doing a messmer playthrough & having a whole new experience with this questline

seen from Türkiye
seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom

seen from Russia

seen from Australia

seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from Singapore
seen from Germany
seen from United States

seen from T1
seen from United States
seen from Türkiye
seen from Germany
seen from Russia

seen from Japan
seen from United States

seen from Chile

seen from United States
doing a messmer playthrough & having a whole new experience with this questline
frolicking in Jarburg prints ✦ patreon
Jarburg.
I was created to be a warrior vessel. Many great warriors reside within me, ever dreaming of becoming a great champion. It's my destiny. And the reason for which I quest. It is my ordeal, you could say. To test myself, to better myself, to fell ever greater foes. And then, one day, we'll be a single great champion. The greatest of them all! What do you think, eh? How do you rate my changes? Heh heh...
Etsy
Here’s chapter 2! An alternate introduction to this short story.
Messmer, Warrior Jar Alexander, and Jarburg
Disclaimer: These are just random thought bubbles and headcanons at 2am in the morning that have taken my brain hostage. I don’t have a solid idea of the timeline of events.
————————————
Assuming this is before Messmer was sent to damnation during the Realm of Shadow crusade, I wonder if he ever visited Jarburg. They are the closest reminder to his mother’s people, where she was able to take back control of the atrocities that happened to Shaman Village and turned it into something good.
Based on the item descriptions and lore, Messmer was quite well liked by pretty much everyone. To the point Radahn and even the Carrian Princess Rellana held him in high esteem. And he clearly held a lot of empathy for those who were misfortunate. As shown with his jar infirmary and his acceptance of an albinauric (Commander Gaius) as his right hand.
I’d like to imagine him being reluctant at first because he feels he might be too imposing, so he stands off to the side like a vampire in the shadows. Watching them from afar.
Jarburg is very peaceful and kind towards many. I don’t know if Marika ever visited herself, but I can imagine that Messmer is nearly brought to tears at how they are thriving. That this is what him and his Marika are fighting for. He probably would just observe from a distance until a jar folk spotted him. Not just any jar folk, but a young one with the boisterous personality to rival Radahn.
Alexander is his name, and he’s going to become a great warrior jar some day. Messmer’s big brother instincts immediately kick him and there he goes regaling child versions of his battles and even teaching the kid fighting tactics on how to use his jar body. The kid admires him so much that he said he’s going to be big and strong and noble like him. The kid is none the wiser to the mental breakdown Messmer is holding back the entire time. Messmer’s heart clenches because he is not noble. He is only doing what he musts, to keep himself and his affliction as far away from others as he can.
The Potentate Complex
Lately, the wonderful @catcas22 and I have been discussing the Hornsent, the Omens, and the Living Jars. Cat has two excellent posts on the subject up, one on the nature of the Lamenters and another on a potential link between the Omen's nightmares and the crimes of their progenitors. I highly recommend you read those posts first and then come back to this one, as they'll make it much easier to understand some of the concepts I'll be bringing up.
Anyhow, there's something that fell by the wayside in all this: the word "potentate." It's curiously exclusive to the context of jars in Elden Ring.
In the base game, Jar-Bairn and the other residents of Jarburg are searching for a Potentate to serve as a leader/protector of their village. The criteria for which are... odd. Jar-Bairn first attempts to enlist the player as Potentate, only to reject us on the grounds that our callused warrior hands are unsuited to the position. He finds what he believes to be a better candidate in Diallos Hoslow, but can later be found remarking that while he rather likes Diallos's soft, supple hands, he finds the younger Hoslow uninspiring as far as protectors go, going so far as to wish that they could have a Potentate who's "big and strong, like you."
In SOTE, we learn that "Potentate" was also the title given to the Hornsent clerics who butchered human/Numen villages to fill the Living Jars.
Interesting.
Assuming Cat's theory about the throughline between the Hornsent Potentates, the Living Jars, and the Omensmirk nightmares is correct, I think I have an idea of what's happening here.
We've established that when a human consigned to a jar reincarnates as an Omen, they retain some subconscious mnemonic impression from their previous life, potentially establishing the terror and torture endured at the Hornsent's hands as the source for the shared nightmares about horned beings that plague all Omen. We also know that "rancorous spirits" cling to the flesh inside the jars.
I don't think it's unreasonable to suppose that if the Omen retain memories of their previous deaths, the jars created by the Hornsent do the same. However, I'd also suppose that the mindscape of a Living Jar is all kinds of confusing. Every jar we talk to seems to have one unified voice/personality, despite their innards being composed of an every-growing multitude of beings who each have discrete spirits. Add that the same souls clinging to scraps of jar meat are also the ones being reincarnated as Omen, and a picture starts to emerge.
I think that the process of being eviscerated and stuffed into a jar, along with whatever ritual allows for their reincarnation, seems to "split" the soul of the victim, and this may be by design. One fragment is allowed to return the Erdtree to be reincarnated, but the other is trapped, sealed in the jar to prevent it from escaping. The free half comes back as an Omen, while the sealed half remains locked away from the Erdtree and its other half, ensuring that pure reincarnation is impossible.
This also has a confounding effect on the memory impressions of the soul. The Omen have vague nightmares about horned beings torturing them. Meanwhile, the Jars also have the memories of their component people, perhaps clearer as a result of not having passed through the Erdtree but confused in other ways as a result of being part of this single-voiced mass of flesh and spirits.
Jar-Bairn and the others simultaneously associate the word "Potentate" with warrior strength and the gentle, ritualistic touch of a cleric. They vacillate between thinking a Potentate should be a strong protector (the Hornsent's sacking and butchering of villages) and a soft-handed, studious artificer (the same Hornsent going on to craft and fill the Living Jars in clandestine underground laboratories). The word is divorced from the terror its origin inflicted in the minds of the jars, who know only that their existence is inextricably linked to strong yet careful beings called Potentates.
There are two interesting addendums to our tale, one being the Potentate's Cookbook.
A record of crafting techniques of the greater potentate who roamed lands near and far. Haunted by the grotesque practice of his village of birth, he stuffed great pots with all manner of things.
Apparently, at least one Potentate was disgusted by the actions of his peers and left to travel the world, but continued to experiment with ritual pots in other ways that involved considerably less occult sacrifice.
The other afterthought I'd like to mention is the weapon of the Potentates, the Bonny Butchering Knife (which is actually a greataxe that looks like a curved greatsword, but that's besides the point):
Weapon of the greater potentates of Bonny Village. An outsize butcher's cleaver used to dismember human bodies in the making of the great jars stored in the gaols.
Restores a very small amount of HP when it squarely strikes an enemy.
I'll now direct your attention to the Butchering Knife found in the base game, used by the Tarnished-Eater Anastasia:
Huge carving knife made to cleanly butcher the human body. Signature weapon of the Ogress Anastasia, known to have eaten countless Tarnished while disguised as a Finger Maiden.
Restores a very small amount of HP when it squarely strikes an enemy.
Again, still not a knife, or a greataxe, but I digress.
These weapons are IDENTICAL in many respects. They use the same model, have the same heal-on-hit passive, and even their attack/guard ratings, weights, stat requirements, and FP costs are the same. The only difference is their names, descriptions, and default Ashes of War, and even the former two are only negligibly distinct. I feel quite comfortable in stating these to be the same weapon.
So here we have a massive cleaver expressly designed to butcher the human body, wielded historically by the Hornsent Potentates who terrorized the settlements of other races to build "saints" out of their corpses, and one instance having fallen into the hands of a psychotic serial killer in a far-off land.
Tying this back to the cookbook, I propose that after wandering for some time, the rueful Potentate left the Land of Shadow altogether, journeying to the Lands Between, where he beheld the fruits of his peers' labor in the form of the Omen and Living Jars dwelling there. At this point, he cast off the tool of his trade and settled somewhere to live out his days in morose solitude.
Some amount of time later, his former weapon fell into the hands of God's bloodthirstiest soldier, who immediately noticed that it was perfect for her preferred pastime of killing and eating people. So perfect, in fact, that it could only have been designed with such a purpose in mind.
And another thing: isn't it funny that the Omenkillers, whose attire draws inspiration from the Omen's nightmares, also use cleavers? Cleavers made from Omen horns, but cleavers nonetheless.
INKTOBER 21 - Jar Bairn, Elden Ring
The little jar as endearing as his uncle Alexander. Eme