easter reflections of an ex-christian
This is my first Easter as a deconstructing ex-christian and it’s a bit of a surreal experience. And while I do have a lot of thoughts on the theological necessity of the sacrifice of Jesus as well as the historicity of the resurrection and how I now deny all its truth claims, I’d rather reflect on the psychological and emotional weight of this holiday.
“But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities; upon him was the chastisement that brought us peace, and with his wounds we are healed.” - Isaiah 53:5 (ESV)
Easter’s main focus is of course the death and resurrection of Jesus. Our churches, sermons, worship songs and even our social media feeds, are inundated with messages and images of Jesus on the cross, bloodied and humiliated. I went to an Anglican private school so of course every year there was a very dramatic depiction of the crucifixion in a school wide chapel service. All these things are of course meant to demonstrate the incredible suffering the Jesus underwent, and the love god supposedly has for us. But there is always an inherent undercurrent of how bad and sinful we are. Intentional or not these messages carry heavy messages of shame.
Whatever the intention, we are meant to feel responsible for a man’s suffering and death thousands of years ago. We are meant to see ourselves as unrepentant sinners. We are meant to see ourselves evil to the core. We are meant to see that the only way to save ourselves is to look upon this mangled corpse on a Roman execution device.
I do not deny that this can be a source of hope for many and it has been for centuries. I however, as a person already predisposed to depression, only associate this message with immense shame, guilt and fear. I am the reason. I am the source. If it wasn’t for how inherently evil, how dirty I am to the very core of my being and how I can never, ever measure up to god’s standard, this never would’ve had to happen.
And if you are a Christian, I can already see what you are thinking, “he’s so close” or “exactly.” But I don’t think you realise the psychological scars, the religious trauma or how this can heavily impact one’s self esteem.
I don’t blame Christians; I don’t even blame the Church. I do however believe these are systemic issues inherent within the Christian system and core beliefs. Easter is a complicated holiday, it can be a symbol of hope for many, but it can also be a source of unimaginable shame and guilt for others. Unfortunately, you cannot have one without the other.
I am learning to heal from these experiences. I am learning that I am enough. I am not broken. I am not dirty. I am not evil. I am whole. I do not need to be saved. I am human. And that is something worth celebrating.