Pairing: Matt Casey x Reader
Prompt: Drinks make the truth come out
Warnings: Swearing, smut (18+)
“Why do you do this to yourself?” Sylvie came up behind you making you jump from your previous position of staring longingly at Matt Casey from across the bar.
“Do what?” You acted innocent swirling your finger around the edge of your cup.
“It’s been months of you even just avoiding him. Aren’t you sick of it? At least if you go and talk to him you can move on. He misses you. He told me.” She avoided your question knowing full well you knew what she was talking about.
“I’m good.” You shrugged turning to face her.
“What’s the worst that could happen?” She pushed.
“Oh, I don’t know. He rejects me and we never talk again and have to spend the next year trying to completely avoid each other at work and I have to transfer because of the awkwardness.” You rushed out, already having thought about it in your head.
“You’re ridiculous.” Sylvie stated a few seconds later.
“Am not.” You scoffed. Continuing to bicker with her until Matt’s voice stopped the words flowing from either of your mouths.
“What’s going on here?” He asked eyebrow raised as he sat across from you.
“Nothing!” You both exclaimed a little too quickly only furthering his suspicions.
“Yeah it sure sounds like it.” He teased face lighting up with the most precious smile that always made you melt on the inside.
“Oh look! Cruz is here!” Sylvie interrupted winking at you before hurrying off. He looked between you and Sylvie before shaking his head.
“It looks like you need another drink.” He gestured to your almost empty cup.
“Oh, no. I’m good. I was just about to head home.” You shook your head.
“What? No, you just got here! Have at least one more. I’ll buy.” He persuaded. You thought for a minute before declining again. “Please. We haven’t had a drink together in forever. I feel like you’ve been avoiding me… please,” What he didn’t know is you were avoiding him. You didn’t want to get too bold and say something stupid, “for me?” He begged. He had no idea the impact that small statement had on you. Sighing you finally gave in. He smiled wide telling you to stay put until he got more drinks. Returning he sat a full glass of wine in front of you. Your plan was to nurse the drink for a while so you didn’t get too drunk too fast but also be able to enjoy the time with Matt you had been avoiding for the past month in fear of your feelings finally bubbling over. That plan however quickly went up in flames. Before long you were on your second glass of wine and even though you didn’t feel it completely yet you knew it’d be coming. Although Matt was drinking beer he was going through them faster than you and you could tell he was at least buzzed, and the conversation was flowing.
“No I’m serious. There’s just something about you that makes people want to impress you. There’s a reason you run the best Truck out there.” You smiled.
“I have a feeling we’d be even better if you came over like you wanted to.” He pushed. You were a bit taken back that he even remembered that. It was whenever you first started 2 years ago, and you casually dropped into conversation that you had always wanted to try to become a firefighter. Push yourself. See if you could accomplish it.
“I think I’ll stick to the ambo.” You laughed shyly.
“Why have you never told me that before? You really are a nerd!” Matt joked.
“Okay rude.” You blushed looking down.
“I’m just kidding.” He smiled lightly taking your hand in his, “a little bit anyways.” He winked making you giggle. “See I missed this. I missed you. What happened?” He asked, but you avoided the question, changing the subject. You had liked Matt from the minute you had met him. Unfortunately for you it seemed like every other girl in Chicago did too. So you settled for good friends. That only fueled your fire for him though so you had to put it to a stop. Give yourself some space. Move on. That turned out to be way more difficult than you had anticipated. Underestimating your actual feelings for him.
Before long everyone was filtering out of the bar and Matt still sat across from you. Both of you aware of what was happening around you and what was being said, but also quite tipsy at the same time.
“I mean yeah I guess mind control would be pretty cool.” You shrugged.
“It seems like you already have that power though.” Matt replied. You looked at him confused before asking,
“You are giving me the most inappropriate thoughts right now.” Matt admitted confidently. After a few seconds of you not answering his confidence seemed to waiver a little. “I’m sor-“ He rushed making you laugh and clasp a hand over his mouth. Standing up you grabbed your purse and coat before grabbing his hand and pulling him out behind you. Luckily Otis, Hermann, and Stella were cleaning and never witnessed you leaving together. Upon walking out Matt tightened his grip on your hand calling for a taxi. The ride back to his place was a mix of awkward, hot, and tense as you lay your head on his shoulder and he gently ran his fingers up and down your leg. He quickly paid the driver before pulling you into his house. He helped take your coat off leading you into his living room. You had been in his house numerous times. It was like a second home to you, but for some reason this time was more intense. As you noticed every part of the room. The small scrape in the paint, the slightly crooked picture, the umbrella leaning against the wall. It felt like all of your senses were heightened. You were still slightly drunk, well buzzed at least, although very quickly sobering up, and wanted this more than anything you have ever wanted before you had no idea how to continue and it seemed like Matt didn’t either. Until he stepped closer to you tucking your hair behind your ear. He looked down at you with a small smile on his face, blue eyes peering into yours, palm against your cheek and other hand on your hip.
“Can I kiss you?” He whispered already almost against your lips.
“Please.” You whimpered looping your arms around his neck. He chuckled lightly before leaning in completely. The feeling of his lips on yours was even better than you could’ve imagined. Relaxing you pushed your body closer against his kissing him harder. His grip on your hip tightened as you nipped the bottom of his lip. He welcomed your tongue into his mouth before fighting back for dominance. Until he pulled back to get a breath, moving your hair behind your shoulders and dipping his head to kiss your neck. You rolled your head back in order for him to get more access. Only breaking for a second so you could get his shirt over his head. You had gotten sneak peaks of Matt without his shirt on, on a few different occasions around the house, but like this...up close and personal, given the ability to run your fingers over his chest down to his abs, feeling him tense at the coldness of your hands was... something else. You sucked in a deep breath as he bit down just below your ear before licking the pain away. He returned to your lips picking you up swiftly in the meantime walking towards his bedroom. In no time you were being laid down on his bed him hovering over you. Matt sat you up to pull your shirt above your head before collapsing back down. He ran his fingers gently along the edges of your bra making you whimper slightly before he lowered his head, his lips following where the tips of his fingers were seconds before. Arching your back up he took the hint reaching behind you to unclasp your bra expertly. “You’re a little too good at that.” You joked making him chuckle, slowly taking your bra off and throwing it to the side. Matt smirked before moving his lips to your neck as his hands roamed all over the top half of your body. Stubble tickling your chest once he made it down to your breasts. Mouth working on each nipple laying open mouthed kisses all over your chest. Getting tired of the teasing you reached down to work on his belt quickly getting it off.
“And you’re a little too good at that.” He retorted eyebrow raised. You shrugged innocently leaning up to kiss his bare chest working to get the button on his jeans open. Once succeeding you slipped your hand under the hem of his underwear heart pounding harder now that you felt the size of him. He stifled a moan against your skin at the feeling of you working your hand up and down his shaft. Moving to get your pants off now. You helped him and before long you laid completely clothless in front of him. The intensity of his gaze looking you up and down suddenly made you nervous and insecure, reaching for the blanket to at least slightly cover yourself up. Once he realized what you were doing he stopped you pinning your hands above your head and kissing all over your body. “And here I thought you couldn’t get anymore beautiful.” He whispered hovering above you and leaning down to press a soft kiss on your nose. You felt your face heat up even more at his compliment. He kissed you gently but deeply before moving down your body not leaving an inch untouched. You could feel yourself getting impatient by the second and could only imagine how wet you truly were by now. The sight of Matt Casey in between your legs was by far the best sight you could’ve ever been graced with. He pushed your knees further apart leaning down to kiss and bite at your thighs making you groan which caused him to grin. “You have to tell me what you want honey. I’m not doing anything without your permission.” He looked up at you cheek pressed against your thigh.
“I want your mouth. Please.” You sighed wiggling a little.
“I was hoping you’d say that.” He smiled lightly going back to pressing gentle kisses up your thigh until he met your pussy. He started off slow gently licking up your folds, occasionally flicking his tongue against your clit. Until he picked up speed his tongue alternating between thrusting inside you and paying extra attention to your clit. His fingers occasionally working themselves in. It didn’t take long at all for him to have to pin your hips down on the bed to reduce the reactions of you jolting up in his face. His tongue quickly made you a moaning mess and you could feel your release approaching, and as much as you wanted to finish you stopped him. Pushing him back and pulling him up to you quickly. “Hey. I was in the middle of something.” He pouted.
“Yeah well that something was about to end either way.” You retorted.
“Well why couldn’t I keep going?” He huffed.
“Because I want my first time with you to be solely from you.” You emphasized. He laughed leaning down to kiss you, still tasting yourself on his lips, you finally got his pants off throwing them on the floor. Your heart about exploded at the sight of him. Not really comprehending that you were about to be fucked by Matt. Finally.
“I think I can get on board with that.” He whispered in your ear biting it. He moved so his hands were resting on either side of your head. “You’re sure?” He asked again. You nodded your head shifting a little bit. “I have you hear you say it babygirl.” He looked into your eyes sincerely. Voice more raspy than you had ever heard it before only making you wetter.
“Yes I’m sure. I’ve never been more sure about anything.” You answered. He laid a gentle kiss on your chest hand dropping to his dick to guide himself into you. You let out a sigh at the feeling, pain overtaking you a little at his size. You raked your fingers up his back as he leaned down to kiss you distracting you from the pain. Stopping to let you adjust when he finally bottomed out.
“Wow..you are so tight…” he groaned into the crook of your neck. You began to squirm and he took that as the go ahead pulling out slightly and slowly pushing back inside of you. You immediately moaning at the motion. “You make the most gorgeous sounds.” He whispered into your ear only furthering the sensations. You both were moving at a steady pace moans and heavy breaths filling the room. Matt shifted propping one of your legs on his shoulder for better leverage, hitting your g spot hard as he did, causing you to cry out in pleasure.
“Matt..god..please right there.” You begged nails digging into his sheets. Listening to your command Matt continued to hit your g spot over and over again harder with each thrust. You felt the knot forming in your stomach breathing heavily, “Matt...baby..” you warned whimpering.
“Go ahead baby I’m right behind you.” Casey grunted thrusting faster and harder. Your legs clenched around his body as he tried to push them open. Muscles spasming as the pleasure filled your body in waves. Yelling out curses and Matt’s name unable to think of anything else. “Fuck..[Y/N]..oh fuck..” Matt groaned pulling out just in time for you to feel spurts of his cum cover your stomach and breasts. Matt collapsed down beside you after completely finishing giving you both time to catch your breath. After a few minutes Matt rolled off the bed returning a few seconds later towel in hand to clean you up before laying back down beside you. You moved to cuddle into him before stopping yourself. Sighing heavily you moved to grab your clothes off the floor. “Hey. Where are you going?” He grabbed your wrist.
“I don’t know..I just thought..” You trailed off.
“Just thought what? That I just fucked you for fun?” He asked confusion in his voice, “Not that it wasn’t fun. It definitely was.” He added moving closer to you. You stared at him silently not able to find the right words. “Come here. Please?” He begged opening his arms. You had no problem giving into him cuddling into his side. “I have no intentions on just fucking around here [Y/N]. I really like you.” He promised stroking your hair.
“Man, this is a fantasy I’ve had since I like met you.” You admitted drawing circles in his chest as he laughed at you.
“Well in that case I’m more than happy to fulfill.” Matt promised.
You woke up to a strong arm pulling you closer and soft kisses being pressed across your shoulders. You hummed contently before shifting to face the man behind you. You smiled running your fingers through Matt’s hair. Taking notice of the tiredness still present in his eyes.
“Goodmorning.” He smiled moving to brush the hair out of your eyes and lay a gentle kiss on your forehead.
“Goodmorning.” You replied snuggling closer into Matt’s warm body and just as you did his alarm started to beep. He huffed rolling over to shut it off before returning to you. “No.” You pouted shoving your head in his neck.
“I don’t think we really get to decide that sweetheart.” He laughed rubbing a hand up and down your back. You groaned rolling over to look at what time it was. He took this as an advantage to get up, unraveling himself from you, reluctantly standing up, and pulling a pair of boxers on. “I’m going to get a shower. You want to join me?” Matt smirked suggestively hands resting on the bed.
“As much as I would love to we have to hurry up. You still have to take me back to my apartment.” You rushed him.
“Why?” He asked walking over to his dresser.
“We can’t drive in together.” You answered like he was crazy slipping out of his bed to throw on one of his shirts.
“We’ll just tell them your car wouldn’t start if anyone asks.” He retorted turning to face you and smiling at the sight of you in his shirt. “Can’t decide if I like you in my shirt or without it better.” Matt flirted moving towards you.
“No.” You scolded hand meeting his chest from moving any closer, “They all know I’ve been avoiding you. Plus Sylvie lives closer it wouldn’t make sense for me to call you AND I have to get my clothes.” You explained moving to gather some of your things ignoring his hot gaze on you.
“So you have been avoiding me.” He crossed his arms accusation clear in his voice.
“Yes, I was avoiding you. Now hurry up!” You scolded.
“Not until you tell me why.” He walked closer wrapping his arms around your waist but leaning back to look at you.
“Fine! I was scared I would slip up and you would reject me. Okay? Happy? Now goooo.” You admitted.
“Yes dear.” He gave in, “but that obviously wouldn’t have happened.” He added kissing you quickly and heading towards the shower. Luckily you had made it on time and nobody seemed to notice a thing. Going about your days like normal. Walking through the bunk room you were quickly pulled into Matt’s office, door shutting behind you.
“Uh hi?” You laughed at him as he leaned back onto his desk.
“I know you were avoiding me before, but do you have to continue to do it?” He asked a little annoyed.
“I don’t want to raise any suspicions.” You answered sadness in your voice.
“So I have to go a whole 24 hours without talking to my girl?” He frowned pulling you into his body.
“Your girl huh? I could get behind that.” You smiled up at him, hand resting on his cheek.
“I hope so.” Matt leaned down to kiss your forehead before moving to sit in his chair and pulling you down onto his lap. “Seriously though.” He repeated himself.
“I’ll work on it. In the meantime we can always enjoy these little sneak offs.” You said innocently twirling the hair on the nape of his neck between your fingers.
“You do owe me a rain check from this morning.” Matt smirked adjusting you so you were now straddling him
and not just sitting in his lap.
“You want to do it now? Isn’t that a little risky Captain?” You teased.
“What's life without a little risk?” He grinned. You chuckled biting your lip before leaning down to capture his lips with yours. Smell and taste of mint taking over you. You felt his smile as he pulled you closer into him. Lifting your shirt up a little as his hands rubbed up the bottom of your back. Just as Matt began to deepen the kiss there was a quick knock on the door followed by it opening.
“Hey Capta-Oh my god!” Came from the doorway as you jolted away from Matt. Outside stood Otis wide eyed and his reaction summed a few others that were gathered around as well. You hid your face in your hands until Casey grabbed them pulling you back down into his lap.
“You do know you probably shouldn’t come in until I give you permission right?” Matt joked.
“Well I do now.” Otis shivered.
“So much for sneaking around.” You mumbled leaning your head into the corner of his neck and shoulder. Matt laughed against you, kissing the top of your head and answering the questions that were being thrown at you both.
