I WILL NOT TOLERATE THE SIMON SLANDER ANY LONGER.
simon regularly gets dragged by people because he comes off as "stupid." SIMON IS NOT STUPID, HE HAS BRAIN DAMAGE. do people not understand this??? literally the whole game happens because simon went in for an experimental brain scan in hopes of recovering from the horrific car accident he suffered prior to the games events. his brain is literally BLEEDING. so much so that he has to go to the hospital to get his fucking skull cavity drained so the blood buildup doesn't cause even more damage
his condition is demonstrated in the prologue. he has memory problems. he cannot remember where he put the tracer fluid, and has to go through his whole apartment to find it. he forgot to send jesse that email explaining why he wouldn't be coming into work that day. he can't watch TV or movies anymore because screens gives him headaches. he needs to be medicated because his nightmares cause him stress, which can be fatal for him.
simon's scan is not only one of the very first of its kind, therefore quite primitive, but it is also that of a damaged brain. it is 'flatter' than the other scans we encounter. right off the bat, all versions of simon are impaired.
so of course it makes sense that he cannot fully comprehend certain concepts. it makes sense that he doesn't quite grasp what is going on and what will happen to him, even when he is faced with it after getting put in a new suit (WHICH TRAUMATIZES HIM BY THE WAY). and just like the ones who embraced the continuity theory, he clings to hope that he will be saved from the nightmare that is pathos-2.
simon is remarkably fucking chill when you think about it. he navigates the dilapidated structures of pathos-2 quite well, despite not only being impaired, but also coming from an entirely different time period. simon's scan is from 2015. he comes to in fuckin 2104. this guy is resilient as FUCK. and on top of that, he is constantly in danger and has to sneak around and hide from literal abominations trying to tear him apart and also has to cope with the fact that the world fucking ended and almost everyone is DEAD AND GONE. in fact, his impairment is partly what keeps him from going completely insane like the other mockingbirds.
and not to mention the fact that his guiding companion knows all of this. catherine is very careful with the way she words things after she picks up that simon isn't quite understanding the concepts involved. she redirects him from certain thought paths, and omits information she know would upset him. it is subtly manipulative. (but i still adore her)
simon was just a guy. an everyman, if you will. he worked at a bookstore. he dabbled in photography. he liked watching movies. he had an unrequited crush on a friend who died horrifically in the same accident that gave him serious, fatal injuries. he wasn't particularly academic. he wasn't an engineer or in STEM. he was just a guy from toronto who was dealt a very shitty hand and died young. and then his brain scan gets uploaded into an absolute NIGHTMARE.
AND HE STILL GETS SHIT DONE. DO NOT COME FOR MY BOY. HE IS PRECIOUS AND HAS NEVER DONE ANYTHING WRONG IN HIS WHOLE LIFE. HE DESERVED BETTER.