If youâre leaning toward supporting socialized health care, please listen to this.
The scary thing about socialized health care is not the idea of âfree health care for allâ, which is of course quite a nice idea on the surface. The scary thing, the thing that should absolutely terrify you, is not being able to buy health care.
This is a nightmare that millions of people in countries with socialized health care have to deal with today.
Of course, if you are healthy and you do not need to buy health care, it is not so bad. But the socialized health care system such as in the UK intrinsically is such that you cannot buy health care.
You may be thinking âwell, why should health care be treated as a commodity? Itâs not fair to distribute it based merely on who has money.â
That would be true in a situation where resources are truly capped and limited and owned by a central distributor. However, health care in real life is not zero sum. If a rich person buys health care they are not directly taking away from a poor personâs health care.
Example under socialism:
Hospital: we only ordered 500 bandaids but we have 600 people injured. Time to do a triage and see who needs the bandaids most. The other 100 people will have to go without.
Example under capitalism:
Manufacturer: oh gee we have 600 bandaid orders but have only produced 500. Better make another 100 band-aids.
If a rich person pays millions for a medical procedure, it does not directly take away doctors from the poor- itâs an incentive for more people to become doctors.
Hereâs an example of some things that you canât buy under the socialist triage system:
bone broke and healed wrong? It canât be reset sorry. Need unusual potentially life-saving expensive care? That money could be split to serve two other people. What, you have your own money? We donât accept that. How dare you treat health care as a commodity. Need slightly nonstandard care that the system doesnât offer? Forget about it. Want a hip replacement? Why spend money on your quality of life when we have people who might die? (Although you can also be killed for poor quality of life, because the money to keep you alive might be better spent on someone who could have a good quality of life.) And you can forget about risky investment in new medical procedures.
Most importantly though, in a socialized health care system, people are a net drag on the system. The more people in it, the more that is taken away from it. Itâs financially advantageous for a socialized health care system to ignore peopleâs illness in order to conserve its limited resources. The fundamental difference is that in socialism resources are seen as limited whereas in capitalism resources are seen as potentially unlimited.
As someone living in the UK and currently dealing with a chronic health condition CAUSED by this triage system, I can completely agree.Â
When I was thirteen years old, I stated getting horrendous stomach pains. My period got heavier and within a year, I wad bleeding for six months with no breaks.Â
I first went to the doctor when I was thirteen, and without even toughing my stomach they told me that it was just IBS and sent me away with a diet suggestion and orders to come back in a month. When we went back to my clinic, there was a different doctor.Â
Five doctors later and I was very, very sick. Barely able to get out of bed and with several âdiagnosesâ that nobody was willing to confirm because my issues were seemingly related to my reproductive system and the NHS gynaecologists wouldnât treat someone under sixteen, we ended up still going to a private healthcare specialist.Â
At the beginning of 2020, I had an operation that revealed that, at thirteen, Iâd had appendicitis -- which, if theyâs touched me, my GP at the time would have felt. The infection went down, but not before it had moved all of my organs out of place. My periods got heavier because my bladder was crushing my uterus, and one of my ovaries had become twisted around my intestine and the fallopian tube on that side had been destroyed.Â
This will change many thing for me over the course of my life. Its unlikely that I will have my own children, and there are many foods I cannot eat and exercises I cannot do.Â
Under a capitalist system, this may not have happened. All I know is that under our socialised healthcare system here, I was one young person in an overcrowded waiting room, and the rules and regulations of our healthcare system have cost me for the rest of my life.Â
I wasnât a teenage girl, I was a statistic.Â





















