So, I want to say something about Tales From '85...
I did not hate it, which surprised me, but there are certain choices which make absolutely no sense to me. Many logic holes where already pointed out countless times before and I do agree that I disliked the whole Byler fight thing they included.
At first I thought I was bothered by what people already referenced before me: that it contradicts the main show, when Nikki points out that Mike treats Will like something broken, while it was a huge plot point of season 2 that Mike is the only one who doesn't treat Will as fragile, because then that line about Mike telling Nikki that Will is the bravest person he knows, almost felt like they were honouring that.
Then I thought it must be Nikki, that makes me mad, then. It feels like we are now post season 2, so we got Lumax, we got Mike and El, they didn't have a clue where to put Will. Why didn't they just team-up Dustin and Will, you ask? I absolutely don't know, especially because they tend to give Dustin so many solo missions?! Like it's not enough that the group is so split up in the later seasons...
And then I knew what my problem is.
Micheal. Wheeler.
Because whatever went down in the writing room... This shit cannot be canon.
Ok, so characterization in Tales? Not the best work, they are all flat versions of the true characters. They had the nerve to make Dustin kinda dumb? Lucas is just jokes although I would say the pumpkin Lumax scene is one of the better ones of the show. They made that whole annoying Hopper and Jane plot which we will see again in season 3 and also the Max and Jane friendship is kinda... Too fast? Because I had the feeling in season 3 that this was the point of them really getting to know each other while in Tales they already feel close.
And i don't know that they did to Will😭 Like he is so sassy...
But okay it is a cartoon, I can forgive that they cartooned down the complex characters to a bit more simple versions but then we have Mike.
He is just ooc. The Byler fight pisses me off and Nikki too, but in the way how Mike is treating Will and Nikki. Because what is Mike known for?
Mike is nice! Mike approached Will in Kindergarten on the swings because he was lonely! Mike is the person El firms a close bond with first because he is kind to her!
Mike would never yell at Will so close after season 2 end, like he did in that fight scene. The whole discussion wouldn't even happen because Mike is not mean like that!
And the most important part is how Mike treats Nikki! You're telling me, Mike Wheeler would be like that to the new kid with no friends, who is also a nerd?
There is a person Mike was that mean to tho:
...yeah right. So basically we have a parallel between Tales Mike and season 2 Mike hating on the new kid. Who invited Max to Halloween? Why did you invite Nikki to DnD?!
See, he was an asshole in season 2, right, so his behaviour in Tales from '85 actually makes sense, Mike is just an asshole, I mean, look at the van scene-
NO!
Because why was Mike behaving like that in season 2? Because he was grieving El!!!
It is pointed out in the show as atypical that Mike is failing classes, mean to Max, withdrawing from anyone because he just watched El die! (And still he never yelled at Will like that!)
So, maybe the writers were lazy and didn't do their homework.
Or maybe we are going back to season 2 characterisation because Mike is grieving again
Because they did confirm that the cartoon is canon. There are people theorising that we are actually seeing a campaign or camazotz.
So maybe it is canon but in a sense of post season 5. Maybe someone (cough Will) created that world from 85 and placed our characters in it, with everyone getting to live. It would explain why Mike is behaving that anxious about Jane/El. But why is he so angry if he lives in an illusion where his loss is alive.
Who is he grieving here then?
Why is Heroes playing as Season 5 Episode 8 end credits?
This was very chaotic and I'm sure much is missing, but just what I'm thinking about at the moment when it comes to Tales from '85











