Scream Og NSFW Headcanon ABC
A = Aftercare (What they’re like after sex – caring, cuddly, distant, etc.)
Billy: isn’t naturally cuddly or soft afterward. He’ll check if you’re okay with a smirk, maybe toss you a towel or water, but he prefers to watch you recover while he smokes a cigarette or runs his fingers over any marks he left. Over time with you, he gets a bit better — pulling you against his chest possessively, whispering “You did so good for me, baby” in that low voice, but it always feels a little calculated.
Sidney: is incredibly attentive and protective after sex. She pulls you close, strokes your hair, and checks in with soft questions like “You okay, baby?” She runs a warm bath or brings water and snacks. Her trauma makes her hyper-aware of consent and comfort, so aftercare is non-negotiable for her.
Tatum: is surprisingly sweet and clingy after sex. She’ll pull you on top of her, wrap her arms around you, and demand cuddles while she catches her breath. She loves when you stroke her hair and tell her how pretty she looked. Expect lazy kisses and her murmuring “You’re so good to me, baby…” in that soft, satisfied voice.
Stu: isn’t exactly the soft type, but after he’s wrecked you he’ll lazily pull you against his chest, still grinning like a maniac. He’ll mock you for how wrecked you look while running his fingers through your hair or wiping you down with his shirt. It’s condescending aftercare but he does it because he likes knowing he’s the only one who gets to see you like this.
Dewey: Incredibly attentive once you’re both finished. Even if he’s exhausted and a little shaky, he immediately shifts into caretaker mode. He’ll pull you close against his chest, kiss your forehead, and ask in that soft, slightly raspy voice if you’re okay. He loves running a warm cloth over your skin, bringing you water, and cuddling for as long as you want.
Gale: She’ll pull you close against her chest, running her fingers through your hair while she catches her breath, murmuring praises about how well you took care of her. She expects you to fetch water or a warm cloth, but she’ll reward you with soft kisses and lazy cuddles, letting you rest your head on her while she strokes your back.
B = Body part (Their favorite body part of their own and of their partner’s)
Billy: His favorite part of his own body is his hands — strong, capable of pinning you down or gripping your throat just right. On you, he’s obsessed with your ass and tits, but he also loves your lips. He stares at them constantly: when you talk, when you moan, and especially when they’re wrapped around his cock. He’ll grab your hips hard enough to leave bruises while fucking you from behind.
Sidney: loves her own tits — she enjoys when you touch or kiss them because it makes her feel desired and vulnerable in a good way. On you, she is obsessed with your lips. She can spend ages kissing them, biting them gently, or watching them part when you moan. She’ll tell you how pretty they look wrapped around her fingers or how soft they feel against her skin.
Tatum: she absolutely loves her ass. She knows it looks amazing in tight jeans or little skirts and she’ll tease you by wiggling it or bending over “innocently” just to get your attention, she’s obsessed with your voice — the way you moan her name, the little gasps you make, and especially when you get all breathy and whiny for her. Hearing you lose control turns her on more than anything.
Stu: Favorite part of himself is definitely his tongue. He’s obsessed with how long and skilled it is, always bragging about how he can make you scream with just that alone. On you, he can’t get enough of your neck and thighs — the way they tremble when he bites down or leaves hickeys, marking you so everyone knows who you belong to. He loves grabbing your thighs hard enough to leave fingerprints while he spreads them apart.
Dewey: Dewey’s favorite part of his own body is his hands because they let him touch and explore you so thoroughly. On you, he adores your thighs and hips—he loves gripping them gently while he’s between your legs, feeling the way they tremble or squeeze around him when you get close. He’ll kiss and nuzzle them for ages, telling you how perfect they feel under his palms.
Gale: Her favorite body part on herself is her legs — long, toned, and always shown off in those killer heels or short skirts. On you, she adores your mouth and tongue; she loves watching them work between her thighs while she lounges back like royalty. She’ll often guide your head exactly where she wants it with a firm grip in your hair.
C = Cum (Anything to do with cum – where they like it, how much, etc.)
Billy: has a strong marking kink. He loves cumming inside you (raw if you let him) and watching it drip out, or pulling out at the last second to paint your stomach, tits, or face. He enjoys the sight of his cum on your skin — it’s like claiming you. He’ll sometimes smear it with his fingers and make you taste it, smirking the whole time.
Sidney: She loves making you cum hard and often. She enjoys the sight and taste of your wetness on her tongue or fingers. She’s not overly messy herself but gets a quiet satisfaction from seeing you soak her hand or face. She’ll praise you softly while you come down.
Tatum: She’s a total mess lover when it’s your turn to make her finish. She loves when you make her cum hard and then keep going until she’s shaking. She gets really vocal and will grab your hair or the sheets while she rides it out. She’s not shy about how wet she gets for you.
Stu: is messy as hell and proud of it. He loves pulling out at the last second and painting your stomach, tits, or face with his cum, then making you look at the mess while he laughs.
Dewey: He gets a quiet thrill from making you come, and he loves the way you taste and sound when you do. He prefers finishing inside you or on your stomach/thighs if you guide him there, but only after he’s already satisfied you multiple times. Seeing the evidence of your pleasure on his skin or yours makes him blush and smile shyly, like he’s proud he could give you that.
Gale: She loves making a mess on your tongue and watching you swallow every drop while she holds your head in place. She also enjoys when you’re soaked from her, smearing her wetness across your lips and chin before pulling you up for a deep, possessive kiss so she can taste herself on you.
D = Dirty secret (This one is self explanatory)
Billy: Deep down, he fantasizes about fucking you while wearing the Ghostface mask or right after a kill (the adrenaline high turns him on insanely). He also gets off on the idea of you knowing his secret and still wanting him anyway — the ultimate power trip and twisted form of intimacy.
Sidney: Deep down, Sidney sometimes fantasizes about letting go completely and being a little rougher or more desperate with you — pinning you down, leaving marks — but she’s ashamed that the idea excites her at all.
Tatum: Deep down she fantasizes about you completely taking control and spoiling her rotten in public places where you could almost get caught — like fingering her under a blanket at a party or in the back of a car. She’d never admit it out loud because she likes acting like she’s the one in charge… but being secretly wrecked by you is her guilty pleasure.
Stu: Dirty little secret is that he secretly wants a threesome with you and Billy. He fantasizes about watching Billy take control of you while he joins in, the two of them tag-teaming you until you can’t think straight. He’s never fully admitted it out loud (yet), but the idea of sharing you with his best friend gets him stupidly hard.
Dewey: Deep down, Dewey has always fantasized about being completely at your mercy in the bedroom—letting you tell him exactly what you want while he focuses solely on pleasing you. He’s a little embarrassed by how much he craves being “used” for your satisfaction, but the thought of you guiding his head or hands and praising him for doing a good job secretly turns him on more than anything.
Gale: Deep down, Gale sometimes fantasizes about letting someone film her while she’s completely lost in pleasure with you — not for broadcast, just for her private collection. She’d never admit it out loud because she’s spent her career controlling the narrative, but the idea of having secret footage of her coming undone under your mouth turns her on more than she’d ever confess.
E = Experience (How experienced are they? Do they know what they’re doing?)
Billy: has decent experience from past hookups and his relationship with Sidney, but a lot of it is self-taught through porn and horror movies. He’s confident and knows how to make you fall apart, but he learns your body quickly and adapts to what makes you scream his name the loudest.
Sidney: Not very experienced yet. She’s only been with one person before (Billy, briefly and unsatisfactorily), and she’s still figuring things out with girls. But she’s a fast learner and very eager to please you. She reads your reactions carefully and asks what feels good.
Tatum: She’s had a few boyfriends but nothing serious with girls before you. She’s naturally confident and quick to learn what she likes. With you she’s eager to explore, but she still expects you to lead most of the way.
Stu: Has plenty of experience — he’s been around and he’s shameless about it. He knows exactly how to use his height, strength, and that wicked tongue to drive a girl crazy. With you, though, he acts like every time is the first, acting all surprised at how wet you get for him just so he can mock you for being so easy.
Dewey: Dewey isn’t the most experienced guy, especially with how chaotic his life in Woodsboro has been, but he’s a quick and enthusiastic learner. Whatever you like, he pays close attention and remembers every little reaction. He might start off a bit clumsy or nervous, but once he figures out what makes you moan louder, he becomes incredibly focused and dedicated.
Gale: Has plenty of experience, mostly with men in her past, but she’s discovered that being with a woman lets her be far more selfish in the best way. She knows exactly what she likes and isn’t shy about teaching you her preferences with that signature bossy tone. She’s had a few discreet flings over the years that helped her perfect her demanding pillow-princess style.
F = Favorite position (Their go-to sex position)
Billy: Doggy style or you riding him while he grips your hips and controls the pace. He loves watching your ass bounce and being able to pull your hair or slap it. Missionary is also a favorite when he wants to be intense and stare into your eyes while choking you lightly or whispering filthy things.
Sidney: She loves being on top in a way that lets her see your face — missionary with your legs wrapped around her, or you riding her thigh while she holds your hips and guides you. Face-sitting is a close second because she can focus entirely on making you feel good with her mouth.
Tatum: being pressed flat into the mattress, your body covering hers completely, while you thrust into her from behind. It makes her feel pinned, helpless (in the hottest way), and she can bury her face in the pillow to muffle her loud moans.
Stu: His go-to is doggy style or having you bent over whatever surface is closest. He loves the way he can grip your hips hard, pull your hair, and slam into you while whispering filthy things in your ear. It gives him the perfect angle to be mean, slapping your ass and telling you to arch your back like a good girl.
Dewey: His absolute favorite is having you on your back or sitting on his face so he can devote himself to you with his mouth and hands. He loves being able to look up at your face, watch every expression, and feel your body respond while he works to bring you over the edge again and again. Any position where he can focus entirely on your pleasure without much pressure on himself is perfect for him.
Gale: Facesitting is her absolute favorite. She loves straddling your face, hands braced on the headboard or tangled in your hair, controlling the exact pressure and speed while she looks down at you with that smug, satisfied smirk. She also enjoys you between her legs while she leans back against a pile of pillows like she’s on a throne.
G = Goofy (Are they serious in the moment, or do they get silly/humorous?)
Billy: Not really goofy during sex. Billy is intense and focused. He might smirk or make a dark, sarcastic comment, but he rarely laughs or gets silly. Sex with him feels dangerous and serious most of the time — like you’re in one of his horror movies.
Sidney: Rarely goofy during sex. She’s usually serious and focused, almost intense, because she wants it to feel meaningful. But if you crack a joke or smile at her, she’ll soften and let out a little laugh before kissing you again.
Tatum: She can get a little goofy and sarcastic even during sex — cracking jokes or playfully complaining (“If you don’t make me cum in the next two minutes I’m breaking up with you”). But when she’s close, the sass disappears and she turns into a whiny, needy mess.
Stu: Is definitely goofy during sex — he’ll crack jokes right in the middle of thrusting, laugh when you moan too loud, or suddenly switch from mean dom to pretending he’s “helping” you like it’s a game. But that playfulness always has a sharp edge; he uses humor to tease and humiliate you in the hottest way possible.
Dewey: He can get a little awkward or shy in the heat of the moment, sometimes cracking a soft, nervous laugh if he fumbles or if you tease him sweetly. But once he’s lost in pleasing you, the goofiness fades into quiet concentration and devotion. He might blush and smile against your skin when you moan his name, but he never lets it pull him out of the moment for long.
Gale: Is rarely goofy during sex. She stays in control and keeps things intense and sensual, though she’ll occasionally let out a low, amused laugh when you get especially eager or when she teases you for being so desperate to please her. Her humor usually comes out as sharp, teasing dirty talk rather than silliness.
H = Hair (How well-groomed they are down there – trimming, shaving, etc. Does the carpet match the drapes?)
Billy: keeps things trimmed but not completely shaved. He likes a little hair down there. On you, he doesn’t mind at all — he actually prefers you natural or lightly groomed. He’ll bury his face between your thighs without hesitation.
Sidney: keeps herself neatly trimmed — nothing too wild, just enough to feel natural. She doesn’t mind if you have hair or not; she’s just happy to be close to you. She finds the whole thing intimate rather than something to overthink.
Tatum: Keeps herself neatly trimmed or completely smooth — she likes feeling pretty and put-together down there. She doesn’t mind a little hair on you, but she loves when everything feels soft and clean against her skin.
Stu: He keeps things pretty natural down there — not completely wild, but definitely not manscaped to perfection. He doesn’t care much about his own, but he loves when you’re smooth or lightly trimmed so he can feel everything clearly when he’s going down on you with that favorite tongue of his.
Dewey: He keeps things neatly trimmed down there—practical and clean, the way a small-town deputy might prefer. He doesn’t mind a little natural hair on you at all; in fact, he finds it incredibly sexy and intimate. He’ll nuzzle and kiss you there without hesitation, showing you exactly how much he enjoys every part of you.
Gale: She keeps herself neatly trimmed and always perfectly groomed — she’s too image-conscious to let anything be less than flawless down there. She expects you to be well-kept too, but she doesn’t mind a little natural hair if it means she can bury her face (or have you bury yours) without any distractions.
I = Intimacy (How romantic or intimate they are during sex)
Billy: He can be surprisingly intimate when he wants to manipulate you or when he’s feeling possessive. Slow, deep thrusts while staring into your eyes, whispering “You’re mine” or “No one else gets to have you like this.” But real emotional intimacy is rare — a lot of it is performance mixed with genuine obsession.
Sidney: Extremely intimate. Sex with Sidney feels emotional. She maintains eye contact a lot, kisses you deeply, and whispers soft praises (“You’re so beautiful… I’ve got you”). Her trauma makes her crave real connection, so she wants it to feel safe and loving.
Tatum: She acts like she’s too cool for super romantic sex, but she secretly melts for it. Eye contact, soft kisses on her neck and shoulders, and you calling her “good girl” or “my pretty baby” make her weak. She wants to feel desired and adored.
Stu: Intimacy with Stu is chaotic and possessive rather than romantic. He’ll stare intensely into your eyes while he’s buried deep inside you, but instead of sweet words you get mocking praise like “Fuck, you’re so tight for me… you really are my favorite toy.” He likes the raw, unfiltered connection mixed with his mean streak.
Dewey: Sex with Dewey is deeply intimate and emotional. He’s not the type for detached or rough encounters—he wants eye contact, soft touches, and constant little affirmations. He’ll whisper how much he loves you and how lucky he feels while he’s touching you, making the whole experience feel loving and connected rather than just physical.
Gale: Even though she’s controlling, Gale can be surprisingly intimate once she trusts you. She’ll maintain eye contact while you’re between her legs, breathing out soft praises mixed with commands. After she comes she likes to pull you up and kiss you slowly, letting the moment feel almost romantic before her bossy side kicks back in.
J = Jack off (Masturbation headcanons – how often, fantasies, etc.)
Billy: He masturbates fairly often, especially when he’s worked up from his “hobby” (the killings). He thinks about you a lot — your moans, the way you look when you cum, or scenarios where he has total control over you. He’s not shy about it and might even let you watch sometimes.
Sidney: She doesn’t do it often — her mind is usually busy with worries or school. When she does, it’s usually in the shower thinking about you: your lips, your sounds, the way you look at her. She feels a little guilty about it afterward.
Tatum: When she masturbates alone, she thinks about you. She’ll use her fingers or a vibrator while moaning your name, usually lying on her stomach in prone position because it’s her favorite.
Stu: Jerks off a lot, especially when he’s thinking about you. He’ll call you on the phone (sometimes in that creepy Ghostface voice just to mess with you) and describe exactly what he’s doing to himself while demanding you touch yourself too. He gets off on the idea of you knowing how desperate he is for you.
Dewey: When he masturbates (which isn’t that often because he’d rather save his energy for you), he thinks about your sounds, the way you taste, and how you look when you come because of him. He strokes himself slowly, imagining he’s still between your legs or following your instructions, and he always feels a little guilty if he finishes without you there.
Gale: When she’s alone and thinking about you, Gale touches herself with slow, deliberate strokes while replaying memories of your mouth on her. She prefers using her fingers and sometimes a toy, but she always stays in control of her own pleasure, imagining exactly how she’ll use your face the next time she sees you.
K = Kink (One or more of their kinks)
Billy: Major kinks include choking/breath play, knife play (he loves dragging the blade lightly over your skin or using the handle), light blood play, possessiveness/ownership, and a bit of fear play. He gets off on you being a little scared of him during sex. Degradation mixed with praise (“Such a good little slut for me”).
Sidney: Light praise kink (both giving and receiving), lots of kissing and touching, and a soft dominance where she takes control but checks in constantly. She also likes when you pull her hair or scratch her back — it grounds her.
Tatum: Has a strong praise kink mixed with a bit of bratty behavior — she loves being told she's your good girl, your pretty princess, or that she's taking everything so well, even when she's just laying back and enjoying it. Light teasing and being spoiled rotten turn her on more than anything rough.
Stu: Has a huge thing for degradation and light pain play. He loves calling you his little slut, his whore, his scream queen while he’s choking you lightly or slapping your ass red. He also enjoys knife play in a controlled, teasing way — running the blade along your skin without cutting, just to watch you squirm in fear and arousal.
Dewey: He has a strong service streak—he gets off on the idea of being your good boy, following every direction you give him, and earning your praise. He loves when you guide his head or tell him exactly how to touch you. Light praise, being told he’s making you feel good, and focusing entirely on your orgasms are the things that really get to him.
Gale: Has a strong dominance kink mixed with exhibitionist-lite tendencies — she loves the risk of getting caught in semi-public places like her hotel room with the balcony door open or in her news van during late-night stakeouts. She’s also heavily into power play, facesitting, light choking (giving), and making you beg with that sharp reporter voice of hers.
L = Location (Favorite places to have sex)
Billy: He prefers his house (especially his bedroom or the living room when his dad isn’t home). He also likes risky spots like your room when your parents are downstairs or in a car. Public or semi-public risk turns him on because of the thrill.
Sidney: Mostly in her bedroom when her dad is out, or at your place for more privacy. She’s too cautious for risky public stuff right now — the last thing she wants is more gossip in Woodsboro.
Tatum: Her favorite spots are somewhere comfortable and private — her bedroom (with the door locked and music playing to drown out any noise), your bed, or a cozy couch during a movie night that turns into something more. She doesn't love super risky public places but enjoys the thrill of almost getting caught at a party.
Stu: He’s down for pretty much anywhere, but he especially loves risky spots like his parents’ big empty house during parties or the back of his car. The thrill of possibly getting caught makes him even meaner and more eager to ruin you quickly.
Dewey: He prefers the safety and privacy of home—your shared bed, the couch after a long day, or even the shower where he can kneel and take care of you without worrying about interruptions. The idea of getting caught makes him too anxious, so he sticks to places where he can devote all his attention to you without any risk.
Gale: Her favorite spots are luxurious hotel beds during press tours, the back of her news van, or her high-end apartment with the city lights in the background. She also enjoys the thrill of quick, risky moments in places that feel slightly dangerous given her line of work.
M = Motivation (What turns them on / gets them going)
Billy: Seeing you scared, vulnerable, or completely submissive gets him going instantly. Also, jealousy — if another guy looks at you, he’ll drag you somewhere private and fuck you hard to remind you who you belong to. Adrenaline from danger or horror movies works too.
Sidney: What turns her on most is seeing you happy and turned on because of her. Your moans, the way you say her name, how you reach for her — that’s her biggest motivation. Knowing she’s making you feel safe and desired lights her up.
Tatum: What gets Tatum going is feeling desired and pampered. Compliments, your hands all over her body, and especially when you look at her like you can't wait to taste her. Hearing you beg to please her or tell her how badly you want to make her feel good is instant motivation.
Stu: He gets insanely turned on when you look scared or overwhelmed, and he’ll deliberately push your buttons with dirty talk and teasing until you’re a mess.
Dewey: What motivates Dewey most is your pleasure and the way you look and sound when he’s doing a good job. A soft moan from you, your fingers tightening in his hair, or you telling him “just like that” is enough to make him completely focused and eager. Knowing he’s the one making you feel that good is his biggest turn-on.
Gale: Nothing turns Gale on more than having complete control over your pleasure while you focus entirely on hers. Praise her ambition, tell her how powerful and beautiful she looks when she’s taking what she wants, or show her how desperate you are to taste her — that will have her pulling you down instantly.
N = No (What they absolutely won’t do or dislike)
Billy: He won’t do anything that makes him look weak or submissive for long (he hates giving up control). He also draws the line at anything involving other people watching or joining unless it’s on his terms (he’s very possessive). Extreme pain that actually harms you permanently is a no — he wants you alive and addicted to him.
Sidney: Anything that feels degrading, pain play, or non-consensual roleplay. She also won’t do anything that makes her feel like she’s losing control in a scary way. Trust is everything.
Tatum: Won't do anything that makes her feel like she's the one putting in all the effort — no heavy domming from her side, no long sessions where she has to service you first. She also isn't into anything too painful or degrading; she wants to feel sexy and adored, not used.
Stu: Won’t do anything that feels too vanilla or boring for long. He also draws the line at anything that would actually seriously hurt you in a non-consensual way or involve other people without his control.
Dewey: He’s very open to most things as long as they revolve around your enjoyment, but he absolutely draws the line at anything that could genuinely hurt you or make you uncomfortable. He also wouldn’t enjoy scenarios where he has to be in full control or dominant—he’s much happier when you’re the one setting the pace.
Gale: Will never give up control completely. She refuses to be fully submissive or let anyone tie her up. She also dislikes anything that feels too degrading toward her — she’s a pillow princess who wants worship, not humiliation.
O = Oral (Preferences for giving and receiving oral sex)
Billy: He loves receiving — he’ll tangle his fingers in your hair and guide you, sometimes fucking your mouth. He’s good at giving too, but it’s teasing and dominant. He’ll edge you with his tongue until you’re begging, then pull away just to hear you whine his name.
Sidney: As a service top, she loves giving. She’s gentle at first, then gets more confident the more you react. She pays close attention to what makes your hips buck. Receiving makes her shy at first, but once she relaxes she melts under your mouth.
Tatum: She is obsessed with receiving oral. Tatum will spread her legs, run her fingers through your hair, and guide you exactly where she wants while moaning your name. She's vocal about what feels best and expects you to stay down there until she's satisfied — multiple times if she's in the mood. Giving isn't really her thing; she much prefers being the one getting worshipped.
Stu: He’s obsessed with giving oral thanks to that talented tongue — he’ll eat you out like he’s starving, holding your hips down so you can’t squirm away while he laughs against your pussy. Receiving is just as good; he loves grabbing your hair and face-fucking you until tears run down your cheeks, calling you a good girl for taking it so well.
Dewey: Oral is where Dewey truly shines and feels most in his element. He loves going down on you for as long as you’ll let him, using his tongue and fingers with patient, devoted attention until you’re shaking. He’s equally happy receiving, but he always seems a little surprised and grateful when you go down on him, often trying to pull you back up so he can return the favor.
Gale: Giving isn’t her favorite thing — she’ll do it if she’s in the mood to tease you mercilessly, but she much prefers receiving. When she goes down on you it’s usually slow and calculated, designed to drive you crazy while she stays fully in charge. Receiving, however, is where she shines: she’ll ride your face or spread her legs and tell you exactly how to use your tongue until she’s satisfied.
P = Pace (Fast and rough? Slow and sensual? etc.)
Billy: Usually a steady, sensual but hard rhythm — deep thrusts with a roll of his hips that hits all the right spots. He can switch to fast and rough when he’s feeling especially possessive or angry. He lasts a good while and loves building you up slowly before ruining you.
Sidney: Usually slow and sensual — she wants to savor every second and make it last. She can go harder if you ask, but her default is deep, steady, and focused on building you up.
Tatum: She likes a mix — starting slow and teasing so she can squirm and complain (in the hottest way), then building up to something steady and deep that has her arching off the bed. She hates when it ends too quickly; she wants to be edged just enough to make her whine.
Stu: Usually goes hard and fast, pounding into you with that wild energy, but he can slow down just to torture you — dragging it out with shallow thrusts and mocking you for whining. He switches between ruthless and teasing whenever he feels like it.
Dewey: He naturally goes slow and thorough, savoring every reaction and making sure you’re thoroughly satisfied before thinking about himself. If you want it faster or harder, he’ll happily adjust, but his default is sensual and focused, building you up carefully with steady, loving movements.
Gale: She likes a mix — sometimes she wants it slow and sensual so she can savor every sensation while directing you, other times she gets demanding and rides your face with a faster, more urgent pace when she’s chasing a strong orgasm. She decides the rhythm every single time.
Q = Quickie (Their thoughts on quickies – how often, how they are)
Billy: He’s definitely down for quickies, especially when he’s impatient or needs to release tension. They’re usually rough, fast, and against a wall or in a bathroom — clothes half-on, his hand over your mouth to keep you quiet.
Sidney: She’s not the biggest fan of quickies — she prefers taking her time with you. But if you’re both needy and have limited time, she’ll pull you somewhere private and make sure you cum fast and hard.
Tatum: Isn't the biggest fan of quickies because she loves being spoiled and taking her time. But if she's really worked up (maybe after a close call with danger in Woodsboro), she'll let you push her against the wall or onto the bed for a fast, intense round — as long as you still make her cum first.
Stu: He’s a big fan of quickies, especially when he’s bored or horny in public. He’ll pull you into a bathroom or closet and fuck you fast and mean, covering your mouth so no one hears you, then walk out like nothing happened while you’re still trembling.
Dewey: He isn’t the biggest fan of quickies because he hates rushing through your pleasure, but if you’re needy and pressed for time, he’ll drop to his knees or pull you into his lap without complaint. He’ll make sure you come first even if it means he doesn’t finish himself.
Gale: Loves a well-executed quickie when she’s stressed from work or chasing a story. She’ll pull you into a bathroom, her dressing room, or the back seat and order you onto your knees for a fast, intense session where she comes quickly and then fixes her hair like nothing happened.
R = Risk (Do they like taking risks or public sex?)
Billy: loves risk. Semi-public sex, doing it while someone might walk in, or fucking you right after something dangerous — the adrenaline makes it hotter for him. He thrives on the thrill.
Sidney: Very low risk tolerance right now. She’s already dealing with enough fear in her life; she wants sex to feel like an escape, not something dangerous.
Tatum: A little risk turns her on — the idea of almost getting caught makes her wetter — but she’s too much of a pillow princess to fully enjoy full-on public sex. She prefers the thrill without actually having to move or stay quiet for too long.
Stu: Risk turns him on a lot. He loves the adrenaline of public or semi-public sex, the chance of getting caught, or even incorporating elements from their “hobby” in a fantasy way. The danger makes everything more intense for him.
Dewey: He’s not into risky or public situations at all—his protective nature and years dealing with danger in Woodsboro make him too cautious. He wants you both safe and relaxed so he can focus completely on making you feel good without any distractions or fear.
Gale: She has a calculated taste for risk. The adrenaline of possibly getting caught (especially somewhere related to her job) excites her, but she’s too image-conscious to go fully public. Semi-public thrill with the chance of being seen is perfect for her.
S = Stamina (How much endurance they have / how many rounds)
Billy: Pretty high stamina. He can go for multiple rounds with short breaks, especially when he’s really into it. He’ll wear you out before he’s done.
Sidney: Pretty good for her age — she can go for a couple of rounds, especially if she’s focused on you. She might get tired after, but she’ll still want to hold you.
Tatum: Can handle multiple orgasms if you’re patient and attentive, but after she’s cum a couple times she becomes extra lazy and sensitive, expecting you to gently bring her down with soft kisses and touches.
Stu: Has pretty good stamina — he can go for a while, especially when he’s in that manic mood. He might need a short break, but he’ll use it to tease you mercilessly until he’s ready for round two (or three).
Dewey: He has decent stamina, especially when he’s in service mode and focused on you. He can keep going for a long time with his mouth and hands, happy to give you multiple orgasms before he even thinks about his own release. He might get a little shaky afterward, but he’ll still try to take care of you.
Gale: Can go multiple rounds as long as she’s the one receiving most of the attention. She has excellent endurance when she’s being pleasured, and she’ll keep you between her legs until she’s thoroughly satisfied, sometimes pushing for three or four orgasms before she’s done with you.
T = Toys (Do they like using sex toys?)
Billy: He’s not against them but prefers using his hands, mouth, or cock. If he uses toys, it’s usually a vibrator to tease and edge you mercilessly while he watches.
Sidney: Not using any yet — she’s still exploring with just hands and mouth. She’s curious though, and if you brought something up gently she’d be open to trying.
Tatum: She enjoys a good vibrator pressed against her clit while you fuck her with your fingers or tongue. She loves being spoiled with toys that make her feel even more like the center of attention, but she won’t use them on you — that’s not her role.
Stu: He’s open to toys, especially if he can use them to edge or overstimulate you. A vibrator held against you while he fucks you from behind is one of his favorites — he loves watching you fall apart and beg him to turn it off.
Dewey: He’s open to using toys on you if you enjoy them—he actually likes the idea of combining them with his mouth or fingers to make you feel even better. He doesn’t need them for himself, but he’ll happily let you use whatever you want on him if it turns you on to watch him react.
Gale: She enjoys using a strap-on on you when she wants to feel even more in control, but she prefers receiving with a vibrator or your mouth. She has a small collection of high-end toys she uses on herself or has you use on her while she gives instructions.
U = Unfair (Do they like teasing/edging their partner?)
Billy: Extremely unfair. He loves teasing and edging you until you’re a shaking, begging mess. He’ll deny your orgasm just to hear you cry out his name and promise to be good.
Sidney: She can be a bit of a tease without meaning to — she loves kissing down your body slowly or edging you just a little because she wants to hear you beg softly for her. But she always gives in eventually.
Tatum: Is the queen of teasing you. She’ll spread her legs, look at you with that bratty smirk, and tell you exactly how she wants your mouth while refusing to touch you back. She loves making you desperate to please her.
Stu: He loves edging you for ages, bringing you right to the edge and then stopping with that psychotic laugh, just to hear you whine and curse at him. Teasing is half the fun for him.
Dewey: Isn’t naturally teasing or unfair—he’s too eager to please. However, if you enjoy a little playful edging or making him wait while he focuses on you, he’ll take it beautifully, breathing hard and looking at you with those soft, devoted eyes until you finally let him finish you off.
Gale: Is extremely unfair in the hottest way. She loves edging you, making you work hard for her pleasure while denying you your own until she decides you’ve earned it. She’ll tease you relentlessly with words and light touches, smirking the whole time.
V = Volume (How loud they are – moans, dirty talk, etc.)
Billy: is relatively quiet — low groans, heavy breathing, and dirty talk whispered right against your ear (“Fuck, you feel so good… take it”). He’s not loud, but his voice gets rough and commanding when he’s close.
Sidney: Is relatively quiet — soft moans, breathy gasps, and whispered dirty talk (“Does that feel good?” “I love making you feel like this”). She gets louder when she’s close, especially if you encourage her.
Tatum: She’s loud and unashamed. Tatum moans, whines, and talks dirty — lots of “right there, baby” and “don’t stop” mixed with breathy little gasps. She gets louder the closer she gets, and she doesn’t care who might hear.
Stu: He is loud as hell — moaning, laughing, dirty talking non-stop. He doesn’t hold back at all and encourages (or forces) you to be loud too so he can hear every sound you make.
Dewey: He’s relatively quiet, mostly soft groans, heavy breathing, and occasional whimpers when you praise him or touch him just right. He loves hearing you, though, and the sounds you make are what really get him going. You’ll mostly hear him murmuring your name and little praises against your skin.
Gale: She’s vocal but in a controlled way — lots of breathy moans, sharp commands, and low, husky dirty talk. When she comes she lets out satisfied gasps and your name mixed with praises like “good girl” or “just like that, don’t you dare stop.”
W = Wild card (A random/extra headcanon)
Billy: He sometimes roleplays horror movie scenarios with you — pretending he’s the killer and you’re the final girl who “surrenders” to him. The mask might make an appearance in the bedroom.
Sidney: Sometimes after sex she gets a little emotional and needs to be held. The vulnerability of being with you (someone who makes her feel safe) can bring up old feelings, but she trusts you enough to let you see that side of her.
Tatum: Sometimes after a really good orgasm she gets clingy and affectionate, pulling you on top of her so she can kiss you lazily while her body is still buzzing. She’ll whisper how much she loves being yours, but only when she’s fully satisfied and floating.
Stu: Sometimes Stu will pin you down and make you watch horror movies while he fingers you, whispering along with the screams on screen and comparing them to the noises you make for him. It’s his twisted way of mixing his two favorite things.
Dewey: Sometimes after a particularly stressful day at the station, Dewey just wants to come home, bury his face between your thighs, and stay there until all the tension melts away. He finds it incredibly grounding and comforting to lose himself in pleasing you like that—no pressure, no expectations, just you.
Gale: Sometimes likes to roleplay a version of her reporter persona during sex — interviewing you about how good you’re making her feel while you’re buried between her thighs, or pretending you’re a source she’s “interrogating” with pleasure until you give her exactly what she wants.
X = X-ray (What's going on underneath those clothes)
Billy: is above average in length and girth, with a slight upward curve that hits your g-spot perfectly. He’s well-groomed and knows exactly how to use it. When hard, it’s thick and veiny, and he loves making you feel every inch.
Sidney: Sidney has a soft, feminine body — perky nippkes she’s a little self-conscious about but you adore, smooth skin, and strong legs from walking everywhere in town. Her pussy is pretty and sensitive; she gets very wet when she’s really into it.
Tatum: Has a gorgeous, curvy body with perky breasts, a tiny waist, and that famous round ass she’s so proud of. Her pussy is pretty and always perfectly groomed, getting slick and swollen when she’s turned on. She knows she looks incredible naked and expects you to stare.
Stu: Is long and pretty thick (8.3 inch) , with a slight upward curve that hits all the right spots when he’s deep inside you. He knows exactly how to use it to make you see stars, and he’s not shy about showing off.
Dewey: Is a solid, boyishly handsome guy with a slightly rugged build from years on the force. He’s nicely sized (6.1) nothing intimidating, but thick enough to feel satisfying—and he keeps himself clean and well-groomed. When he’s hard and eager to please you, there’s a slight flush across his chest and cheeks that makes him look even more endearing.
Gale: Is sleek and glamorous even naked. She has a toned body from years of staying camera-ready, with soft, full breasts and smooth skin. Her pussy is always perfectly groomed, sensitive, and gets incredibly wet when she’s really turned on. She knows exactly how good she looks and uses it to her advantage.
Y = Yearning (How high is their sex drive? How do they handle desire?)
Billy: His sex drive is high, especially when he’s obsessed with you. He can get needy and possessive fast. If he wants you, he’ll find a way to have you — even if it means sneaking into your room at night.
Sidney: Her sex drive is moderate — trauma has made her cautious, but being with you awakens a lot of desire. Once she feels safe, she yearns for you constantly and loves spending lazy afternoons making out and touching.
Tatum: Her sex drive is high when she feels desired. She’ll moan to you on phone calls or whisper dirty things in your ear at parties just to get you worked up so you’ll take her home and worship her properly.
Stu: His sex drive is high and impulsive. When he wants you, he wants you right then — he’ll text you filthy things or show up at your place unannounced, already hard and ready to be mean.
Dewey: His sex drive is pretty steady, but it spikes when he sees you happy or when you give him that certain look that says you want him. He doesn’t push for it often because he’d rather wait for you to initiate or ask, but once you do, he’s completely devoted and ready to spend however long you want.
Gale: Her sex drive is high when she’s stressed or riding the adrenaline of a big story. She doesn’t get needy often, but when she does she’ll text you short, commanding messages like “Come over. Now.” and expect you to drop everything to take care of her.
Z = Zzz (What they’re like after sex – do they fall asleep right away, want to cuddle, etc.?)
Billy: After sex, he usually stays awake for a while, watching you fall asleep or smoking a cigarette. He might pull you close and hold you possessively, but he doesn’t pass out immediately. Sometimes he leaves soon after if he has “things to do.”
Sidney: She usually stays awake a while after, holding you and making sure you’re okay. She falls asleep last, curled around you protectively, often with her head on your chest or your lips brushing her skin.
Tatum: After sex, Tatum turns into a sleepy, satisfied kitten. She curls up against you, demands you hold her, and usually falls asleep quickly with a little smirk on her face, knowing she got exactly what she wanted.
Stu: Afterward, Stu usually crashes hard but not before pulling you close in a loose, possessive hold. He might mumble something goofy or teasing as he drifts off, keeping one arm draped over you like he’s claiming you even in his sleep.
Dewey: Afterward, Dewey gets sleepy fast, especially if he’s spent a long time focusing on you. He’ll pull you into his arms, tuck your head under his chin, and fall asleep with a soft, content smile, one hand still gently stroking your back. He always makes sure you’re comfortable and safe before drifting off.
Gale: After she’s come hard, Gale likes to pull you up against her body and drift off while holding you close. She’ll murmur a few sleepy praises and keep one arm draped possessively over you. She falls asleep fairly quickly once she’s satisfied, but she wakes up first and expects morning cuddles before she gets back to her ambitious day.
