On the “Edgy Tumblr Musical” Culture...
Ok, so there’s something that’s been on my mind for quite a while, and that’s the culture and reactive counter-culture of the “Edgy Gen Z Musicals”, “Edgy Tumblr Musicals”, or simply, “Tumblr Musicals”.
The culture on this website of people obsessing over just a small slice of contemporary musical theatre and then labeling themselves a “theatre nerd uwu” can get incredibly annoying, especially to career actors and people who want to really talk theatre and get responses like, “owo Heathers is the best musical sry”, or, “Connor my trash son”. It’s a frustrating and often easily-toxic culture.
But! You know what’s also bad? The holier-than-thou attitude that comes from putting down people who are into the Tumblr Musicals. What do you get out of that? Just because someone hasn’t been introduced to classical theatre yet doesn’t make them “cringey” or “a poser” or “a fake fan”.
Both attitudes are gross and it always saddens me to see people arguing when really, at their core, both parties are devoted to the performing arts, whether that’s acting or directing professionally, running tech at their highschool, or just listening to cast recordings and getting lost in the music.
So here are your reminders:
1. There’s more to musical theatre than Hamilton, Heathers, DEH and BMC (and more to theatre than musicals, but that’s for another time)
2. People are allowed to like things that are popular? Sorry if that angers you??
3. If you try to talk theatre with someone and it turns out they’re only familiar with a handful of contemporary musicals and their favorite is Falsettos, instead of laughing at them or calling them a fake fan, why not introduce them to a classic, or a little-known off broadway gem, or something from the 50s with a completely different sound than they’re used to?
4. Hamilton is a piece of historical fiction based very heavily on real people. Shipping Alexander Hamilton with Thomas Jefferson…isn’t classy.
5. Theatre is subjective. Not everyone is going to know or like all the same things you do and that’s ok.
6. All that being said, if I hear about one more person romanticizing J.D. from Heathers, I will steal their kneecaps and delete their blog.