To all my RDR2 fans put there, stop writing modern AUs with Thanksgiving Day and including Charles. Thanksgiving is NOT a positive holiday, and it’s quite literally a day for MOURNING for many Indigenous peoples. Stop pretending like it’s…
1. The holiday is something positive, and not celebrating a genocide.
2. That just because it is a modern au that societal issues vanish. Indigenous peoples are still being oppressed, murdered, kidnapped, sa’d.
Your whole understanding of Charles’ character went over your head if you think he would celebrate a holiday of colonization.
In truth, massacres, disease and American Indian tribal politics are what shaped the Pilgrim-Indian alliance at the root of the holiday













