Disney Back Catalogue Reviews #17: Flubber Puppies
For much of Walt Disney Studio's history, their bread and butter has been adaptations of books. From their very first theatrical film, Snow White, the studio has found inspiration in novels and short stories written by authors around the world. With the exception of their documentaries, nearly all of their films I've reviewed so far are of this type, but since I don't have all the time in the world (nor the patience), you'll have to forgive me for reviewing the movies without reading their referents first.
One of those is 'Swiss Family Robinson', a retelling of the 1812 novel of the same name, about a family of five that become marooned on a tropical island and learn to fend for themselves. This was the second film adaptation of the book, the first being released by Disney's old collaborator RKO Pictures in 1940.
The film itself is interesting, though nothing that I'd call deeply compelling or worth a second watch (unless you're a really big fan of one of the actors). What initially drew me in, the whole concept of a family surviving on an island by making everything our of wood, is there in all its glory, though at times it feels glossed over in favour of subplots or happy moments. I was really excited to learn about the treehouse, which I'd visited during a trip to WDW nearly a decade ago, but was disappointed to find the film really only shows some of it, and cares more about its attempt at character drama instead.
For some reason, in the minds of the writers, getting the sons girlfriends was seen as more worthy of screentime than showing how they made a working plumbing system our of sticks and leaves. When a potential love interest is introduced, the two eldest Robinson sons suddenly become obsessed with her, fighting for her attention while the rest of the family is busy with survival. The character herself hardly does anything of significance in the movie itself, and its a bit disappointing to see her lose all agency the minute everyone realizes she's not a guy.
Still, the film is pretty to look at. Most of it was shot on-location in Tobago, with animals like tortoises and elephants shipped in from elsewhere. Its a tropical paradise to be sure, though some testimonies from cast and crew allege that behind the scenes, it was a nightmare to shoot. Bugs, quicksand, scorpions, Disney would be lucky if nobody got hurt while filming.
What's not pretty to look at is the racial stereotyping. Throughout the film, the Robinson family is stalked by South Asian pirates, and the film loves to paint them as evil and cutthroat. Some of the characters, as I've been told, were played by non-Asian actors in facepaint, which is totally not cool. The pirates' inclusion puts a bad taste in my mouth, especially considering how previous movies with pirates in them showed them to be reasonable, or at least decent enough to be bargained with. These ones, meanwhile, are 'savages' that speak another language, and try to kidnap young women for dubious purposes.
At the time of release, it seems most critics and audiences didn't notice, and the film did incredibly well at the box office both foreign and domestically. The New York Times called it a tale of "family love", and to this day, it has a high 80's score on Rotten Tomatoes. If it wasn't an obvious enough success, the company would later build a recreation of the family's treehouse in one of their theme parks, which remains to this day, between more current media franchises.
Between live-action films, Disney has always worked on what their studio was originally founded on: animation. With so many movies since the last I'd seen of their animated work, I was hankerin' to see what they'd cooked up next, and while I was pleasantly surprised, it wasn't exactly to my highest expectations.
The 1960 animated film 'One Hundred and One Dalmatians', based on a book of the same name, is about a family of two young Brits and their dogs, who welcome an unusual amount of puppies into their family. When their puppies get stolen by a jealous ex-friend, the parent dogs travel far and wide to get them back.
One thing is for certain about this film: it was done on the cheap. After their last animated movie, Sleeping Beauty, didn't do as well as they'd hoped, the studio knew they had to make movies on a tighter budget than before, and that meant cutting some corners. Xerox technology was used to make the animation and coloring process faster, and lineart was done in a sketchier, pencilwork flair that you can see pretty clearly on any of the characters.
The backgrounds, as well, are done with this slap-dash style that I'm shocked they got approval for. Colors don't always stay inside of lines, and some things in backgrounds aren't even fully outlined, making it look like an illustration in an old comic book. Still, the colours are warm, and scenes have a nice atmosphere, especially the ones inside the family's home.
But there are times where the film's budget becomes extremely noticeable. Puppies faces, and sometimes entire bodies, are copy-pasted to make crowds, and certain shots (like one of four puppies barking) are reused at different times in the movie. There's even reused assets from other Disney movies in there, which you can spot if you're looking for them. Many dogs in the Twilight Bark scene are taken directly from Lady and the Tramp, and recolored. One of them, a bulldog, is animated with his lips flapping, but isn't speaking, which is hilarious but also makes me wonder how they got away with it all.
Still, the film isn't all bad. The story is quaint and heartwarming, and the voice acting has that nice old-style charm. The movie's villain is iconic, and I'm shocked she hasn't appeared in Kingdom Hearts yet, with a goal like hers. She's so devious, so over the top about her evil persona, it makes you want to see her more on the screen, even though she's there to skin puppies for coats. I can't speak for her live-action counterpart, as I haven't seen it yet, but I will eventually.
Disney seemed to be on a high at this point, with a double-hit of good movies that did well at the box office. This time, they kept that good train rolling, with the release of 'The Absent-Minded Professor' in 1961.
The film focuses on a university chemistry professor (who today would be called neurodivergent), who accidentally discovers a new energy source which puts out more energy than it takes in. He names the substance 'flubber', and finds new ways to use it around town, while trying to win back the heart of his fiancé.
This movie is full of late 50's-60's sci fi charm: science being represented with bubbling beakers and tubes, sweatervests with your first initial on them, school sports being a town pride, flat and wide cars, its an old-school Americana that feels nice to see. At one point, a character remarks that 'only 8% of Americans buy cars', which was quite a trip.
The plot is pretty one-note, but it gets the job done in it's constraints. As soon as Professor Brainard invents Flubber, he's trying it out on everything, and each part of the film shows some new, wacky way it can be used. All the while, he tries to get the attention of his fiance, who is always conveniently led away right before he can show her his invention. It feels like a story that, these days, would get a kids show, with every episode having some new weird invention, and maybe by the final he'd propose to her.
There are moments in the movie where it drags (the beginning is quite slow), but when it gets going, its decently entertaining. Like I've said with many other movies, its not what I'd call thrilling cinema, but for the time, and considering all the snooze-fests Disney's put out before this, its really good. At times, its very funny, and the effects are cheesy, which just lends to its charm.
As it gets warmer out where I am, I hope that I'll have more free time to watch these movies, so I can get further into Disney's history. If I hustle, I can get to Walt's death in no time!
Also, for those who are keeping track, my Cry Counter is now at 8 (Once from Snow White, once from Pinnochio, once from Dumbo, twice from Bambi, twice from Lady and the Tramp, and once from One Hundred and One Dalmatians, because I legit thought the puppy died.)