Hi Mark! I have been a huge fan of the UB sets we've gotten so far (both in flavor and gameplay), I had a blast with Edge of Eternities and have no beef with the new aestetic territory Magic has been pushing into (I loved the feel of Thunder Junction.) As a player since Revised, I feel like Magic is only getting better as time passes. I am also a huge Star Trek fan (the Star Trek game from Decipher was also one of my first CCGs).
Even with that high praise, I'm really struggling with the idea of Star Trek in Magic for a pretty simple reason. There's plenty of people who Gather in Trek, but there is no Magic. Star Trek might be the closest thing to true "hard" science fiction in pop culture. For any given technology or event in Star Trek there is an attempt to ground it in actual current day theoretical science. I can't explain how a replicator works or how those time travel gates in City on the Edge of Forever function, but I know there's someone out there who can, and it'll be grounded in some kind of real-world hypothetical principle.
All of our standard legal UB sets so far are in universes that have magic. There are lots of science fiction properties that cross into science fantasy (maybe a big one owned by the people who also own Marvel, for instance) and use magic. Edge of Eternities showed us that space fantasy is a great fit. Star Trek just isn't space fantasy.
I'm excited to see Magic explore other properties, I just would really prefer Magic to have magic, not to put magic in properties to fit them into Magic. I really love both magic and Magic and would prefer them to overlap.
I'm sure I'll enjoy the gameplay, the work you guys are doing is phenomenal, and I appreciate you taking the time to give me this venue to be an old man yelling at clouds.
P.S. Jaws III: The Revenge pretty clearly establishes that the shark/sharks have some sort of supernatural gene-memory and tracking powers or something, so that one sits just fine with me. I assume that's why the property was chosen, I appreciate that careful consideration.
Avishkar is a world of invention, where magical spells are represented by the use of technology rather than magic. Did that upset you?
i know MaRo won't even read this reblog and his attitude will never change but like, good god man this is such a disgusting response to this guy who had nothing but positivity to share. he very explicitly said he likes UB and will play and likely enjoy the set anyway and just wanted to express concern about the fit and theme, and here comes MaRo (head designer mind you) with some snarky crude high school mean girl ass reply that sidesteps and ignores everything he said. disgusting, horrendous work, do better.



















