhere between frustration and something else you don’t want to name.
“I don’t know how to stop doing that,” you admit, quieter now.
He watches you for a moment, his expression unreadable in that same controlled way but his attention feels sharper now. More focused.
“You’re thinking about it too much.”
You let out a soft breath, almost a laugh. “That’s kind of my problem.”
“Then stop thinking about it.”
You tilt your head slightly, giving him a look that’s almost incredulous. “That’s not helpful.”
“No,” he says evenly. “It’s accurate.”
You shake your head, your fingers slipping from the strings as you drop your hand slightly into your lap. “I can’t just turn it off.”
“No,” he repeats. “But you can redirect it.”
You glance back up at him, a small frown settling in. “To what?”
“To something you can control.”
Before you can ask what he means, he steps closer.
Not just the shift in space, but the intention behind it. The way he closes the distance without hesitation, without asking, like it’s already been decided. Your breath catches faintly, your fingers tightening slightly against the neck of the guitar.
His voice is lower now. Closer.
You blink, caught slightly off guard by how quickly he’s picked up on it. “I’m fine.”
“No,” he replies quietly. “You’re not.”
Before you can respond, his hands settle lightly on your shoulders.
The contact is unexpected. Not abrupt, not rough, but deliberate enough that it stills you completely for a second. His fingers press just slightly into the muscle there, enough to make you aware of the tension you hadn’t realized you were holding.
The word is softer than before.
You swallow faintly, your body reacting before your thoughts can catch up. Your shoulders shift slightly under his hands, an instinctive response, even as your awareness sharpens in a completely different direction.
His touch lingers, it’s not something easily dismissed as necessary.
He adjusts his grip slightly, his thumbs pressing more firmly this time, working into the tension with slow, controlled movements. It’s not rushed. Not careless. Each motion is deliberate, measured, like he’s taking his time with it.
“Loosen your shoulders,” he murmurs.
“I am,” you say, but your voice comes out quieter than you intended.
His hands pause for a second, then continue, slower this time, more focused. The pressure eases, but the contact doesn’t.
“You’re still holding it,” he says.
You exhale softly, your grip on the guitar loosening as you try to follow the instruction. Your shoulders drop slightly, the tension easing enough that you feel the difference.
But his hands don’t move right away. They remain where they are for just a second longer than necessary, the warmth of his touch settling into something more noticeable now that you’re not actively resisting it.
Then slowly, he shifts. One hand moves from your shoulder, sliding down along your arm until his fingers settle lightly around your wrist.
Your breath catches again.
The contact is lighter here, more precise, his grip adjusting your hand with the same controlled intention as before. He lifts it slightly, angling your wrist just enough to correct the position.
“Here,” he says quietly. “You’re still overcompensating.”
You nod faintly, even though your focus isn’t entirely on the correction.
His fingers guide yours back into place against the strings, pressing them down with careful precision. The movement is familiar now — the way it lingers isn’t.
His hand doesn’t leave immediately. Instead, it stays there, steadying your wrist, holding it in position like he’s waiting to see if you’ll maintain it without him.
Your fingers move under his guidance, the chord forming more cleanly than before. The sound is steady, controlled.
You shift to the next, no hesitation.
It works. A quiet breath leaves you before you can stop it.
The word lands close. Too close. You don’t look at him, but you’re aware of him. Of how near he is and fact that his hand is still around your wrist.
His grip loosens, his fingers sliding slightly as his hand moves lower.
It’s subtle, almost unnoticeable, but you feel it.
His hand settles briefly at your side, just above your waist, the contact light but unmistakable as he adjusts your posture.
“Sit up,” he says quietly.
Your body reacts before your thoughts do, your back straightening slightly under the guidance of his hand.
The pressure is minimal, but it lingers. Not long. Not enough to be obvious. But enough to notice. Your fingers falter slightly against the strings.
“You’re distracted again.”
His voice is quieter now, closer. You swallow, your gaze fixed firmly on the guitar. “I’m trying not to be.”
The words aren’t harsh, but they land heavier now. His hand leaves your side, however the space it occupied doesn’t feel empty.
You nod faintly, your fingers pressing into position once more. Your movements are slower now, not from uncertainty, but from awareness. Everything feels more deliberate, more controlled, like you’re trying to hold onto something that keeps slipping just out of reach.
The first chord rings out.
The second follows without hesitation.
You move through the progression more smoothly this time, your focus sharpened by something that isn’t entirely concentration anymore. Your fingers move with a steadiness that feels almost automatic, your body responding more instinctively than before.
When you finish, you exhale softly.
You don’t move right away.
Even after finishing, even after the last note fades into the quiet, your hands remain where they are, resting lightly against the strings as if continuing would be easier than acknowledging the stillness that’s settled around you.
You can feel him behind you. Closer now than he’s been before. Not just in proximity, but in presence. It’s sharper, more defined, like the space between you has narrowed into something that no longer feels neutral.
You don’t turn. You don’t trust yourself to.
His voice comes from behind you, lower than it had been before, close enough that you feel it more than hear it.
You swallow faintly and nod, even though he can’t see it, your fingers shifting back into position. You don’t take as long this time as you already know what you’re trying to correct, what you’re trying not to think about.
You play through the progression.Not perfectly, but better.
The word comes quieter this time. Closer.
Your hands still immediately, your breath catching slightly as the sound of your own playing fades.
“I didn’t–” you start, but hesitate, your voice quieter now. “I thought that one was better.”
“But you’re still doing it.”
You close your eyes briefly, exhaling through your nose as your shoulders tighten without you meaning them to.
“It’s not as bad,” you say, softer now, like you’re trying to convince yourself as much as him.
The word lingers and you feel him shift behind you. Not stepping away — moving closer.
Your grip tightens slightly on the guitar, your fingers pressing into the strings even though you’re not playing anymore.
“I don’t know what else to do,” you admit, quieter than before.
“If you keep repeating the same mistake,” he says, his voice lowering further, “you’re never going to correct it.”
The response is immediate. Calm. But it doesn’t soften what comes next.
“But trying isn’t the same as fixing it.”
Your breath shifts, your focus slipping despite yourself. You’re aware of how close he is now, close enough that if you leaned back even slightly, you’d feel him. The thought settles uncomfortably and not entirely unwelcome.
“So what am I supposed to do?” you ask, your voice quieter now.
You almost laugh, but it doesn’t quite come out. “That’s not helpful.”
“No,” he says again, calm as ever. “It’s necessary.”
Before you can respond, you feel it, his hand. It settles lightly at your waist.
Not abrupt ort forceful, but deliberate.
Your breath catches sharply this time, your entire body going still as the contact registers. His hand isn’t gripping, not pulling you into place, but it’s there, steady and unmistakable, guiding the slight shift in your posture.
“I told you to sit properly,” he murmurs.
His voice is closer now. Too close.
You straighten instinctively under his hand, your back aligning more carefully as your grip on the guitar tightens slightly. The movement feels small, but the awareness of it isn’t.
Yet, his hand doesn’t move. It remains at your waist, the pressure light but grounding, like he’s keeping you exactly where he wants you — not forcing, just holding.
Your breathing isn’t as steady now.
You try to focus on the strings, on the placement, on anything other than the fact that his hand is still there.
You start playing. This time, your movements are more careful, not just technically, but deliberately restrained, like you’re trying to keep control over something that’s slipping. You make the mistake again. It’s small, but it’s enough.
His hand tightens — not enough to hurt, but enough that you feel the change immediately.
Your fingers still and your breath catches.
“That one,” he says quietly, “you didn’t even try to correct.”
“I did,” you insist, but your voice lacks the certainty it had before.
The word is softer now. But firmer.
A pause settles between you, heavier than before. Your grip tightens slightly against the guitar. “It’s not that simple.”
“No,” he says again. “But if you keep ignoring it…”
His hand shifts slightly at your waist — adjusting his fingers, pressing just enough to remind you they’re there.
“…you might need a different kind of correction.”
The words land slowly, causing your breath to falter. You don’t respond. You’re not entirely sure you can.
The implication lingers. It’s not explicit but clear enough that it settles somewhere deeper than the rest of his instructions had. Your fingers feel unsteady against the strings.
This time, your focus is sharper but not calmer. It’s heightened, pulled tight between concentration and something else entirely. Your movements are careful, controlled, your fingers pressing into place with more precision than before.
You don’t make the mistake. You finish the progression, your breath leaving you slowly as the final note fades.
There’s a pause, it’s longer this time.
His hand is still at your waist.
And then, he leans in. Not enough to touch beyond that, just close enough that you feel it. The shift in air, the presence of him just behind you, his voice lowering further when he speaks again.
Your breath catches again, your fingers tightening slightly against the guitar as your awareness sharpens all over again. You don’t turn but you know how close he is.
And still. he doesn’t move away.
You start playing again, not because you’re ready or because your focus has returned, but because the alternative is sitting there in the silence with him still that close behind you.
Your fingers press into the strings, the movement slower now, more deliberate, like you’re trying to ground yourself in something familiar. The sound comes out steady enough, but it doesn’t feel controlled. Not in the way it should. There’s a disconnect between what your hands are doing and where your attention is, like your body is following instruction while everything else lags just behind.
You don’t hear him move, don’t feel him step away, not even slightly, and that awareness sits heavy at the back of your mind, pulling at your focus no matter how hard you try to keep it steady.
You make it through part of the progression before it slips again, not the same way as before. Worse. Because this time, you don’t even try to correct it.
“You’ve stopped trying to hide it.”
His voice comes from just behind you, low and even, close enough that it sends a quiet, immediate tension through your shoulders.
Your hands still against the strings, your breath catching faintly before you let it out slowly. “I haven’t,” you say, but it lacks the certainty it had earlier.
Not raised. Just certain, causing your to fingers press a little harder into the strings, but you don’t turn around.
The silence stretches just long enough to make it feel deliberate.
You hesitate for a second, and that’s enough.
“Or don’t,” he adds, quieter now.
That lands differently, your fingers press back into place almost immediately, like the hesitation hadn’t happened at all, like you can undo it just by continuing. The chord sounds again, steady enough to pass, but you’re still not focused
“You’re not even pretending now.”
This time, he moves, you feel it — the shift in presence as he steps out from behind you, the space changing again as he comes into your line of vision. You don’t look up right away, but you’re aware of him differently now, the closeness no longer behind you but beside you.
Your grip loosens slightly on the guitar, your shoulders dropping just a fraction as you exhale. “I don’t know what you want me to do,” you admit, quieter now.
his hand tilts your chin upward.
It’s not forceful or rough, but it’s firm enough that you don’t resist.
Your breath catches as your gaze is drawn to his, the proximity hitting you all at once now that you’re facing him properly. He’s closer than you expected, close enough that you can see the smallest details, the steadiness in his expression, the control that hasn’t slipped even once.
“I want you to focus,” he says quietly.
You try to respond. You really do. But the words don’t come, you’re too aware of how close he is. Of the fact that neither of you has moved. Of the way his hand hasn’t dropped from your chin.
Your breath falters and that’s when it happens.
It’s not rushed, not sudden. If anything, it feels like the moment had been building toward it for longer than either of you had acknowledged. He leans in just enough to close the distance.
For a second, you feel it before it happens — the faint shift of air, the quiet proximity of him.
Then his lips meet yours.
Soft at first. Barely more than a brush, restrained enough that it almost feels like a question. The contact lingers, light but deliberate, his mouth still, as if he’s taking in the moment rather than acting on it.
And then it changes. The pressure deepens, his lips pressing more firmly against yours, more certain now. Still controlled, but no longer soft. There’s intention in it, something quieter but heavier beneath the surface, like he’s decided this is what he wants and isn’t pulling back from it.
Your breath catches sharply, your body going still for a split second, caught somewhere between surprise and something else.
It lasts only a moment longer before he pulls back. He doesn’t pull back far, just enough to look at your face.
The silence that follows is deafening.
You stare back at him, your chest rising and falling a little too quickly, your thoughts scrambling to catch up to what just happened.
He doesn’t look unsettled, or unsure. If anything, he looks exactly the same. Composed.
Like he’s already decided how to frame it.
“You needed to reset,” he says evenly.
The words don’t match what just happened. Your brows pull together slightly, your breath still uneven. “You–”
You stop, shaking your head faintly, like saying it out loud might make it more real.
“A distraction,” he interrupts calmly. “And you weren’t correcting it.”
“That’s not how you fix it,” you say, quieter now —but the resistance in your voice isn’t as steady as it should be.
The question is simple, but it lingers.
You don’t answer because you don’t entirely know how to.
The room feels different now. Smaller, Like the air has shifted in a way you can’t undo.
You pull back slightly, your hand dropping from the guitar completely now, your fingers curling faintly at your side as if they don’t quite know what to do with themselves.
“I–” you start, but stop again, your thoughts too scattered to land anywhere properly.
“I need to use the bathroom.”
The words come out more abruptly than you intend.
There’s a pause as he studies you for a moment. Not stopping you. Not questioning it.
“Down the hall,” he says.
You nod quickly, already standing before you can second-guess it, your movements just slightly unsteady as you step away from him. The distance feels necessary now, urgent, even, as you move toward the hallway without looking back. The bathroom door closes behind you with a quiet click.
And suddenly. it’s silent. Completely silent.
You stand there for a second, your hand still on the door handle, your breathing uneven as the reality of what just happened settles in all at once.
The thought lands heavier now, without his presence to distract from it. You let out a slow breath, turning slightly as your gaze moves around the room.
The bathroom is exactly what you should expect. Minimal. Clean. Controlled.
The counter is clear aside from the essentials, nothing unnecessary, nothing personal left out without reason. Even the mirror is spotless, reflecting the room with sharp clarity that feels almost too precise.
Your reflection catches your attention.
You look different. Not physically, but there’s something in your expression, caught between confusion and something else you don’t want to name.
Your fingers lift slightly, brushing briefly against your lips without thinking, lingering there a second longer than they should.
It hadn’t been an accident. That’s what stays with you.
You exhale slowly, your hand dropping back to your side as your thoughts spiral slightly, trying to make sense of it.
Your grip tightens slightly against the edge of the sink as you look down, your thoughts catching on that details more than anything else, and not entirely for the reason you want them to.
You don’t let yourself answer that. Instead, you straighten slightly, forcing a steady breath as you push the thoughts down enough to step back out there without completely losing your composure.
You don’t stay in the bathroom longer than necessary.
Even though it would be easier to remain here, in the quiet, controlled stillness of a room that doesn’t feel like it’s shifting under your feet. You’ve already steadied your breathing, already forced your thoughts into something resembling order, but the moment you reach for the handle, that fragile sense of control starts to slip again.
Because he’s still out there.
The thought settles low in your chest as your fingers curl around the handle, hesitating for just a second before you push the door open. The hallway feels quieter than before. Or maybe it’s just you.
You step out slowly, your movements more measured now, your awareness sharpened again as you move back toward the room. Each step feels deliberate, like you’re bracing yourself for something you can’t quite predict. You don’t hear him at first, not until you reach the doorway.
Henry stands near where you left him, posture unchanged, expression just as composed as it had been before you walked away. If anything, the stillness makes it worse — like nothing has shifted on his side at all. Like what happened didn’t affect him.
Your steps are slow as you enter the room. For a moment, neither of you speaks. The silence stretches, not empty, but heavy, filled with everything that hasn’t been said. Your gaze flickers briefly toward the guitar, still resting where you left it, then back to him.
He’s already looking at you. Of course he is.
You hold his gaze for a second longer than you should. And this time, you don’t know what you’re looking for. There’s no apology in his expression. No hesitation. Just that same quiet, controlled focus that makes it impossible to tell where he stands.
“You’re done for today.” The words come calmly. Decisively.
You blink slightly, caught off guard by how easily he says it. Like the decision had already been made before you even stepped back into the room.
It’s the only response you can manage.
“You’re not focused,” he continues, his tone even, measured. “There’s no point continuing like this.”
The explanation makes sense. It should. And yet there’s something about the way he says it that makes it feel like it’s not the full reason.
You nod faintly, your fingers curling slightly at your side. “Right.”
Another silence settles. Neither of you moves immediately. The space between you feels different now, charged in a way that lingers, like something unfinished is still hanging there, waiting to be acknowledged.
You’re aware of everything.
The fact that you’re still standing there.
You should leave. The thought is clear. Obvious. But you don’t move right away.
“Next time,” he says, and your attention sharpens instantly, “you’ll need to focus.”
The words are familiar, the way he says them isn’t. Your breath shifts faintly.
“On the guitar,” he adds, after a beat.
The clarification comes too late. You swallow, your gaze dropping briefly before you nod again. “I will.”
You’re not sure if you mean it, not in the way he expects.
It feels like something else should be said. Like there’s something sitting just beneath the surface that neither of you is acknowledging. But he doesn’t say it, and neither do you. So instead, you turn.
The movement feels heavier than it should, like you’re pulling yourself away from something that hasn’t fully let go yet. Your steps are slower now, more deliberate as you move toward the door, your awareness lingering behind you even as you create distance.
You can feel it. His attention is still on you.
Your hand finds the handle and for a second, you hesitate. You don’t turn around. But you think about it.
The air outside feels colder. Sharper. It hits you all at once, the quiet of the street replacing the stillness of the house in a way that should feel grounding, but it doesn’t. Not completely. Because the tension hasn’t left. It’s followed you, settling just beneath your skin, impossible to ignore.
You step away slowly, your movements unhurried, like you’re trying to process everything before it slips too far out of reach.
The thought returns immediately. Clearer now. Louder.
You exhale softly, your hand lifting unconsciously, your fingers brushing lightly against your lips before you drop it again.
It hadn’t been impulsive or uncertain, it was contolled. Deliberate. A ‘correction.’ A way to reset you.
Your brows pull together faintly. It doesn’t make sense and yet you hadn’t pulled away. You hadn’t stopped him.
Your pace slows slightly as you turn onto your street, your gaze unfocused as your thoughts loop back again, catching on the same moments, the same details.
The way he’d looked at you. The way he hadn’t hesitated. The way he’d acted like it was nothing. Your fingers curl slightly at your side.
The question settles deeper than you expect.
Because if it was, then why does it feel like this?
You reach your door without fully registering the walk, your hand resting against the handle as your thoughts finally begin to quiet, not resolve or settle, but slow enough that you can breathe again.
The words echo faintly. Your chest tightens slightly, but not with dread. Something else. Something quieter.
You don’t try to convince yourself it shouldn’t happen again. You don’t even try to ignore the way the thought settles, because somewhere beneath the uncertainty, you’re already waiting for it.
Then finally, you open the door and step inside.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
tysmm for reading this chapter!! i told you this one was going to get more intense. i hope you enjoyed how the tension is building between them 👀
things are only going to get more intimate from here, so good luck for the next one 💗
