No, I think I will read any “[biological] sex is real” statement as a transphobic dog whistle, actually, especially since iirc, it’s how Joanne started signaling her descent into TERF/transphobic politics, specifically by tweeting out “sex is real.”
Context: Just read “Of Course Biological Sex Is Real” by Sam Killermann. I can’t find the date on the article. Maybe I’m digging up years old discourse. I guess even if he’s moved past this himself, it’s still relevant to our world today.
Not to get too ✨radical ✨with it, but I’m starting to think “sex is real” as a concession is how we backslid into the current cesspit today, where people want to act like trans women have every single possible advantage ever in sport because of testosterone is, like, the juice that ascends you to godhood or some shit (with of course the in-built assumption that a trans woman’s T levels will automatically be the same as a cis man’s. nevermind either the fact that cis women do, indeed, have T in their veins…). Like, the idea that “sex” as a barrier is just too hard for anyone to ever overcome thus pigeonholing us back into “silly rabbit, girls are inherently fragile!” They’re gonna start saying that “girl math” is biologically true next by using some poor trans woman mathematician as the vehicle for “proof” that only someone with “biological advantage” could be talented at math, I swear.
Apparently this has been on my mind this past week because apparently we’re on some kind of new character arc but I just … yes, okay, my flesh exists (unless you’re having an existential crisis), my meatsuit is real, but the thing about the meatsuit is that it is actively mutable and changeable. The human being is not so easily categorized into two distinct sexes that can never cross. If this was the case, medical transition wouldn’t do anything to the meat, except oh wait, it does. It literally does.
It’s just — sex is a social construct. My appendix exists, sure, but I could easily take it out, and also, being an appendix-haver does not make me inherently biologically stronger and more advantaged at every single task in existence. Being born with an appendix and then having it removed would not somehow mean that my appendix-having status never changed. I literally would not have an appendix. No one on the street would be calling me an appendix-haver unless they had a vested interest in assigning an inherent value to the appendix and had decided they could Tell that I used to have one.
If sex was “real,” you wouldn’t have to alter a percentage of people at birth to fit the binary that allegedly is “inherent” to human beings.