My Life with the Walter Boys: The Cole Effect
When the trailer and title frame appeared on my suggestion screen I decided to play, mostly out of bored curiosity and definitely more than half expecting it to be a simple teenage drama about a whole school’s worth of boys fighting over a mediocre female character.
This series has devastated me in my hormonal state. I ended up watching the whole series. I see it as a tragedy. A tragedy in Alex’ unrequited love for Jackie; in the impossibility of Jackie and Cole ending up together without consequences, in Alex’ best friend who is so in love with him that she can’t tell anyone; in the loss of the family home; in Erin’s insecurity; in Cole’s attitude towards life and ultimately the deepest betrayal of what he promised he would never do. This is what the country music genre is about, wasted youth, escaping the town, cowboy boots and drinking. Little attention is paid to these themes otherwise, and they are painted over with cute and playful moments throughout which is I think partly why I’m so unbalanced.
Despite having the set up to do so (Jackie is thrust into a houseful of “raging hormones”), I am grateful that I was not watching a painful romantic drama (I cannot take the love triangle in Twilight seriously). The intricate relationships between all the family members were interesting and complex and I was able to relate to the teenage frustrations I saw in all of them.
To me, Jackie was not the main character, Cole was. To begin with is painted as the villain. He is the only boy who doesn’t welcome Jackie to the home, he is the most sought-after boy in school (“the Cole effect”), he uses his popularity and charm to treat girls as disposable, including his not-girlfriend Erin, but it’s casual so it’s fine... He is cocky, selfish and seems to enjoy evoking anguish in his siblings and school friends. In the first few episodes every conversation he had with Jackie I was internally screaming for her to just tell him to f*** off.
But then you learn about the future he had stolen from him after a leg injury. Suddenly there’s nothing for him. His family can’t afford college, so without that football scholarship he’s not going. He doesn’t see anything good in the future, or himself becoming anything more than what he already is; a bitter man stuck in a small town with no skills, no reason to be loved, all the attention on his younger brothers achieving their dreams and fledging the nest. And it’s so tragic.
This is the first time I understood the small American town narrative. In the UK we have small rural villages, but you are never so far from a town or city or a train station to take you to a musical, if you wanted to do that. The boys listen wide-eyed at the table as Jackie says that if they went to New York, they could see a ballet. I feel that rural is too urban a word to describe where the Walters live. And Cole really highlights this trapped concept.
Cole lets his grades sink and his relationships disintegrate, because he has no desires anymore. I infer that he sleeps around to stay relevant, or as an avoidance mechanism, or both. His friend takes his place on the football team. The only thing that he can cling onto from his life before the injury is the female validation. This is my hot take, Cole is not a demon for messing girls around. It is an unhealthy coping mechanism that unfortunately affects other people, and he is too damaged to see that.
I’m glad we learn more about Erin too. Her insecurity about Cole’s intentions towards her makes her mean to Jackie. She’s not a mean person. Insecurity makes people act uncharacteristically, trying to take control of a part of the situation, which is the other girl. The classic situationship is displayed, she knows she is worth more than a man who can’t commit to her, who doesn’t call her back and who then acts like everything is fine. But she has feelings for him. It’s not that easy.
And Cole does care about his family. When he’s called out on his behaviour by Will, a light changes in his eyes. He is confused and regretful. He doesn’t want to hurt anyone, but he has been intentionally doing it for weeks. He didn’t realise though, because he’s not important enough for anyone to be hurt by him? Does that make sense? Will tells him of course he has choices over his life, and that his behaviour is a choice. Everything you do is a choice. This is the only thing that seems to get through to Cole.
A scene I wanted to highlight was the fight between Will and Hayley. It’s such a perfect example of communication. Hayley handles this fight incredibly well. Despite both being angry and upset, with strong feelings involved, she stays calm. She makes her points despite attempts to be derailed with accusations of character. This scene should become a teaching material, I am that serious about it.
Another scene I love is the school fight. I don’t think it’s cliché that the Walter boys had a reputation in a school, a hot target for gossip. Families with two siblings were talked about as dynasties in my school, and this family has six siblings in the same school. Within a few hours a rumour spins out of control and in the confusion and heat of embarrassment and anger Alex believes Cole is responsible. Alex has lost out to his cooler older brother his whole life. The interaction between a victimised Alex and an exhausted Cole in the auditorium escalates and turns physical. Isaac, Lee and Nate in the cafeteria see the livestream of the scene, glace at each other and then sprint to the auditorium. It is strangely heartwarming to see the innate pack-bond that the boys have for each other.
Finally, I wanted to talk about Jackie and Alex’ relationship. Alex is head over heels with Jackie. The intensity of a high school crush, who you already think is perfect, but you managed to date them! Jackie thinks he’s cute, but it’s obvious she was never actually into him. I can’t think of one thing she does for him. I think their relationship is the biggest tragedy and I dislike Jackie for never being honest with herself about it. Ashby Gentry (Alex) plays the perfect naïve and doting good boy-next-door character. Alex waits up for her when she’s late, she punishes him for a miscommunication, he apologises with an amazing date, she doesn’t tell him about talking to Cole, he sacrifices time with his friends to meet her when she flakes. Not a 50/50 relationship.
I saw a take that the writing attempts to assassinate his character to appear overbearing, in order to redeem Cole. I agree with this @skam-in-every-language. Although whilst wathing, every romantic gesture just exaggerated the imbalance in feelings between them, and I wanted to rip my heart out on his behalf.
I guess for Jackie, Alex was the easy option. The one without risk, with reliable feelings. And I reason that Jackie does not need to be disappointed by someone she loves and is looking for safety. However, the consequences of her tragic situation are never really shown in her writing, so it’s hard to understand. It’s only the first two episodes where you believe she is vulnerable. I am a strong believer that it is unfair to let someone love you more than you love them- but there is no correct answer to relationships, a piece for another time.
So, this 10-part series is only two boys fighting over a girl, not 9. I can’t decide if Jackie is a mediocre character or not. She is not a mediocre person, an athlete, an academic, petite, pretty, and upper east side “exotic.” But to me I watched the show to understand the family dynamics and the small-town frustrations, not because I felt invested in Jackie’s storyline. I think more could have been done with her. Maybe this was intentional and she was created to mediate the story of the other boys. Or maybe I am cynical because of the way she took Alex for granted.