Toldos: So What Color is Your Gallbladder?
Story from the Talmud When Rabbi Yosi ben Kisma became ill, Rabbi Chanina went to visit him. Rabbi Yosi spoke strongly to his student: "Chanina, my brother, don't you realize that it is a heavenly decree that these people, the Romans, are allowed to rule over us? They are the same people who destroyed Temple, burned the Sanctuary, killed so many holy, pious people and destroyed everything good -- and they still exist! Yet I have heard it said that you sit and teach Torah publicly in huge assemblies while holding a Torah scroll in your arms."
Rabbi Chanina answered, "Heaven will have mercy on me."
Rabbi Yosi answered sharply: "I am telling you that your defiance is common knowledge and you answer me that Heaven will have mercy!? I would not be surprised if you are burned alive together with the Torah."
When Rabbi Chanina heard his rebbe's prediction of his death as a martyr, he knew immediately that it was true. Instead of panicking, he asked, "Rebbe, what will be my portion in the World to Come?"
"Have you ever in your life done a good deed ?"
"Yes. Once I prepared two purses of money for Purim. One was for the Purim meal, and the other contained money to be given to the poor, so that they, too, might enjoy a festive Purim meal. The two purses got mixed up and I didn't know which purse was for what purpose. So I took all the money I had in both purses -- all the money I had -- and gave it away to the poor."
When Rabbi Yosi heard about this deed he said, "If so, I wish that my portion would be as your portion, and that your fate be mine. "
This story brings up a number of perplexing queries. Why would Reb Yosei discourage Reb Chananya from spreading Torah?
How could Reb Chananya think that he wouldnāt get Olam Haba?
And why did this act of Tzedaka confirm his chances of the World to Come?
To help us understand, the Alter RebbeĀ will explore two different physiological features and their implications on the human personality.
Mara shchora = black bile - People born with a black bile tend to be more introverted, serious, have long attention spans, love to learn, focused, prone to stinginess, donāt like to give to others because that means they have to give over themselves.
Mara levona = white bile - Those born with white biles are more expressive people, spontaneous, love to give, could be oversharers, unfocused, like to have fun, may be considered āADD.ā
But now we have an issue, because when every person goes up to the heavens, heāll be asked by the beis din shel maāaleh: āDid you set time for Torah study?ā But if the mara schora enjoys learning, then heās at a tremendous advantage!
Everything is relative Hashem doesnāt judge us like that, because itās totally unfair. Instead, half hour of learning for the mara levona can be worth more than two hours of the mara shchoraās scholarship.
Back to our story Reb Chanina asked Reb Yosi if heād get Olam Haba because, though he spread Torah, he didnāt know where his actions are coming from. Is he like a philosopher who just learns because heās genetically inclined to deep, complicated subjects? Or is he learning just because Hashem told him to?
So R. Yosi asked him if he can tell him something he did that would reveal his true nature.
When R. Chanina said the story about having two purses of money and giving both to tzedaka, R. Yosi realized that it was R. Chaninaās nature to give freely, which is a characteristic of the mara levona.
R. Yosi then said, "If so, I wish that my portion would be as your portion, and that your fate be mine,ā because he knew that R. Chanina learned all this Torah despite the fact that his mara levona nature was less inclined to it.
Itās not about how far you are but how far youāve come Itās not about what you do but how much effort you put into it. Even R. Chanina was concerned about this! If itās in your nature to enjoy a certain mitzvah, then thatās your clue to invest even more of yourself into it, so that youāre doing it totally for G-d.
The Arizal says that people are born with different battles. Hashem judges us based on our efforts, not necessarily our results.
Parsha Q: Why did Yitzchak want to give the brachos to Esav? A: Yitzchak knew that Esav was born a rasha, which means his nature wasnāt his fault. Yitzchak wanted to give him the weapons to battle his challenge. This blessing was the responsibility and power of Torah and Mitzvos.
Yitzchakās mistake was that he thought that Yakov was so perfect, he wouldnāt need Torah. Yet Esav was so evil, he wouldāve actually used Torah for the bad. (Give a druggie 10,000 dollars and see if he buys bread and milk with the cashā¦) Instead, Yitzchak gave the brachos to Yakov in order for him to help refine Esav, because Yakov needed the Torah if he wanted to deal with the world and elevate Esav.
We are all born with specific natures, which means weāre inclined to certain actions over others. Even if we desire to do something good - like give tzedaka - we must push ourselves to be sure that this mitzvah isnāt just coming from our natural tendencies. Hashem judges us in the most refined and sensitive way, and doesnāt compare our successes to those of others. Above all else, heĀ wants to see us try.











