You Think Things Could Improve at Least Somewhat
( "'THE ELDRITCH RACE'" by Midhras is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 2.0. )
Despite great effort, you fail to prevent the cultists from enacting their ritual and summoning their dread elder god from its ancient prison between worlds. And you watch, as you'd long predicted, all the nations on Earth utterly powerless against the writhing alien darkness that unmakes space itself through its very presence. It takes only a few short days to take over completely--how few you're not sure, seeing as time now warps and stretches like fabric. All of creation laments its cruel fate, forced to bear the existence of that which, by all rights, should not exist yet, against all reason, does.
The world is remade to fit the ancient god's horrid reality. A new order forms. The nameless god rules all, sees all, knows all, consumes all. It is a wound on the face of creation, from which seethes forth numinous abominations that fill the planet with terror and dread. No one is safe, save for the blasphemous priesthood, made of half-mad once-humans, that carries out its wishes.
All else in this world was nothing more than fodder for its howling madness.
You do what you can to survive, spending most of your time darting between the many safehouses you'd constructed for just this occasion. Others are less fortunate. You see many carried off into the endless night. Sometimes you are tempted to help, but previous experience has shown there is precious little that can be done. It won't be long before they're eaten, or their souls are sucked out, or their bodies are twisted into some perverse monstrosity. You know things look grim. But you aren't despairing. You know of a magic ritual that, if performed properly, can send these eldritch horrors screaming back where they came from. All you need are 9 ancient artifacts and at least 8,100 dedicated people. Simple, right?
No. Not at all. Most are just trying to get through their day without, say, their shadow eating their reflection. Sure, they all concede, it would be nice for the nameless god to be banished to the endless void, but they just don't find that very realistic. You always say it's perfectly realistic! All people have to do is collect the 9 ancient artifacts scattered throughout the world, divide them among 9 groups of at least 900 individuals, and activate them one by one over 9 days while fending off the hordes of inhuman creatures that will inevitably attack. It won't be easy, but it's not completely impossible.
That may be, people tend to respond, but isn't it better to focus on things that can be achieved right now? Take the all the blood sacrifice. Why should they have to go to the temple, through traffic and the devil birds that eat your memories, just so the priests can spend five minutes cutting out their heart and burning it. Much more convenient for them to come to you instead.
You can respect that view, but you keep pointing out that this never solves the main problem of the nameless god. And people shrug and give a wan smile and say they just think the best thing to do is improve their lives in this world, and make things a little more tolerable.
(Kawanabe Kyōsai, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons)
You find, to your disappointment, this is a very widespread view. No one really likes the fact that the nameless god defines the very structure of the universe, but people don't seem to possess much urgency in defeating it. It is so pervasive, in fact, that you soon hear word that the people (at least a certain set of people) have come together and elected a representative who will negotiate with the nameless god on their behalf.
This makes recruiting your 8,100 people even more difficult. Now people say the Representative has it covered, and they're sure things will get better soon. You kind of miss when they'd engage you enough to pick your arguments apart. Now, it seems, no one cares. The Representative quickly gets to work, meeting directly with the priests of the nameless god, whose eyes have collapsed into pits of shadow. It doesn't take long before tangible results are delivered.
Human sacrifices will be capped at no more than 50,000 per day worldwide, except for the anniversary of the day the nameless god first entered our world, when it will be unlimited. Furthermore, heresy against the nameless god will no longer be an instant death sentence--instead, they will simply turn your tongue into a ravenous beast, which will slowly and surely take over your mind. And the best part? Sunlight. The nameless god itself will suspend the magics darkening the sky for thirty minutes every day. In return, however, the priests demand that everyone tattoo themselves with the sigil of their dark lord, dedicate ten drops of blood per day to its glory, and ban iodized salt. The Representative decides this is a decent deal and agrees, signing the pact in blood.
No one was consulted about this decision, least of all you, but people seem to believe this was a big accomplishment. Of course, there were some caveats. Because the nameless god controls time itself, it can make it the anniversary whenever it wants, meaning the 50,000 cap was rarely enforced. Further, while heresy against the gods is no longer a death sentence, the priests greatly expanded exactly what counts as heresy, leading to many more people getting their tongues turned into slavering parasites. Though the sunlight, people agree, is pretty nice. A shame it can't be on longer.
The Representative, now filled with confidence, says it's not over, and there's so much more to accomplish! Less painful executions! Less food that devours you from the inside! Finally doing something about that devil bird problem! And, of course, more sunlight. Why, if everyone works really hard, maybe, one day, they can get a whole hour of it.
You, meanwhile, still do everything you can to gather 8,100 people. So far, you've got 110, so you're not very hopeful. You keep wondering about the iodized salt. Why did the priesthood want to ban it? You start looking for some as you skulk around the wasteland, though it takes weeks to find any. When you do, however, you discover that iodized salt not only neutralizes magic from the nameless god, it also burns its servants. This seems like a pretty ridiculous weakness, and are especially surprised no one had tried it before, but after a few experiments you have to conclude that it works.
(BigBrotherMouse, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons)
Your timetable suddenly gets pushed up. You and your now-105 allies scour the world for as much iodized salt as you can, and when you can find no more you learn to make it yourselves. It doesn't take long before you have literally tons of the stuff.
You share your secret with the world and arm thousands of people with iodized salt. With it, you're able to easily resist the minions of the nameless god. Seeing your early victories, more people join you and fight back. In less than a year, you've recovered seven of the nine artifacts with the help of, now, 7,800 people. You're close. You know that soon the nameless god will be banished and your world will be freed.
What you don't anticipate is, one night, people working for the Representative drive up in firetrucks and wash away all the iodized salt. At the same time, others destroy the facilities that had been making more. This, you find out, is happening all over the world. In less than a week, there is nothing left to fight the nameless god. Everyone is now scared and abandons the plan, doing their best to not mention it ever again and going back to supporting the Representative.
As your hopes turn to ash, the Representative tries to assure you this had to be done. They couldn't afford a "little stunt" like this, not when they were so close to a breakthrough on the sunlight negotiations! They were going to give us two--TWO!--whole hours of sunlight, but that deal's gone now. But maybe, by stopping your plan, they could at least save the concessions on soul shredding they'd been working on for weeks.
You're told you need to let go of these silly fantasies that it's somehow possible to overthrow this system of oppression and dread and replace it with one of mutual aid and solidarity. It's time, says the Representative, to live in the real world. The more everyone struggles, the less the priesthood will listen to reason, and that makes it so much harder to fight for positive change in the community.
Not that it matters what you think. The nameless god has now acted to remove the very concept of iodized salt from all people's minds save your own. Whenever you bring it up with anyone now, they just look confused while trying, and failing, to wrap their heads around the idea. Without even knowledge of the weapon, let alone the weapon itself, no one will risk enacting the ritual. Not that you stop trying. You keep trying, again and again and again, to get your 8,100 people and all nine artifacts. Always. For the rest of your life.
( "The Temple - Lovecraftian Concept Art by Mihail Bila" by Mihail Bila (MCrassus Art) is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0. )