Barking Up the Wrong Tree
Lately I’ve been reading posts or statuses from friends and familiar that concern me. So, being that this has been heavy on my heart, I thought I would talk about the idea of “prosperity” gospel, or self-focussed worship. Not because I want to seize the heretical teachers and see them burned at the stake, but mostly because the teachings of the prosperity gospel are misleading. Where Christians should be looking to our savior, to the prosperity that He already is, there are many that are looking for the right “equation” in which to gain our “divine” entitlement from God. It’s a theology that is primarily bent on material needs, good-feelings, and words steeped in optimism and emptiness.
And most importantly, in its subtle concepts and crevices, it leads us away from actually knowing our father and his will, and from what following Christ actually looks like.
I might do a number of blogs on this topic, but for now we’ll talk about it from a fundamental of Christianity. Here I come to these topics with the prosperity teachings in mind, but I think this applies to a wider variety of distractions from the gospel.
The Prosperity “Gospel”
There is a thing that has arisen in modern mainstream christianity called the "Prosperity Gospel". The reason it is even called a specific kind of a gospel is because it isn't the ACTUAL gospel. The “Gospel of Prosperity” teaches a sort of message that says "the power to a better life is IN yourself. You have the power to your own destiny". I was flipping through the channels and landed on a evangelical teaching series, and that was literally what they said. I couldn’t believe what blatant disregard for Jesus’s teachings you have to go through to arrive at that point. But that is the world we live in... I have spent some time listening to people like Joel Olsteen to see if it's really as bad as they say. And believe me, it is.
Honestly, there will be bits of truth always mixed in with deceitful messages. I have overheard some thing Joel Olsteen has said that I could confidently say, “Yeah, thats true”. Most of the things I’ve listened to, however, follow this cookie-cutter processed message of “blessings for us”, with little to no focus on what it actually means to be a disciple of Jesus. In addition, perhaps the most aggravating thing, is the scripture used in his talks are taken seriously out of context, and are used unfortunately with agenda in mind, and not original intent.
But enough of that already. I’m not trying to pick a fight or particularly rant about anyone in particular. My goal is to show the fallacy in this askewed and widely accepted view of the gospel by use of the Gospel in scripture.
The Prosperity Gospel focuses on human entitlement, human achievement, and the proper equations to activate God’s blessings. Which is admittedly attractive in this day and age.
But it doesn't work. Why?
Well here is some scripture that directly addresses the human condition, and our need for him, which would contradict the focus of Prosperity teachings: Rom 3:9, 23; Eph 2:8-9; Eccl 7:20. And in Matt 8:18-22 we see Jesus telling eager would-be disciples that following Jesus is not a walk in the park.
But I would like to expand further.
Other Gods
Let's talk about idolatry a little bit. The First Commandment states to "have no other gods before me [Yahweh]” (see Gen 20). Now, you and I may look at this and say,"Well I got that one down good! I don't have molded idols dedicated to Baal, Magog, Melkor, or Sauron. So that command is more for primitive folk who struggled with alternative deities." The problem with that is that the 'gods' that referred here were very real to those people, and exist today in very real (but less overt) ways. The main issue was that when people worshipped other god’s, they really only worshipped prosperity.
For example. The Greeks had a god for for every need. If you were a farmer you worshipped Demeter, the God of grain, growth, and harvest. If you were a merchant, Hermes. There was one for sailors, soldiers, mother, virgins, musicians, socialites, and craftsman! The list goes on! And that’s just the Greek gods. The idea was “if I do this thing (sacrifice) for this god, I will do well in life (wealth in trade, success in career, health in life, prosperity in war, etc). So in the end, they didn’t worship those gods for gods themselves, they worshipped them in the hopes of gain. Today, we skip the graven images and make our homes the temples, or our job-sites. Our children become our anchors, or our friends, or our social status, or our education, or our marriage.
I’m using broad terms here, but anything that you subconsciously say “I must have that in order to be valued/satisfied” is actually your god, your identity. Sometimes they are hard to identify. But you can sometimes see what they are when you see what you spend the most time in, emotionally or mentally or physically. Then you can almost catch a subtle glance of the graven image--the god you pray to.
Now most of these idols are not bad things as themselves. Prosperity is a good thing. Our children and jobs and relationships are good things. But to the Christian, when they are put before God, they become idols. And you can worship anything, even doctrine and theology can take a clever place where the actual Jesus belongs. A god is anything you worship or slide right in the slot between yourself and God.
Hazards of gods
The effects of following these things as your “end-all” is that they will inevitable leave you either constantly grasping for more, or/and will eventually collapse on you while your hands flail about for the next thing that will inevitably do the same. Why is this way? Because scripture tells us these things are not designed to fulfill us. That, instead, we are designed to be fulfilled by God.
In Acts 14:8-18, as well as in Act 17:22-31 Paul addresses the greeks in Lystra and Athens and essentially tells them they are barking up the wrong tree, and that God was the thing they ultimately sought. Now that’s just a small facet of these verses, and they focus on even deeper theology and philosophy than I am giving them credit for. But the idea is this: there is nothing that will fulfill us, because God is that fulfillment
But the Prosperity gospel teaches that god is essentially a good-looking vendor that loves us. It says "ACTION (prayer, positivity) + GOD = BLESSINGS" See the focus here? It isn't God. Its actually blessings. It’s actually on us.
But that isn't Christianity. It's idolatry.
So, in other words, we are barking up the wrong tree.
What Does the Gospel say?
So what is the actual Gospel? What does the Bible teach us? Well, I'm glad you asked. It's very different, and a ba-zillion times better. Here are a couple main contradictions:
1. Prosperity "gospel" says that all God wants is for your to have a rich life. The BIBLE shows us that following God actually leads you through hardships.
It used to be a common understanding that becoming a christian does not mean your life gets better. Yes and no. I would say your life does get better, but not because it becomes easier or circumstances are magically created in which you become a millionaire. It’s because your understanding in life changes from focussed on the temporary and physical, to the eternal and the spiritual. And it changes with a tint of hope that reconciles all misfortunes and sin. But it is certainly not easier.
Lets look at the scripture for this. Matt 8:18-22
18 Now when Jesus saw a crowd around him, he gave orders to go over to the other side. 19 And a scribe came up and said to him, “Teacher, I will follow you wherever you go.” 20 And Jesus said to him, “Foxes have holes, and birds of the air have nests, but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay his head.” 21 Another of the disciples said to him, “Lord, let me first go and bury my father.” 22 And Jesus said to him, “Follow me, and leave the dead to bury their own dead.”
We already see Jesus warning would-be followers about the hardships of following him in Matthew. As the Reformation Study Bible puts it:
8:18–22 These two events show the radical commitment Jesus demands of disciples. Those who identify with Jesus will be “sojourners and exiles” in the world (1 Pet. 2:11). Honoring one’s parents by providing a proper burial was a strict obligation in Jewish society, but Jesus demands a greater allegiance to Himself.
We also know that the first disciples (I believe all but John) were brutally martyred for their belief. And beyond that, the early church experienced waves of persecution, and in the circumstances of Roman plague, the christians deliberately endured suffering and sickly death to minister to the dying.
Our prayers should be focussed on asking God for His will in us, not our will with him as an added boost. When Jesus teaches us how to prayer, one of his first statements in the prayer is “Thy will be done...” Jesus, even wishing for another way to exact salvation, asks on the mount of olives: “not my will, but thy will...” knowing the hardships he were about to face. And as you see through out Pauls ministry, who faces stoning, beatings, torture, and shipwrecks, Paul doesn’t ask for less hardships, but endures them knowing the gospel was worth it. C.S. Lewis says on this matter:
“There are only two kinds of people in the end: those who say to God, "Thy will be done," and those to whom God says, in the end, "Thy will be done."
Even Bruce Lee had a good grasp on this concept, saying:
“Do not pray for an easy life, pray for the strength to endure a difficult one”
The mainstream prosperity gospel doesn’t look anything like this sort of christianity.
2. Prosperity "gospel" says the power is in yourself. The BIBLE says we are all really depraved and INCAPABLE of fixing our problems.
Scripture tells us in that our hearts are corrupt. The New Testament and Old testament is steeped in the evidence of our hearts being corrupt, and our need for God’s redemption--for His grace to save us. It is the human condition (ex Mark 7:21, Jer 17:9, for start, Rom 3:23).
But on a more positive note, Genesis tells us we are made in God's image, it tells us we were declared good by our creator Himself. So our value to God is great, which is why he doesn't want us to muck about trying to gain value from other 'gods'.
Some of us know our faults. Those who don't realize their own faults are usually ignorant to them because the thing that keeps them from seeing this is their idol: "I'm not so bad, because I have this, or because my identity is in that..." WE LITERALLY SAY THIS. I said it the other day and then realized it later on, saying, “Oh man, even I say that!” But it is IMPOSSIBLE to come to knowing God without knowing our faults. Because that's what knowing God does, it reveals to us our need for him.
3. Prosperity gospel focuses heavily on getting God to get gifts. The Gospel tells us to follow God to get God.
When we come to terms with our inability to be ‘better’ people, and our need for our savior, it tends to push away the material prosperity. Because it shows us that even if we GOT THOSE GREAT THINGS (Great Job, awesome spouse, sweet house, social status at the local pub) we would still be lacking what really fulfills us: God.
As Timothy Keller put it:
“All money, talent, health, power, and pleasure in the world are God's. But the greatest treasure he can give us is life in his presence.”
And, before, C. S. Lewis said:
“Aim at Heaven and you will get Earth 'thrown in': aim at Earth and you will get neither.”
This is the point: if we focus more on the things of God (blessings, prosperity, etc) and not on God himself, who is the master and provider of those things, we miss it. And ultimately we are trying to purchase parts for a machine we don’t actually have. We are hoping in lesser goods in place of the biggest good.
The Daily Threat
Now, let me say this: we have to make God our 'god' daily. We have to make our identity Him, daily. Because we are fallen people in a fallen world, we will always return to our other 'gods' "as a dog returns to it's vomit". Which is what also adds to the relationships concept. Its not necessarily a transaction we undergo once and then , PRESTO-CHANGO! We are never wandering astray! insert kazoo sound!
No. That's not how it works. It's an ongoing account. Its a companionship a... well... a relationship. Its a constant. I'm talking here about consistency, not salvation. That's a separate theological point we can talk on later. So what I'm saying is, we need to be mindful. Because I have found that usually when I am distressed about something, or angry and bitter about someone or circumstances, or just feel abandoned, its because I was trusting in something else. I had put another ‘god’ before Yahweh, who is THE ONE GOD TO RULE THEM ALL (seriously though).
And knowing that THAT is the human condition from what the Gospel shows us--how Jesus fulfills that need for perfection, or fulfills that longing for fellowship--I know that I can look at the anger and pride and disappointment and say, "Its because I left God." And what does one do from there? He Turns to Jesus and rests. See MATT 11:28-30. And that's where the Grace is. Its where our turning, our inability to faithfully follow him is covered by HIS faithful goodness, HIS faithful relationship. See what Paul says in Romans 5:1-8
Therefore, since we have been justified by faith, we[a] have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ. 2 Through him we have alsoobtained access by faith[b] into this grace in which we stand, andwe[c] rejoice[d] in hope of the glory of God. 3 Not only that, but werejoice in our sufferings, knowing that suffering produces endurance, 4 and endurance produces character, and character produces hope, 5 and hope does not put us to shame, because God's love has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us. 6 For while we were still weak, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly. 7 For one will scarcely die for a righteous person—though perhaps for a good person one would dare even to die— 8 but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us.
Conclusion
Some of you might have read this, and not being of the "Prosperity Gospel" and know what I mean by "total depravity", have realized that this isn't a message for you. But it is. It most certainly is. And I would charge you to look at your life and the things that are eating at you now (we aren't always going to be aware of them). Look at those things and say "is God my god, or has something else taken that place?" 10/10 times I am in a state of depression or worry or anger or pride, it is because it's not God who I am trusting, it isn't God who is my identity. Its usually because it is something else. It’s me barking up the wrong tree.
For more reading on this, I highly recommend Timothy Keller’s book, “Counterfeit Gods”.







