I've been struggling with how to articulate this but while yes, romance novels can and should be taken seriously and read critically and analysed like any other book can be analysed, it has to be done with the knowledge that the logic of the genre supercedes everything. So much of the romance novel conceit is that It Works Out for the protagonists because that is the central premise of the genre and the deal is that you, the reader, will engage with the text accordingly and suspend whatever cynicism or real-world problems would prevent this particular Happily Ever After. Of course we know that childbirth has historically been dangerous to women but when the Regency heroine is pregnant in the epilogue, we are meant to understand that she will have a bunch of kids and live a long and happy life with her duke because that's the point of the HEA. When you get to the end of a romance novel and the protagonists take a big and potentially risky swing at life in order to be together, you are supposed to understand that It Works Out for them! This is romance novel logic! It's wish fulfilment! If your critique of a romance novel ending boils down to "this would not Work Out in the real world" then you have failed to understand the text for what it is, just like "if she just hadn't left the house she wouldn't have been eaten by zombies" is a failed understanding of how horror movies work








