I can’t begin to express my gratitude to Sadie and Dylan for giving us everything they had in order to tell this story. All Too Well The Short Film is out on YouTube, and showing all week at the AMC 13 theater in NYC. For you, from us.
Writer: *shows the serial killer the murder scene they’re writing* babe, i’m not sure if this would actually work?
Serial killer: *kisses writer on the forehead and leaves, comes back later, a suspicious scent of blood coming off them* it works baby, you’re doing great
I love this, I love all of this, but quick question, does the author know? Like are they aware that their significant other is a serial killer or do they just think that they have a morbid sense of humor? It’d be even funnier if the author had no fucking clue, like how Aurthur Conan Doyle was apparently stupidly gullible, and on top of it they’re a horror or crime novelist. Like the serial killer works at a butcher shop or something so it’s completely normal for them to come home smelling like blood, no murders going on here, no sirey. Just my darling coming back home from a long day at work.
Now fast forward a bit and the author has managed to get their first book published, with loving support from the serial killer who helped them fine tune all the murder scenes, and it’s a big hit. Enough so that a detective with the local police department has noticed some disturbing similarities to several active cases, including details that were never released to the press. Obviously he brings this up to his superior and convinces him that there’s something to the theory, but it’s all circumstantial right now. He stakes out the author’s home and is super convinced that the author is the murderer, but they don’t seem to do anything??? Like they literally are at the house all day, that’s it. Most they do is leave for groceries.
So you get this dynamic of the serial killer mining the author for creative murder schemes, the author being lovingly encouraged by the serial killer, and finally the detective who is just so sure that the author is the killer and that if he sticks it out long enough he’ll FINALLY have proof.
Ok so here’s the setup. When i was like 7, my parents moved us into a house where my sisters and I shared the upstairs, which was split into two bedrooms. I got a separate room bc I was the most territorial the eldest. Both bedrooms had these weird little attached attic…space…things that were essentially unfinished closets. they were padded to the brim with this stuff:
i later found out the company that sells it had an advertising deal w/ the pink panther cartoons. that detail is completely unrelated to this story.
fyi that pink stuff is fiberglass insulation. my mom, presumably, at some point, almost certainly told me not to touch it, and that it contained crushed glass, and that I absolutely should not touch it, listen to me [deadname], look at me: the pink stuff is dangerous so do not touch it.
i say presumably, bc i was unmedicated at the time and my hyperactive 7-year-old brain tended to filter out unnecessary information.
also, in my defense, that stuff is fluffy. like it may contain glass, but soda bottles contain glass, and they don’t hurt to touch. and neither did this stuff! it was pretty soft actually. i would occasionally pat it with my bare hands while hiding in the dark swaying back and forth pretending i had been kidnapped and was being held hostage in the belly of a pirate ship and it was fine. so after awhile my brain just sort of put the pink stuff in the category of “don’t eat it or anything and you’ll probably be fine.”
i would later wish, above all wishes, that i had heeded my mother’s warning.
a pertinent detail about my bedroom attic: it had a crawl space. just a tiny little black tunnel that disappeared into the house beyond. i naturally, one day, became curious about where exactly it disappeared to. and how far.
my curiosity was compounded by the fact that the crawl space headed directly towards my sister’s bedroom. upon further reflection, it was very possible that the crawl space in fact connected both attics.
i should at this point discuss my sisters’ bedroom attic. while mine was mostly used for storage and for sitting alone in the dark listening to scary radio shows that gave me nightmares my sisters had rather brilliantly decided to repurpose theirs into a clubhouse/Stuffed Animal Storage Facility. from what i had seen, it was stuffed to bursting with goddamn stuffed animals. it also had, i believe, a little tea table. and they had drawn on the walls. all in all, very makeshift and cozy.
i say “from what i had seen” because generally speaking, i wasn’t allowed in the Stuffed Animal Storage Facility. it was Their space, and of course there is not more territorial group of people that children of the age group 12 and under. Also, i was the least popular member of the household, except possibly for one of the hamsters.
So the scene has been set: I am a 7-year-old delinquent who just so happens to be obsessed w/ espionage and bank robberies and I have discovered a secret tunnel from my bedroom to my sisters’ Forbidden Clubhouse.
i consider myself a victim of circumstance. the events that followed really wrote themselves.
what possible other ending could this story have? one sunday afternoon when i had nothing better to do, i decided to test my hypothesis that i was narrow enough to fit into the itty bitty tunnel.
and i WAS! an ancient and world-weary 8-year-old couldn’t have done it, but i was just stick-like enough to manage. i strapped a flashlight to my wrist and got on my hand and knees and crawled through that fucker! this, it transpired, was a colossal undertaking, as i was only technically small enough to fit into the wall. there was very little additional room to, for example, bend my knees and elbows. i ended up propelling myself forward mostly by inching along with my toes & wiggling like an eel. it was not very effective!
i got stuck several times. i tried to go back several times. it turns out there is no feasible way to turn around in a tunnel that is exactly as wide and as tall as the width of your shoulders. in one of my darker moments (i was stuck behind the bathroom wall, probably quite close to the toilet) it occurred to me that i had no actual proof there would be an opening on the other end. this presented certain concerns. it turns out it is rather difficult to drag yourself backwards by your toes.
i persevered! propelled by panic and (most of all) a lack of other options. 30 minutes and 10 yards later, i confirmed there was indeed an opening on the other end, which did indeed open into my sisters’ attic, because i was indeed a veritable genius.
it was at this point i discovered my sisters were not in their bedroom. they had, in fact, at some point decided to go downstairs. meaning i would not be able to burst out of the attic to the shock and astoundment of all bystanders.
i waited patiently for almost an entire minute. and then, observed only by the glossy plastic eyes of a hundred passionless plush toes, i tiptoed quietly away and hobbled back to my bedroom.
This was, naturally, the beginning of the most woeful, misery-filled fortnight of my short and sorry life.
So i returned to my daily life, content in the knowledge that i had once again escaped the consequences of my actions, like the protagonist i so truly was.
Until.
The next day.
Monday evening. Oh, Monday evening. After a long, tedious day at school, I lay peacefully in bed, content in the expectation of a well-deserved rest. Set down your constant burden, human, and rest thy weary soul.
But then. A sensation of dread swept over me. It had begun.
The ITCHING.
Did I mention the crawl space was lined with fiberglass insulation?
As it turns out, dragging yourself against 30 feet of finely crushed glass does, in fact, beget consequences. Microscopic shards of glass DO NOT CARE if you were wearing clothing at the time. they go where they choose. and that miserable Sunday afternoon of my wretched folly, they had chosen to
EMBED THEMSELVES DIRECTLY INTO MY SKIN.
What words to describe the suffering of the next 2 weeks? Reader, I took so many showers. SO MANY. Hot showers first thing in the morning, directly after school, and again before dinner, and right before bed. There was never any hot water left. i SOAKED. i SCRUBBED. i WEPT like the PITILESS WRETCH i so truly was reduced to.
and the itching would. not. STOP. Everywhere, it was everywhere, arms and legs and torso and FACE. Oh my stars it was so bad. I rubbed up like a cat against brick walls and desks corners and furniture. i scratched. i prayed and discovered that the gods are either powerless or indifferent to our suffering or perhaps are merely moderately entertained. nothing helped.
two weeks. two weeks of ITCH, before my skin finally, finally expelled the invaders. It was misery. My sisters were unamused (and somewhat bored by the matter, and told me not to go in their room). My mom was unimpressed. And me? I was not excused from school (probably due to the fact that as an undiagnosed autistic kid in chronic discomfort, the adults around me were already in the habit of ignoring my constant complaints.)
(which how fucked up is that, that my base level of discomfort was so high that the adults around me didn’t believe i was in more pain than usual when 80% of my skin was literally embedded with glass???)
When it comes to showers, cold water works best to get the fiberglass shards off. there’s some dispute about whether warm water “opens the pores” or if that’s a myth
You can *carefully* place duct tape or electrical tape against the skin to peel off the shards
Wash your clothes in apple cider vinegar to get rid of the glass/avoid it spreading to the rest of your laundry
DO NOT BREATHE THIS SHIT. Wear a face mask/respirator & goggles & protective clothes if you’re gonna be working near it
i reiterate: do not touch the pink stuff or pain will be your only fortune, all your joy will melt in your hands and lament requiems at your feet
So, I never understood why people who relate to Catra hate Hordak so much? I always thought they were quite similiar what with doing bad things as a result of their abuse and then eventually overcoming their abusers by the end of the show. Why the hate?
Normally I don't engage with this stuff, so this will be my one piece on it. Let me touch on 2 things before I compare and contrast Hordak, Catra, and Wrong Hordak (who I will call Kadroh for the remainder of this meta).
1) I am someone who finds Hordak to be an interesting character, but I dislike his stans and don't usually engage in content featuring him primarily. I feel this way about the majority of characters that I find interesting but don't outright love. I find his personality to be unlikable, but that doesn't make him a bad character, just someone I wouldn't want to be friends with. 2) The framing of this question makes it seem like it's "just" Catra fans who dislike Hordak, thus making it seem like there must be something wrong with that subgroup when there are actually many valid reasons to find him unlikable and many others dislike him as well (he is, after all, a villain). I will, however, extend good faith once - and only once - and assume you are asking why someone likes one villain and not another when they both ended up hurt by the same person (Horde Prime). Spoiler alert: the answer is all other context surrounding them as characters and their actions.
Okay, so let's talk about some of the differences between them in no particular order, because unpacking them all would be exhausting and this is already the longest meta I've ever written, but I want to get this off my chest and then I'm going to continue ignoring any asks about him and the people who try to fight over him. Why is Catra more sympathetic (and canonically more redeemed) than Hordak? Here are a few big reasons, though there are many more and this is in no way comprehensive:
1. Kadroh. He was raised in exactly the same environment as Hordak. We don't know what position he held, but he was considered high enough to be on Prime's mothership. He learns the truth about Prime merely by finding out that he has factually lied and by "reading" information about Prime's invasion of Krytis. He, with very little prompting, immediately turns on Prime.
We don't see the exact circumstances with which Hordak arrived on Etheria, but it is implied that he told Scorpia that her grandfather took him into his kingdom - showing him the same kind of compassion that Entrapta showed Kadroh - and then her grandfather joined the Horde gave the kingdom to Hordak. This is pretty obviously a lie or stripped of context in some way because it would be a completely illogical move for a monarch to give their kingdom to a stranger, but it implies that Hordak was initially taken in by the people of Etheria, and thus got a similar introductory level of kindness upon being separated from Prime as Kadroh did.
Hordak had even more information against Horde Prime than Kadroh did - he knew he wasn't infallible because he created the "imperfect" Hordak, he knew what Prime's war looked like on a high level and on the ground, and he even knew that Prime wanted him to die and hated him personally, which is a far worse position than Kadroh was in - and yet, instead of turning against Prime as Kadroh did, he decided the best course of action was to start his own war to prove his worth and then return to him. You can put that down to differences in personalities somewhat, but you would be remiss to ignore the fact that they are both clones and were members of the hive mind.
2) Hordak never acknowledges that the Horde is evil - Catra does so in the pilot. Catra cares that the Horde is evil, she has been hurt by them herself, but she doesn't know any other life. Hordak knows even more about what the Horde has done than Catra and he doesn't care that it is evil. I know some of his fans claim that he does, but that is an idea completely created by fanon and never stated in the show. He talks of Prime with awe - Catra talks of Hordak with fear and resentment from episode one.
3) Prime reveals there was a time when Hordak wished Prime would never come for him. It isn't revealed when this was - it could be at any point in the series when things are going well for the Horde, or during a fleeting moment that he shared with Entrapta, or even a thought that became ever-present and started before the series itself. It does tell us this, though: Hordak was happy (or at least felt fulfilled enough) running his army and conquering Etheria.
Catra, by contrast, we rarely see happy in the Horde at all (as Scorpia says: The Crimson Waste was the first time she ever saw Catra happy, when Catra was completely removed from the Horde). Catra talks about how winning isn't even fun for her. She is at the top of Hordak's Horde, right beside him, and she is playing at big bad villain, but it isn't fulfilling her even after she was brought up as a child soldier and groomed for it. This isn't what she wanted - all she ever wanted was Adora.
Hordak, on the other hand, is triumphant, and we don't see that crack vindication in the same way that we do for Catra. Canonically, it isn't there. He is still reveling in destruction after causing it for at least two decades (Adora and Catra are both about 20 at this point, and Adora was taken by the Horde as a baby. We don't know how long they existed before that, so the war has been waging for a minimum of 2 decades but possibly more) whereas Catra isn't enjoying causing pain after only 2-3 years - and that's dismissing the fact that you can make an argument for how she never was at all.
4) Hordak doesn't make amends within the series. He fights Horde Prime to save Entrapta - which is definitely good, but it is also his only good act that we see. You can absolutely look at the trajectory of the series and say he improves as a person afterwards, learning to be good the same that Catra did over season 5, but we don't actually see it. We see Catra sacrifice her life on the chance that it will save Adora, all while thinking she is absolutely nothing to Adora (As Catra says in Noelle's fic: “She wouldn’t come back for me.”).
Hordak, knowing full well Entrapta still cares about him and did even when he was running the Horde (and thus might not demand he change much, if at all), saves her when she rather literally has the gun against her head, mere feet from him. The act that he takes is to attempt to kill Prime, thus freeing himself as well - by contrast, the act Catra made was to free someone else knowing that Prime would brainwash or murder her for it, with absolutely no intention of or expectation to survive herself. The magnitude of the acts is different. Hordak knew his action might win them the entire war - Catra knew she was sacrificing herself to keep Adora safe for just that moment. The fact that his redemptive act is smaller doesn't take away from it as an act, but it does mean it doesn't go as far to redeem him on it's own - and it is on its own.
I whole-heartedly believe that he does continue to improve after the end of the series given its trajectory thus far, but that is up to speculation, whereas Catra had a season to show us how she is now fighting for her friends and taking steps to control her anger, apologize, and better herself. Hordak's sacrifice comes right at the end of the series, so he has done less to redeem himself while creating more harm overall (a reminder that Noelle said the only person that Catra killed was maybe Tung Lashor, whereas Hordak has an entire nursery full of children that he orphaned).
5) We also get small moments of caring with Catra throughout the series - in flashbacks and in the various times where she saves or helps Adora, starting with season one (giving her back the sword, etc). She even thanks Scorpia for disobeying her at the end of White Out despite it losing her a chance at capturing She-ra. On the whole, we see a lot more small moments of humanity and caring from Catra than we do from Hordak, and we even see her extend kindness to multiple people such as Adora, Scorpia, and Glimmer. Hordak we only ever see be at all sympathetic with Entrapta, and honestly his scenes with her... skeeved me out as a survivor. I am not elaborating on this further, it's way too uncomfortable, and I will block you if you attempt to talk with me about it. Basically, the point here is that Catra is much more likable and even has relatable backstory as a childhood abuse victim (which I've already discussed).
6) Individual abusers need to take responsibility for their actions regardless of who started the cycle of abuse. Catra takes responsibility - she apologizes to people she has hurt (at least those that she can who aren't chipped), she recognizes when she snaps and takes a moment to calm herself, she fights against the Horde, and she genuinely believes what they are doing is wrong - she tells Adora in "Taking Control" that she "has to stop them" and then helps her do just that. We watch Catra begin to reform her actions and make amends. It takes no mental effort to know she will continue after the end of credits.
We don't get the same with Hordak. In the final seasons, he is also brainwashed and chipped, but he remains under for much longer. As a result, we never see him apologize, and we also never saw him be remorseful before that. He is not redeemed on the same level that Catra or Entrapta was. Entrapta we see trying to do the right thing in the final season after she also fought her friends and served the Horde, even if she isn't sure exactly how to fix things.
In a similar vein, Shadow Weaver never admits she was wrong, always claiming that she had to do what she did or that her victims even deserved it. She and Prime are clearly the most irredeemable characters of the show - they are completely irredeemable in my opinion, regardless of Shadow Weaver's last, self-serving sacrifice. Hordak is better than them, but that doesn't mean he doesn't rub a lot of people the wrong way as a man who hurt a lot of people, never made amends for it (in canon), and then is celebrated by a very vocal subset of the fandom.
7) Hordak is removed from Horde Prime in a totally different dimension when he perpetuates the cycle of abuse. Despite returning to Prime being his motivation, it is harder to say that Hordak is forced to perpetuate the cycle of abuse for Prime considering how far they are removed from each other by both time and space.
Catra, in contrast, is always within the reach of punishment and consequence from her abusers, with the only semi-comparable moment of removable being when she was sent to the Crimson Waste, and then there was the whole thing with Shadow Weaver and Adora that changed the entire situation there, whereas Hordak did not have a similar gutpunch at the time.
Furthermore, Catra was sent on a suicide mission to the Waste - she wasn't supposed to survive, but she was given the hope that if she did and succeeded, she would be reinstated (a mercy granted to her by Entrapta, not Hordak, who seemingly gave that slim hope to her only because it would mean Entrapta wouldn't hate him for killing her friend. This way he has plausible deniability in her death). Hordak was sent to die with no hope or promise of return to the only life he had ever known and instead of inventing his own freedom, he invented his own twisted redemption arc to come crawling back.
8) I'm not even going to get into discussing the gulf between the gay and/or female part of the fanbase and the straight and/or male part of the fanbase that sides with Hordak (he also has female fans, I won't deny that, but all of the ones that I have seen are either straight or bi and attracted to him, which is entirely different thing from in depth character analysis and might have no correlation with actually excusing his actions). However, I will say this: many people see an asshole that they know in Hordak. They can name a man who did the bare minimum (AKA stopped being an asshole with no apology or barely any, which is exactly what he does onscreen in canon, regardless of intent afterwards) and was immediately given the benefit of the doubt and excused for their actions.
It's annoying as hell to see someone given a free pass because they're a man who did the bare minimum, especially when people then attack Catra, who did more than he did to correct her mistakes. The way Catra is treated is a double standard rooted in centuries of misogyny and lesbophobia, whereas Hordak is a male character allowed to get away with the things male characters always get away with. What you are seeing Hordak "go through" (he isn't actually going through it, he isn't real) is only a portion of the vitriol aimed at Catra, any female characters with similar qualities, or even the female fans themselves. So yeah, a lot of the people in the fanbase don't like him, because they've seen him over and over, either in stories or in real life.
tldr; The long and short is that Hordak overall created more harm than Catra personally did, he is less sympathetic overall, he takes less responsibility for his actions, and he improves far less on screen (regardless of the intention for his continuing arc off screen). That is why people who like Catra can also dislike him.
A Genie offers you one wish, and you modestly wish to have a very productive 2017. The genie misunderstands, and for the rest of your life, every 20:17 you become impossibly productive for just 60 seconds.
“Well, it was a nice day.” You kiss your sweetheart gently on the forehead and sigh as the last remaining seconds of 20:16 tick away. “See you at 8:18,” you say.
Then it happens. Every ounce of fatigue or hunger leaves your body. The face of your beloved is perfectly still, their expression exactly the same. The ticking of the clock on the wall has stopped. Once again, it’s 20:17.
You stretch your arms and walk to the table with the homework for the three doctorates you’re working on. The work is mentally stimulating and enjoyable, but it’s finished far too quickly. You check your pocket watch and see that not even one hundredth of a second has passed.
You knew it was too soon to be able to see any movement on the watch, but you can never quite help yourself from looking early on every 20:17. Time to move on.
You clean your home, do your budget, then go outside and fix a noise that your car was making earlier that afternoon. (Oh how you already miss afternoons.) Then you go back inside, boot up your computer (which magically speeds up to keep pace with you as long as you’re in contact with it) and check for any new orders.
You’ve set up a website for the small business you started called “Magic Elf Services.” People in your area can pay a modest fee on your site to have different tasks and odd jobs done by “The Magic Elf” at 8:17pm every day. It was a little slow to get started, but word has spread and these days you have a steady stream of clients.
The money that comes in from the business is nice, but you’re mostly grateful that it gives you a clear list of things to do. You print off your updated list of clients, step outside, and start making your way through the neighborhood with your to-do list.
There’s the apartments down your street where several neighbors have hired you to tidy up, do the dishes, and mop the floors. You do the windows too, just to see if they notice. There’s the large house across town that paid the “Magic Elf” to clean out the gutters. After the first dozen jobs are done, you manage to stop looking at your pocket watch.
As near as you’ve been able to determine in the past, 20:17 seems to last for approximately one normal year. But it’s not exact. For one thing, it’s hard to keep track of “time” when everything but you has crawled to an almost total standstill. For another thing, time seems to move differently depending on how “productive” your behavior is. One time you tried to spend all of 20:17 sitting at home in your pajamas, but that was getting you nowhere, so you eventually gave up and got busy. (Though you defiantly stayed in your pajamas the whole time.)
During 20:17 your body doesn’t get tired, hungry, sick, or injured. You’re essentially tireless and immortal for the duration of the “minute.” So sleeping or eating away your boredom has never really worked for you.
One of the houses on your list forgot to follow the instructions and leave a key for you to get in. At first you figure you’ll just send them an email telling them to pay more attention and that you’ll do the job tomorrow. Then you decide to go home, get your locksmith tools, and come back.
After finishing up all the jobs on your list, you go into several other homes and small businesses in the area, performing tasks you hope they’ll find helpful, and leaving a hand-painted business card at each one. (The business cards don’t contain your real name just in case somebody thinks “The Magic Elf” should be subject to breaking and entering laws.)
Speaking of laws, you head down to the local police station to pick up your case file. You’ve been in contact with a detective who’s been investigating corruption within their department, and your ability to investigate unseen and get in almost anywhere between the ticks of the clock has proven invaluable. You see that they’ve also added five missing person cases to your file this evening, which certainly raises your interest in the job.
You make your way through town gathering evidence, and start making your way to the outskirts of town. Since you happen to be out that way (and you’ve already solved three of the five missing person cases) you decide to swing by the stone castle you’re building and do some more work there.
The castle walls stand about 20 feet right now, but you know they’ll be much higher when you’re done. You’re far from any roads and pretty safely tucked away, so for now it’s your little secret. You’ve been excavating and moving all the rock yourself, which has been much easier than you first expected since your body doesn’t get tired or sore. You’ve also got a nice system of tunnels going underneath the castle, and you dig and build more of that network for a while.
All that time spent underground has left you feeling rather lonely, so you walk back home to see the face of your sweetheart. Their facial expression has moved ever so slightly since you last saw them, which is a comfort to you. Looking at them gets your imagination going and makes you dream up a story you’d like to tell, so you sit on your couch, plug in your laptop, and write a book.
After you finish editing the last chapter for the third time, you finally allow yourself to look at your pocket watch again. Three seconds have officially passed so far.
Wow. Simply beautiful. Kinda expected more than three seconds to have passed and j love that it surprised me. Made me feel immersed in the feeling of the character.
Thanks! That’s definitely the reaction I was hoping for. :D
On a side note, I did the math and figured out that if the whole minute felt like approximately one year, then three seconds would feel like about 18 days. Of course that’s without sleeping, so it would be almost 440 hours of productivity (roughly approximate to 11 weeks worth of work shifts for a full-time job.)
Reblogging this for no reason in particular other than the fact that I’m putting one of my kids to bed for the fifth time tonight, and I was re-reading some of my favorite posts from the past while I wait for them to fall asleep.
I'm still reading you latest awesome essay but I wanna point out before I forget in the process: Shadow Weaver as you said used Adora as a puppet against Catra, and then almost immediately Light Hope does the same by using fighting simulations that are designed to make She-Ra comfortable into killing Catra and "letting go"
:: Adora and the darkness within-
Hey! Thanks so much for the kind review! And thanks for bringing this up, because you're exactly right. It not so cute like it seems- (Adora is completely useless in s2ep1 the second Catra shows up ☺️- turning her sword into a coffee mug and a flute!? lol!!) We are, indeed, actually seeing something that is very scary-
But it couldn't possibly be that, right? After all, Adora wouldn't really do it, because when she puts her sword to Catra's throat in White Out, Catra then flirtatiously teases her...
.. Sadly, that's not the end of this, Adora does internalize to this brutal conditioning after all. (spoiler warn ⚠️) Adora does continue drilling hard on the idea of killing Catra. And, she almost does so- if you don't know to what I'm referring, it has to do with the one other 100% canon SPOP source material- I'll cover it below in the spoiler section.
Just... know that Adora really does internalize this concept-that she must kill her best friend for 'destiny'... (more later.)
It's this belief in 'destiny' by which Light Hope is still able to continue to manipulate Adora, even after she refuses to leave her friends behind, to "let go". Destiny is a concept that's so important to Adora's perception of self value that Light Hope uses it against her, towards the goal of her evil purposes, and of getting Adora to "let go." If Light Hope can get Adora to kill Catra, that's a whole lot of 'letting go' all at once. It would have broken Adora, she never would have recovered. It's so terrifying.
Where does this belief that Adora must do anything to fulfill 'destiny' come from, why is she so concerned with it that she stops thinking any further? Why must it be Adora's burden to do this ?
We know Adora does show wisdom, by refusing to leave her friends behind- she's not willing to give in to Light Hope's idea that she should seclude herself in the woods. Yet, isn't Catra also Adora's friend- one which she hurtfully turned against for what is a false destiny, and whom she is now plotting to kill ?
What's really going on is super ugly- despite the cute undertones to lighten the mood. Light Hope is using Adora's sense of duty against her to get her to potentially do something that's very hurtful to herself, and to the person who loves her most. What's so wrong with Adora's 'destiny', that she's got to kill someone she loves? How can that be right, is the war even what we think it is, and is killing Catra for it the right choice ?
Why- that's the big question. Why is it Adora's, or She-ra's, job to save the princesses from the Horde? Why does Angella feel the need to make this Adora's burden? Could the Rebellion really not have done it themselves, or did they just give up out of grief? As Catra says in s5ep9: "Why does it have to be Adora?"
Like Catra says in s5- this is exactly right: all throughout SPOP, nothing about Adora's situation is right, or fair. Everyone is just forcing their burdens on her... and she ends up a desperately anxious person because of it.
And it's all a lie, a set up to make Adora fail- just like Mara did.
Like Mara, Adora was "never meant to succeed. They made a plan for (..her)"- it's history, all over again, and everything Adora thinks she's doing for 'destiny' and to end the war is part of this lie. That includes the 'destiny' as Angella describes it for her: it's just another likely set up: "I know the legend of warrior of the one the First Ones called She-ra, they said she would return to us in the hour of our greatest need to bring balance to Etheria". How, exactly ? By winning the war at any cost ?
This is also almost certainly a myth started by the First Ones to prepare the next She-ra for failure, as part of their plan to use the weapon. A deception implanted within cultural beliefs, meant to further enable their betrayal- Light Hope and the First Ones never had any intention of bringing balance to Etheria, they only wish to use the weapon. And again, why is it Adora's job to save the rebellion from the horde???
Angella and the rebellion gave up on that all on their own, back when Adora was just a small child. Also... keep in mind that Shadow Weaver was allowed to run to the horde, and consequently left with no accountability and complete control over little Adora and Catra, which she used to abuse the heck out of them. So why is this supposedly Adora's burden?? There's nothing fair about it.
We see that Adora feels legitimate anger, desperation, and sorrow from how she's been forced into her position- everyone is hurting her with their burdens. It puts Adora in a constant state of anxiety, and her feelings of frustration and anger at this is well deserved.
But... what's so interesting about Adora's situation is that her anger towards Catra is perhaps the least deserved, even though Catra is fighting against her in a war which is wrong. Adora might feel mad at Catra for refusing to go along as she enacts her beliefs and this 'destiny', instead making it harder by fighting back against her, and yet, Adora's not even doing the right thing in the first place as her entire destiny is a lie to use her as a weapon. Catra simply refuses to just accept her friend as this person who just turns on people who mean something to her, supposing evil upon them all. Adora really is doing the wrong thing by enabling Light Hope's evil... and she can't even see it...
Well... what Angella told Adora about her 'destiny' seemed to make sense- and so she went with it. She's there to "bring balance" through 'destiny' by saving them from the Horde. So, for 'destiny', she assumes that she needs to be willing to do whatever she has to win that war- she has to hurt Catra...
Deception, and more deception- what even is the war on Etheria ? Where does Hordak even come from, other than Light Hope purposely crashing him on Etheria to set a conflict? It's not Adora's fault that the rebellion couldn't deal with Hordak, she was a small child when the rebellion fell apart. And Adora's agreeing to win this war at any cost is a bridge too far... if she were to kill Catra, the damage to herself... it would be beyond comprehension. When we see her talking to Light Hope in s2ep1, we finally get to see how Adora is all kinds of hurt by Catra's refusal of her, she's all broken up inside: "she's in my head". Catra wasn't supposed to be Adora's enemy: Adora couldn't realize this, and she made her one by essentially giving in to the prejudicial views of the rebellion.
Long story short, the war isn't quite what we think it is. Instead- who, really, are She-ra's greatest enemies? Next to Horde Prime and the First Ones, Hordak hardly even measures...
Adora's biggest enemy, as She-ra, is, in fact, the First Ones: and we know that because of Mara. We know Horde Prime must have existed in Mara's time, yet Mara considered her own people, and the weapon which they created, to be so much greater an enemy that she gave up everything to stop them. And just like Mara, what the First Ones want to do to Adora is so evil it outweighs anything having to do with the war on Etheria- the entire planet is at stake if Adora doesn't wake up to the reality of how the First Ones wish to use her for their evil...
What the First Ones did was always the original betrayal..
But, Adora is a soldier, and so she has a really hard time realizing this. Light Hope uses her belief in 'destiny' and duty to manipulate her- as a soldier, Adora does what she told (within reason) because what Light Hope tells her is what she expects to hear. Light Hope tells her that killing Catra will end this war, so she drills the moment of killing Catra to do it. What act is too much, what price is too high, what cost to her own morality is too dark? How terrifying it would be if Adora actually did kill Catra...
So, here's the warn for LotFP spoilers 🚨🚨 -more good discussion is yet to come- and I promise not to spoil anything more than necessary for you folks-
💞🏳️🌈🌹
(If you really don't want spoilers, now's your chance)
So... Adora does actually make the decision to try to kill Catra.
In LotFP, it's obvious that Adora had continued drilling the idea of killing Catra, over and over, with Light Hope following White Out. Because- like in White Out- Adora gets a chance to hit Catra- and this time she doesn't hesitate.
Adora consciously attempts to kill Catra. Keep in mind that Adora still had no idea how to heal at that point. Why does Adora try to do that, and what makes her believe she has to do it?
*(p.s- I won't go over how LotFP happens after s2ep5, but if you've been wondering when it took place- yup)
The rebellion may talk a cute game around being more humane with war... but, that's mostly Bow. When it comes to it, both Glimmer and Adora at times take actions that cross the line into the downright sinister to end the war- no act is too dark for them. Adora comes terrifyingly close to killing Catra because of it...
Luckily for Catra, in the moment of Adora's brutal confusion and attempt to take her life, Catra finally has someone in her life that will take care of her, and Scorpia steps in to protect Catra.
Scorpia then rightly tells Adora off for her continued, out of control, bloodlust towards Catra, willing to murder her friend for what turns out to be an evil destiny, anyways. Catra was never planning to take things that far- she only tries to bring Adora low, or capture her... and to make her see how she's naive. Why should Adora bear such a burden of the war, at such potential emotional cost to herself and to Catra's life?
... Adora ends up suitably chastised for her actions in LotFP, and you can start to see a change in her behavior following it in s3ep3-ep6: she's realized she can't just kill Catra. She also begins to realize that Light Hope has been manipulating her, and that she's been living a lie.
Unfortunately, Adora's actions before this point comes at a cost: SPOP is very clear about consequences: it leaves Catra desperately afraid after seeing the love of her life constantly trying to kill her. Each time Adora sees Catra following Promise, 3 times in total, she ends up trying to kill her- unwittingly during the Battle of Brightmoon, possessed during White Out, and then as a conscious decision in LotFP. Is that acceptable behavior?
This cruel behavior Adora so hurtfully has towards Catra for false destiny sets up Catra's biggest mistake and her following mental break down:
Catra desperately looks elsewhere for any kind of support- the person she loves wants to kill her... Hordak is being hurtful and threatening her: So, Catra decides to try to trust Shadow Weaver. After all, why not- nobody can be THAT evil, right??? She must have SOME humanity...
That's a mistake, as Shadow Weaver is all bad, and all that Catra gets for trusting her is more horrible emotional wounds and so much more damage that by the time Adora sees Catra in s3ep3, she's one bad hit from totally losing her mind. And the hit comes... and she does... and Adora simply cannot reach Catra through her grief and her anger.
Even though Adora changes her behavior towards Catra in s3ep3-ep6- showing deference for her past mistakes, love for Catra, humility, Catra is too far gone to hear it- she only sees protecting herself from further harm at any cost- that includes pulling the switch and winning the war. It was how she was going to finally be safe...
Everything proceeds to fall apart, so much chaos ensues. One thing that's so scary about Adora's behavior is that it shows she was fighting while having no idea where her line was: what action was too much, too sinister, for her 'destiny'? She didn't really understand her own feelings, her own darkness.... and if Adora had taken Catra's life... it's real scary to think about. Fighting without understanding your own convictions is always scary, which it was for both Adora and Catra.
And so, by the time Portal happens... there's not much Adora can do for Catra. She's too hurt to hear Adora's pleas of love. All she can really do is ask Catra to be better, to heal herself. As Adora says:
"You made your choice, now live with it!*
*WOMP*
She's right, Catra can't live with it, and we see this in s4 as her anger begins to breaks down into something else.
Catra is stuck in a downward spiral, and at least Adora is always trying to be better. Can we say the same about Catra? No not really.
One last thought-
Scorpia is a good, smart, interpersonal person, she realizes Catra's needs, she protects her like no one else ever has, including Adora. Yeah, Catra doesn't really deserve her, (also, Scorpia was always Catra's best option for support, something Catra should have worked harder at accepting), but it's really good for people like Catra to see someone show care for them, besides. And, Scorpia also stops Adora from doing something she herself never would have recovered from.
Hooray for Scorpia! Hooray!! Without her, no kiss, no saving the universe. Hooray for Scorpia!! She's the best- 🖤♥️🤍
Happy 1 year anniversary to Catradora canon!! 🎉🏳️🌈 💞🎉🥰
Everything in SPOP is always a team effort. Adora has a lot to thank Scorpia for, too... after all, she saved Catra from Adora's own hurtful confusion. How scary it is that she came so close to taking the life of her future lover... 😥
Thanks as always for a like or a ✨✨✨rebloggg✨✨✨ and let me know if you have questions or concerns! I will gladly answer them-
With Love,
~EtheriaDearie
::Here's a link to the original post to which this refers- all links are on tumblr
🥰 Got time for one more fast and fun read about Catradora love to help the author out? Check on this quick read-💞🏳️🌈
LotFP = Legend of the Fire Princess
Here's the total list of more reading if you'd like-
Hey! I just found your blog and I've gotta say, your analysis for the characters and episodes are incredible! They're so engaging and intere