creepypasta x afab reader | nsfw | their secret kink - headcanons
characters : jeff the killer, eyeless jack, ticci toby, jane the killer
cws : explicit content, afab reader, breeding kink, knotting, creampies, free use, public sex, power play, fem dom, bdsm, lingerie, degradation
a/n : another round of creepypasta headcanons! this time it's what kink i believe the pasta's would be a little shy about admitting ;). if you guys would like a part two then just leave a comment what characters you would like to see next! i do plan to branch to some other fandoms that are listed in a link on my pinned post, so don't be shy to send some requests! enjoy xoxo
jeff the killer | jeffery woods
i am such a firm believer in free use jeff. something about getting to have you all to himself whenever and wherever he wants just sets him off. especially in risky situations when you both know anyone could walk in and catch you. his favorite spot is the kitchen because it's right by the living room where someone always is. he'll have you bent over the sink, one hand coming up to press against your mouth while the other is shoved in your pants pumping his fingers in and out of your gummy walls. better not be too loud or they just might catch you.
getting him to actually admit this though is like pulling teeth. we all know jeff can be a stubborn ass at times (especially when he knows it's the truth). it's such a hit to his pride to admit just how much he constantly wants you, how many times he thinks of taking you. but once you suggest the idea of free use? you might just come to regret it when you realize just how insanely high this mans sex drive is. you can't get anything done when he's around. laundry? he's kneading at your tits and grinding himself against your ass. dishes? somehow you end up with dish soap down your tits and a horde of hickies. this man is relentless when it comes to you!
jeff loves the idea of having that kind of power to just take and take whenever he wants. there would be many moments within the mansion that he would lead you off to a private spot, wordlessly slipping down your pants and shoving his fingers into you. it wouldn't be until you're literally begging him to fill you that he would oblige. leaning down to whisper sweet praises that your his good little slut as he pumps you full of his cock. get too loud and he'll shove a couple of his fingers in your mouth to muffle the sounds as his thrusts get more brutal. "look at you, can't even keep quiet you're so needy for my dick," he'd murmur against the crook of your neck.
•• ━━━━ ••●•• ━━━━ ••
eyeless jack | jack nyras
....i have said it once and i will say it again. breeding kink eyeless jack! it doesn't even matter if the two of you don't want kids, he wants to stuff you to the brim!! especially when he reaches his season of heat (demon biology has its perks). it's genuinely the only thing on his mind just to breed you over and over again. he's bad about containing that too. every chance he gets he'll have his thick cock buried inside you to the hilt, muttering about how he needs to fill you with every thrust.
eyeless jack isn't too shy to admit this though, it doesn't take much convincing to get him to cave in. and once he does? he's going to have you stuffed so full of him that you'll constantly have to change your panties. something about that only turns him on more though. the idea of him dripping down your thighs throughout the day, reminding you of who you belong to. makes him want to cum inside you all over again. he'll lead you off to the bedroom, whispering sweet things about how much he needs you and he just can't get enough of you. when he does finish, he makes sure that you take every last drop, pushing any drips back inside you with his fingers even after he pulls out.
i also believe that jack would knot (if you weren't an omegaverse kid, you're on you own with this one lol). his cock swelling at the base , making sure you physically have to take his seed. he'd be hunched over you, his form encasing your own as that knot swells to stretch you out even further. "just like that sweet thing, you can take it," he'd whisper, pressing encouraging kisses to the back of your neck and shoulders.
•• ━━━━ ••●•• ━━━━ ••
ticci toby | tobias rogers
hear me out on this one. i feel like toby would be secretly into his partner having complete and total control. it would take a great deal of trust but something about actually putting that trust into another person is exhilarating to him. it would start off small, with you topping him or commanding him into what position you wanted. then it would become more exploratory. you choking him, blindfolding him, gagging him, etc. the more trust he has in you, the harder the kinks get.
this would be a hard one for him to admit to. i mean, it's not exactly an easy conversation to start with "hey i want you to tie me up and ride me like a bitch in heat". it would have to begin with you initiating a little power over him. riding him and telling him what a good boy he is to let you use his pretty cock however you wanted. that would help open him up more to the idea of you being in complete and total control. eventually, leading to some more aggressive kinks, or even punishments. he'll start acting up on purpose just to get you to make him eat you out for the next hour to earn forgiveness.
toby is already a very praising partner but once the two of you begin exploring this- he will worship you. he'll beg you just to let him lick your perfect cunt, he doesn't even need anything in return. (but you still take care of him after being such a good boy). he especially loves it when you ride him, his hands cuffed to the headboard as his hips desperately rut up into you. his cheeks would be all flushed, eyes glazed over with sheer need. "p-p-please y/n, i'll do anything just let me cum in you," he would beg in that sweet whiny little voice he always used when close.
•• ━━━━ ••●•• ━━━━ ••
jane the killer | jane richardson
jane and food play. that's it. that's the post. i feel like she realized she had this kink when you were eating something messy like ice cream. you just a bit of cream smeared over your upper lip- and jane? jane was transfixed. before she knew it, she was leaning in to lick it away. she always had been drawn to seeing you in pretty things. lacy lingerie just for her, your hair and make up all done up like you were begging her to ruin it. but the idea of you being her personal plate? delicious (pun intended hehe).
she wouldn't even realize there was entire kink for this. who wouldn't want to lick whipped cream off their girlfriends nipples? but the moment she suggests anything about it to you, and you explain that it is in fact an entire kink- well, at least she has a name for it now. after that, she'll constantly want to try new things on you. some strawberries perfectly rested on your collarbones so she can suck the remaining juice off and leave hickies? yes please. she'll even try and match it to whatever lingerie you have on. but her absolute favorite is whipped cream. simply because she can put it anywhere on you without it rolling off and create various patterns with it. even spelling her name across your body.
she would have you all sprawled out in her plush bed, various candies and dollops of sweet cream along your form. with each lick or suck, she would leave behind a light purple mark to remind you. as she trails lower, her hands push your legs apart, her lips hovering just over where you needed her most. "my favorite treat," she'd hum, running her tongue just barely across your folds. you were the kind of craving she could never get enough of.
I feel like something no one really talks about is how flexible Creepypasta is. It's why I've been so head deep into it for over 10 years by this point. We can all just make our own stories, make our own interps of popular characters. We all essentially just play with everyone's OCs like they're canon characters from a specific piece of media. And that's why it's so fun. Everyone's version is so cool and loved. So many different HCS, so many different stories!!!
hi :-) can I get the “saying I love you and leaving them on read” with tim and Kate perhaps,,, (or just all the girls) I love ur work jackie : 3
SAYING "I LOVE YOU" THROUGH TEXT THEN LEAVING THEM ON READ [PT.3]
(Pt.1) (Pt.2)
⋆˚࿔ Summery: basically sending them a text saying "I love you" before leaving them on read
⋆˚꩜｡ A/N: you've reached the end of THIS series!! Watch out for more SMAU content bc I had a lot of fun making this lol / I ALMOST forgot to add Helen so he will be added to this AND my masterlist once I edit it sorryyy
── .✦ Warnings/content: Jane, Nina, Nat, Kate, Helen, and Tim x GN! Reader, angsty af, very hinted suicide but it is not specifically specified so it can also be read as reader is hurt, no LJ, Slender, or Candy Pop mention
