continued with @thestanfordmoose, from here
Chuck was used to the ‘college dropout, one of the guys’ persona he’d perfected during his time on earth. It basically wasn’t a persona anymore – he was that guy. He felt like that guy more than he felt like God, these days. It was like a suit that fit pretty well, and he liked how it looked and how it felt, and he liked walking around as this guy. Metatron had said he’d gone full method, and maybe that was true, but so what? He’d done the whole ‘Alpha and Omega, First and the Last’ thing for literally thousands of years. He didn’t wanna be that dramatic anymore. He just wanted to… chill. He was done with the ‘Lord of Hosts’ schtick. Besides, he was stuck in this world, so he had to go along to get along, for his own freaking sanity.
But there was one guy who he knew who always struggled with God being Carver Edlund, and that was Sam Winchester. He wanted the religiosity, the piety, the holy nine yards. He wanted to deify Chuck in a way that he was really sick of being deified. Sure, he was the creator of… well, everything, but he didn’t want to be idolised anymore. He wanted to be the Winchester’s buddy, their go-to guy, their friend who slummed around in boxers and ate takeout and watched porn on Dean’s computer, who also happened to be God. It was the only way he was gonna keep them on-side, if they saw him as their pal. And that was what Sam needed. His obsession with being holy and worthy and spiritually clean was really unhealthy. It had been a necessary evil for his whole ‘demon blood’ arc, and it had cropped up later during the trials of Hell, but Chuck really wished the kid would get over it now. He’d hung out with God in the bunker, seen him in a t-shirt and boxer shorts, eating cold Chinese food. You couldn’t get further from holiness than that, right?
So, he told Sam he wanted to talk because he did. Just talk. No appearing in a heavenly flash of light, no booming voice from the sky calling Sam his ‘son’. None of that. He just wanted to talk. Sam said that he’d prayed, and Chuck sighed. “Yeah, I know you did,” he said, wearily. “I heard.” He shoved his hands into his pockets and gave Sam a long-suffering smile. He’d heard all of it – Sam’s faith paralleled the faith of the saints from biblical times, David writing the psalms. How long, O Lord? Will you forget me forever? Everything was so emotive and passionate and the end of the freaking world.
He loved Sam – of course he did – but he didn’t know what Sam wanted from him. Dean was easy – he wanted Chuck to be an absentee father, the fall guy, so he could get pissed and hate him for every single thing that went wrong in his life, XTC’s ‘Dear God’ style. But Sam? Sam wanted him to be a Father, sure. He wanted him to be his supporter, to validate him. But he wanted something else. Something Chuck couldn’t give because he didn’t even think it existed. Some sort of holy anointing, divine cleansing… thing. If that had ever existed, he’d quit doing it hundreds of years ago. Humanity just didn’t go in for stuff like that anymore – Sam was about two thousands years late. The vial in the Basilica of the Holy Blood was just a bottle with a piece of cloth in it, the Shroud of Turin was just a shroud. There was no hallowed mystery to anything anymore. Chuck couldn’t give Sam what he wanted, so he gave him what he needed instead, even if Sam couldn’t see it was what he needed, like a good father should.
“I didn’t answer your prayers with words, Sam,” he said. “But I was always rooting for you guys. You know that. I’ve told you.” He didn’t say anything for a few seconds, but he knew he had to bring up Dean. “I guess you know your brother’s not my number one fan right now, huh?” he asked, conversationally, as if it didn’t piss him off every freaking day. “But you and me, we’re still good, right?” It was a question, because he didn’t want to tell Sam that they were good, but he figured he knew the answer. Sam couldn’t hold a grudge against God. It was literally impossible for him. They would always be good.
Sam understood his own hypocrisy. How, just like he’d beseeched, God stood on sacred ground and played King of You. There was no parting of the tides or “and the earth opened her mouth wide and swallowed him whole”, even when Sam wavered and dreamt of being consumed. Chuck’s betrayal wasn’t done in technicolor, but it was the first and only time he had felt like a God. It was there, in the graveyard as he watched his son’s eye ignite (they always die in ash and brimstone), Sam realized that this was exactly what he’d asked for. He wanted Chuck to step out of his lackluster ‘tude, the apathy which disgusted Sam in all the same ways he envied it, and to take up his role as a deity.
Instead of Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest. Matthew 11:28, Chuck was God the Conspirator; and the hunter had a split second to reconcile his idea of faith with the one killing his kid. He zeroed in on the grass stains crisscrossing Jack’s back, muddying the sweatshirt with licks and kisses of Earth, as if a promise to ground him - he’s part human, too. Jack flops helplessly, likely unawares as the same grace that has resurrected him and his brother and Castiel and - everyone, everyone, it made everyone - corrupts and burns and mutilates a body, a child, and Sam’s sense of self all in one ‘snap.’ The callousness of the gesture - look how easy it is for me to hurt you - was never lost on him. A double entendre wearing cheap loafers and moth-bitten jeans.
He would be his own advocate.
Within those precious few breaths, Sam decided he was tired of having his autonomy taken from him. Inhale; I wanted you to love me. Exhale; I was good. Inhale; you’re hoping he stay blind. Exhale; I can see. Inhale; and he has a gun in his hand and he’s firing it before he can register the hilt or remember the consequences. There is one thought, and only one, as he takes aim and shoots: ‘If only the Truth made you holy.’
Human instinct. That’s what he acted on. Unbridled anger; the feeling of being used like the rag beside a kitchen sink, reliable and coveted but somehow also worthless and covered in grime. Humanity is something Chuck can never mimic, a creation gone awry, and it was their rapture.
Blood sluggishly leaked from his shoulder like sewage from a rusted pipeline, and before Sam would stop it, he found himself revered because he’d been touched by God.
He doesn’t bleed like Christ, but his wound matches Chuck’s and he’s a stigmatic and he’s blessed and do you smell roses?
Let him bleed out like Christ on the cross. Leave bloodied footprints on the grimy motel carpet so Dean can see where he’s walked and trace his footsteps after he’s redeemed. Let him wash Sam’s hair with a red solo cup, filling it in the sink and tipping it back over “you sure you don’t want me to cut it for you?” to rinse away the clumps of dried soot and blood that have tangled in the strands, caking them together and giving him his Crown. He’ll smell floral and for awhile, Dean will associate roses with his brother’s death, but it’ll be okay because Sam will have been saved.
He understood his dichotomy and it made him ill everyday. Every time Dean scolded him or raged against Chuck, Sam wished he didn’t crave heaven’s pity.
“I didn’t need a cheerleader,” He replies meekly. Somehow feeling inferior all over again, like he isn’t also the man who shot God. And it’s true, because that isn’t what Sam needed or wanted. He didn’t care if Chuck fist bumped every time Sam so much as found a case or banged a girl. “I needed to you hear me. To help. Where have you been?”
The fury, the questioning, fades quickly and Sam is just a lost kid again. He nods, unable or unwilling or undeserving to hold a grudge against Chuck. He envisions himself reaching out desperately, chubby hands grabbing, clawing, aching. “Yeah, yeah--of course. No, I get it. I mean, I’m mad, but you-we---”
Sam looks toward his palms with a morbid disappointment, unmarred flesh, supple and pink and whole.