feel like fraction doesnt really understand bruce and alfred, first with the hallucinations now with the new butler
first of all, i dont want to immediately dismiss this character since we dont know the context of why shes here yet and i know people are already gonna hate her just by virtue of being a woman replacing a popular male character. i dont want to come off that way but there is an actual reason im skeptical of alfred's role being replaced instead of just bringing him back
i dont think fraction understands what afred is to bruce. bruce doesnt have any other domestic workers and i cant think of an example of him showing a want for another one. when alfred is not here bruce has only showed a want for alfred back, not a replacement. this is because alfred is not just his butler, he is his dad so alfred cant be replaced at this stage in bruce's life. bruce deeply respects and trusts alfred and i feel like theres a codependency in a lot of early batman stories, no not because he cant mop the floor but because it feels like alfred is the only person bruce can really talk to at that early stage in his life. alfred also isnt really a great person to be emotionally dependent on because he often minimizes bruce's feelings. as bruce meets more people who know the real him, he becomes less dependent on alfred. alfred has enough money to retire several times over but he remained the butler until he died because he does actually deeply love bruce and wants to remain close to him but also doesnt want the responsibility of being anything more than a butler so he continues doing the house chores and keeping their relationship professional even if they both know their relationship is much deeper than that, they just dont say it out loud. and no theres nothing wrong with parents who live with their adult children, you people just have nuclear family brainrot and as someone whose lived in a multigenerational household i really like that they lived together that long.
so anyways i just dont see bruce wanting a new butler since she would just be his butler and the dynamic would not be the same and her role in bruce's life would not be the same. i dont think fraction gets the reason why bruce had a butler in the first place. also i know bruce can do the fucking dishes and put away the laundry and it just feels like she is here because woman = wash dishes for man. doing chores is not why bruce kept alfred around😟. only other reason i can think as to why shes here is to serve as the narrative foil that alfred often served as and even then i feel like it hits differently when alfred openly disagrees with bruce because again that is his dad coming from a place of love(even when hes wrong) and she would just be an employee