If any of you knew me in the 4th grade, you knew that I was INSUFFERABLE about Batman. Well, after seeing Matt Reeves’ The Batman, 4th grade Adam is back…. with a VENGEANCE.
Compared to a lot of other superhero movie directors, it feels like Matt Reeves lives and breathes Batman comics. Hell, it feels like me and him have gone on the same damn Reddit threads. The Batman is first and foremost a film focused on Batman’s detective work, which is something the fans have been begging for decades. Additionally, The Batman is directly inspired from my favorite Batman story, The Long Halloween, but also notably takes cues from stories like Zero Year, Year One, Earth One, White Knight, and others. Unlike Nolan, Reeves isn’t afraid to sprinkle in a variety of Easter eggs and cheeky references into the script. There are so many moments where he didn’t need to include an awesome reference, but damn well says “what if I did it anyways?” While Batman movies aren’t nearly as embarrassed of their roots as the MCU is, it’s nice to see a film that boldly wears its love for the comics on its sleeve.
Speaking of bold, The Batman sets itself apart from a lot of other superhero movies by taking a lot of risks. The first risk here is effort and ambition. Instead of being formulaic, cheesy, and studio-controlled, it feels like Reeves had a lot more of artistic freedom in making it. For the first 30 minutes or so, I was kind of star struck because it felt like a…real? movie instead of a superhero movie. I think I felt that because it has more of a soul behind it, due to fantastic visuals, directing, and tone. The Batman doesn’t look like a lot of superhero movies and it makes you think “damn, why DON’T superhero movies look like this?” There’s a lot of inventive use of color and lighting, which succeed where the past few Avengers movies failed in making a compelling argument for having a whole lot of orange and grey in a genre whose source material is defined by loud and popping colors. Sometimes it feels like Matt Reeves is flexing on us in some scenes, especially with shots like the upside down shot of Batman walking away from an explosion shown in the trailers, but also the entire opening sequence that feels like something from a horror movie. While I wish the rest of the movie had more parts like this, I’m still glad it was included. Finally, Matt Reeves’ biggest flex is getting mainstream audiences to sit through a three-hour movie. I can confirm that while the runtime can occasionally be felt, it really pulls it off by feeling like you’re bingewatching a great TV show instead of watching an exceedingly long movie. I think this can mainly be attributed to its noir tone. While long, the film remains consistently compelling and barely stops running once it’s hit the ground. Much of its runtime is dedicated towards Bruce, Gordon, and Selina looking through every lead in a complex case and it’s such a delight to watch. Being such a well-made film, it’s topped off with a fantastic orchestral score that’s a lot more New Hollywood than 21st century superhero schlock.
Bringing up The Batman’s detective movie tone reminds me of some online discourse from before the film came out accusing it of being just another “dark and gritty” Batman movie, which to this I say: kinda?? Yes, The Batman can be quite dark, but that sure as hell doesn’t mean it’s realistic and definitely doesn’t mean it can’t be campy and funny. It’s unbelievably over the top and the fact that so many characters take this over-the-topness on its face value leads to a lot of laughs. There’s plenty of moments that feel like they’d show up in a Burton or Schumacher movie, but feel organic rather than corny. Speaking of camp, one of the funniest characters is Colin Farrell, masked by god knows how many prosthetics as The Penguin. Instead of the curmudgeon with a top hat, monocle, and umbrella we’re used to, we get something far more akin to Paulie Walnuts from The Sopranos, yet equally ridiculous. Unlike a lot of other designated comic relief characters (looking at you, Drax the Destroyer) Farrell’s lines don’t feel out of place, he’s just being the obnoxious and oafish Mafioso you’d expect from Gotham City. For a while now I’ve believed that the only city in America that matches Gotham City’s energy is Philadelphia, and Farrell’s Penguin isn’t a Florida Man, he’s a Philly Man. While The Batman is a dark and relatively serious movie, it’s also weird and funny enough to escape the trappings of being yet another insufferably “dark, gritty, and realistic” superhero film. It allows itself to balance the dark and camp, feeling much more like a Batman film than Nolan’s movies ever did.
The creative risks are what make The Batman great, but not all of them pan out. One massive surprise was how much I didn’t enjoy Robert Pattinson’s performance as Batman despite him being one of my favorite current actors. The Batman we get in The Batman is clearly at a very early stage, hilariously inexperienced, and perpetually gloomy. He hasn’t really formed the playboy “Bruce Wayne” persona we all know and love, and instead remains this tortured loner that only knows how to speak through his fists. Very reminiscent of the character in Frank Miller’s Batman: Year One, this Beta Test Batman still trying to figure out both sides of his identity has a lot of potential but didn’t work for me in two ways. First of all, is Pattinsons’ line delivery. I don’t know if it was Pattinson’s or Reeves’ choice to do so, but for some reason Batman’s undeveloped and depressed demeanor expresses itself by straight up him whispering 90% of his dialogue. I’m a massive fan of Kevin Conroy’s voice acting as Batman in nearly every non live action iteration of the character, and while I understand this portrayal is Batman clearly in Early Access Mode, I wish Pattinson exhibited a hint of the charisma Conroy imbued in the character. Instead we get a mumblecore Batman, so awkward that it makes the romance between him and Catwoman a bit too hard to believe. I wasn’t kidding when I said he talks mostly with his fists, because there’s no way people can hear him when he’s nervously mumbling about vengeance like he’s a school shooter. Secondly, as interesting as our woefully green Batman is, anything resembling internal character development feels slept on to make room for massive plot dynamics until the film’s climax. This connects to a larger issue with the film, which is that it has a LOT to juggle, ranging from its convoluted plot to balancing a large variety of exciting characters and themes. A lot of this is surprisingly well-managed, which I attribute to its much-needed three-hour runtime. That being said, its detective-oriented plot sometimes works to its detriment, where it’ll get so engrossed in one of the nooks and crannies of its mystery that it’ll feel like they completely forgot about the overarching plot. While most of the themes are nicely explored and ironed out, its attempts to introduce some political ideas don’t always pan out. Some topics, like the very explicit awkwardness that Bruce Wayne is in the same social circles as the corrupt elites he’s trying to purge, strike hard, while others, like exploring the effectiveness of reforming the city’s corruption, just kind of sit there and feel tacked on.
Like Dune, the last movie I had absurd amounts of hype for, The Batman’s cast is stacked with premium talent, and unlike Dune, very little of them feel wasted in this movie. I already described my thoughts on Battinson and Colin Farrell and can confirm that Kravitz, Turturro, and Wright absolutely kill it playing iconic and unforgettable versions of their characters. One of the biggest highlights of the film is Batman and (not-yet commissioner) Gordon’s relationship, portraying them as genuine friends. While Nolan’s films might show Gordon and Batman as two tragic heroes from different backgrounds developing a mutual trust to save the city, Pattinson and Wright as Batman and Gordon are simply….. guys being dudes. Wright adds a lot of subtle quirks to Gordon that makes him and Batman seem more like close friends than partners at work, creating a feeling of genuine intimacy in their relationship. Speaking of intimacy, Zoe Kravitz is near-perfectly cast as Catwoman. She nails the pure cool and simmering rage of the character like no other. Even though her badass and cunning Catwoman doesn’t feel like the best romance match for Pattinson’s depressed and shy Batman (I’d actually argue the film has a love triangle with Bruce trying to choose between Gordon and Selina), their screen chemistry is great. It seems like Matt Reeves took note of the constant criticism that superhero movies are “sexless,” lacking in intimacy, sexuality, and chemistry, and took it the opposite direction. Pattinson and Kravitz look like they studied at the “Oscar Isaac school of whoring” because their onscreen chemistry was so tight that when they finally kissed someone in my theater yelled “FINALLY!” John Turturro, playing Gotham mob kingpin Carmine Falcone, is a LOT more prominent in the film than I expected, absolutely embodying the slime in Gotham’s soul that existed long before the rise of its costumed crazies. Finally, Paul Dano’s performance as The Riddler, the film’s main villain, didn’t really do it for me. It felt a bit too inconsistent and rough on the edges for me and the character’s presence over the plot felt a lot more effective than Dano actually showing up in costume. That being said, I still respect how cool and unique the creative decisions that shaped this interpretation of the character were.
Overall The Batman blows away the competition in terms of how stylistic, unafraid of the source material, and ruthlessly unique it is. It’s not perfect, but definitely my favorite superhero movie since, idk, Spider-Verse or Logan. 9 stars out of 10.