attention moana cosplayers and everyone who wants to cosplay moana (of all races)
So very recently Iāve talked to a various amount of people who have different opinions about if cosplaying Moana is something anyone should do, regardless of heritage or what they look like. Numerous amounts of debate has gone on about who should do what. The biggest one Iāve seen isĀ ācosplay whoever you want, itās cosplay!ā
Iāve had a quite a few people tell me I would make a great Moana, which is why I decided to cosplay her. I do look like her, so it was nice to see a character I could identify with appearance wise in the Princess lineup. Once beforeĀ Iāve been told by someone who was white that I shouldnāt cosplay Moana, so I dismissed it because the person was not Polynesian themselves. Obviously it isnāt in their place to decide.
However! @swampthing, who is Pasifika, has messaged me with concerns of making and wearing traditional garments of their culture offensively by wearing a culture that does not belong to me because I do not participate in it. I had discussed it in private with @swampthing, and had agreed that it was offensive. If you want #receipts Iāll gladly provide.
Retrospectively after this conversation, I shouldnāt have sought advice from anyone else afterwards in an effort to be able to keep a costume i had worked on. So after discussing it another friend who was part Hawaiian and actually complimented my costume, I posted a picture today of me wearing it, and @respectyoursister has called me out for posting another picture after having the conversation with @swampthing. in turn, i recognized that it was an idiotic and disrespectful move to ignore everything @swampthing said to me for one personās opinion and for the sake of posting pictures in a cosplay.
youāre probably thinking I wouldnāt have made this post if I were not called out for it, and sure, I wouldnāt have, because I had thought I was in the okay, at least until someone came along to tell me once again that it wasnāt.Ā so,Ā ultimately, after being publicly called out for it on the picture itself, iām posting this, because I made two mistakes, and it was in my error to hold one personās opinion above someone else who is from the culture of the character you are cosplaying, who was actually concerned about the appropriative aspects of constructing and creating a traditional costume of a culture that does not belong to you, especially if that culture belongs to a people that is a small percentage of the population of the world.
No matter how many hawaiian/polynesian/pacific islander friends you have that are okay with it, if one person from the culture does not want you to do it, listen to them, and donāt blow them off for one opinion.
Moving forward, I urge everyone: if you are NOT Polynesian, do NOT cosplay from Moana. She is wearing traditional garments. They should not be treated like a costume.
I know there are a lot of black cosplayers, latina cosplayers (such as @momokurumi ) and other people of color who are not Polynesian that identify with the way she looks, and I know representation matters, but this isnāt necessarily negotiable. And whether Disney Parks chooses to cast someone to wear the costume who is actually Polynesian has no relevance either, as their habit of white washing characters and using people who are ethnically ambiguous to be their people of color in their parks doesnāt seem to be breaking anytime soon.
So what of those who have to in disney parks? The girls who will be auditioning to be Moana in The parks. The little girls who will dress like Moana. Will they be appropriating the culture by dressing as their heroes?
The clothes Moana wears in the movie. Although traditional will become a costume because Disney will make it into a costume.
There is a quote from lilo and stitch where nani states the place she was working at before she quits(or was she fired?) that their culture was now disgraced. That tradition became a tourist attraction.
That's going to happen here with moana's outfit. It will be made into a costume either way.
I'm sorry. But that is what's going to happen. It's a sad truth. -Mod Dipper

















