been thinking about porn game mechanics lately. specifically how the physical sex of a protagonist greatly impacts what you're able to do and the sort of story you can tell. obviously you can do whatever you want forever, when i say "can" i mean "while keeping it to my tastes and/or attracting a wider audience" and the "you" in the sentence is really "me". ok? i'm putting this under a cut because it's long stream of conscious rambling. thinking out loud.
it's the basic sex game conundrum of punishment/reward. say we're playing a theoretical sex castlevania. you've got enemies on the map, and you've got bosses. where do you put the sex?
the natural answer is "when you lose/get too damaged" because everyone loves a sexy game over. and maybe when you beat a boss you get rewarded with a sexy cutscene. there ought to be sex as a reward, you don't want to Only reward playing the game poorly.
so what does that mean if your protagonist is a cis man with a cock? or a cis woman with a pussy? how does the story and monster design change if you're expecting a dude to get beaten and fucked vs a lady? do you make it a gay sex game, with the guy getting it up the ass? or do lady enemies all ride him when they catch him? i hear you reaching to type "both" but then what is your story saying about sex, domination, and humiliation? one of those sex acts is more "humiliating" than the other, more understood to be a punishment.
which is part of the challenge with the other side, what if your protagonist has a pussy? how do you differentiate between the sex as punishment and the sex as reward/triumph when penetration is your main option? what sort of story can you tell? what kind of message may you end up sending? "taylor you can just do other sex acts" does an image of fingering or cunnilingus feel like more of a Video Game Reward than an image of PIV? be honest. "give them a strap on/magic cock" we're back to Saying Things about penetration and dominance and humiliation and that needs to be given consideration. and also come on that's lame.
if a pussy protagonist is getting fucked five times by enemies on the way to the boss, once they've defeated him, what is the game Saying if your reward is to put his cock inside you? what does it mean for your protagonist and their story goals and motivations? how does one inform the other and the narrative choices you can make?
as with any narrative you've always got to be asking yourself why you're making certain choices. what point are you trying to make, why are you telling this story via sex game? in this subgenre of sex game? why is it a metroidvania, a roguelike, a dungeon crawler? how do the game mechanics and larger narrative support and justify each other?
it's much to think about. i imagine it's why so many sex games with pussy protagonists are about succubi, it's an easy justification for why sex as punishment and sex as reward look the same. but it's also the only way a lot of game devs can imagine a female protagonist wanting to go on a sex adventure where she has any agency--it's a biological imperative. they can't imagine sex being a reward for a woman in any other way. sad.
it's relevant to regular writing too, tbh. like cadogan. if he defeated romick in a fight, riding his cock isn't very different from if he lost. sure, romick could be tied up and not in control, and that's kinda humiliating, but he's still putting his cock and cum inside cadogan, the thing he'd have wanted to do anyway. at the end of the day it's not much of a punishment. (and i am talking purely in the pornographic, narrative sense, yes i know "you got to have sex, what are you upset about" is a real problem with SA). this is why cadogan is functionally ace as a character--this is how he would think of it. i beat this man, why would i reward him with my pussy? madog, you fuck him.
i wasn't really building to any particular point so much as just thinking out loud. how do you make sex a reward and a punishment in a video game or story, while keeping it interesting, sexy, and thematically cohesive. our greatest scientists are working on it