FOR: Orthodox
Regarding the prohibition of music during sefiras haomer and the three weeks, have any poskim written about what constitutes music? I know there’s some debate about whether it’s only live music or also recorded music that’s prohibited, or whether a capella music is permitted, but I am curious if anyone has written about this prohibition re: genres like harsh noise or artists like Merzbow, where many people might not think of it as music. Or what about bird or whale “songs”: do these constitute music even though they’re not human-made?
.








