hi there, this is gonna be kinda rambly but i hope it makes sense. idk if you've been in this position before, but you're like. a Cool Internet Trans Uncle, so i hope it's okay to ask for advice anyways. i'm a 19 year old trans guy (or at least heavily guy-adjacent), and i've been wanting to go on hrt since i was 14, but i haven't been able to due to bullshit laws and then bullshit finances. but all those years have given me time to overthink it (like, way overthink it) and i guess i'm really worried that it's... not gonna work for me? or something? like, right now i'm seen as Young Woman (Fairly Pretty), and i'd give just about anything to be seen as Young Man (Fairly Handsome), but i'm scared that going on hrt will end up with me being seen as Young Adult Who's Not A Man But Also Who Is Far Away Enough From Cis Womanhood To Abuse. which would just result in dysphoria AND people treating me badly, which would be even worse than where i am right now. i guess the fear is that there'd be enough changes to take me away from safety but not enough to cause any comfort or joy? like, what if i'm just permanently fucked? i can't exactly take my skeleton back in and ask for a do-over. so yeah. like i said, this is rambly, but i'm hoping that you or your other followers might have some advice. i hope that you and your spouse and your cats are doing well and having a good day :)
Lemme break down some thoughts:
HRT has profound mental effects for a lot of us that is separate from, "I like what I see in the mirror". My brain is calmer on T and I am overall much more emotionally regulated. This is a huge, huge benefit for me and 100% internal.
You are going to get clocked throughout your life. It will happen a lot as you begin transition and it will happen in surprising ways when you think you pass. It's a thing we have to always be prepared for.
On HRT, you will more likely be seen as teenage boy than anything else. This may last years.
If you are white, thin, and/or able-bodied, you are still going to be invisible to a lot of people.
Cis-passing is not a guarantee against transphobic violence. You may be safer from random street violence, but you are still subject to violence from the State. All bets are off once you are outed and paperwork trails are everywhere. Passing privilege is extremely easily revoked.
Be very aware how much the desire to look conventionally attractive in a cis-passing way is influencing you. Be ok with the idea of just being Some Guy. Be especially ok with looking like some of the men in your family. And never equate your value with beauty. Even if you achieve it, it's fleeting.
If you are worried about safety, start mitigating that now. We all have to do risk calculus every time we leave the house. Look to community as your safety net. Be very picky about who you choose to bring into your life. And of course, if you have the means, look for work and a home in progressive areas and always have a Plan B in case you lose your job or housing.
A lot of cis people honestly do not give a shit in either direction about trans people. There is some safety in that ambivalence.
You can always stop HRT and even detransition. Some effects are permanent, but if trans women can voice train and laser their beards, so can you.
Make more friends with visibly queer trans/nonbinary/gnc people. Consume more queer art. go to queer meetups and other events. Recalibrate your brain to celebrate visible transness & gender fuckery, instead of seeing it primarily as a threat to your safety.
I think it's all worth it. <3