@tale-xistime , you make valid points. Honestly, I have divorced myself from the show by inches since season 5. I felt that once they embraced the idea of Daddygate for as long as they did they put the characters in an untenable situation they couldnāt easily undo. If you think of someone as your FATHER for 2 years (the timing is iffy but it was for a long while they embraced that particular lie) you change how you interact with them, you change how you allow yourself to think of them.
Even these two f-ed up people. Resurrecting Lizzington after Liz accepted for so long that he was her father was, at best, disturbing. Even in fanfiction, I have not seen a well thought out, well written, not skeevy approach to untangle that mess that makes any psychological sense without it ooking me out.
But the show really put the gun to their own head, in my mind, when they had the audacity to ignore the hanging threads that they left (Lizās second memory wipe, the absolute shift in her attitude towards Red from one episode in season 3 to the next, the ignoring of the fact Red never lied to Lizzy and the breadcrumb trail heās been leaving since the pilot, etc) for our conspiracy theories and jumped off the bridge of audience-baiting instead of just skirting the edge like they had been doing with the one-two-punch of Keenler and **spitting** taking Redarina seriously.
For the first, I know many of my favorite fans on Twitter and Tumblr support Keenler and I donāt want to offend, but for me I never saw the foundation for it other than Diego and Megan were young and pretty together and their characters were alone and, maybe, lonely.
I loved them as partners and close friends. Resslerās boyscout nature to hold the line and Lizās ability to play in the grey areas and make the hard choices. THAT was an awesome partnership.
No. I could only see them hurting one another. Red could handle Lizās nature of not being held by the rules but every time Liz walked on the dark side she would disappoint and hurt Ressler and, while thatās great drama for work partners to deal with, itās not healthy for romantic partners.
Itās their characters, how theyāre wired, that made them a bad match, imo.
And maybe the reading of the pilot script in which Ressler was originally older and disliked/distrusted Liz from the start played a part, too. Honestly, I like his character. Heās come a long way and held up under tremendous pressure with those plot curve balls he got to field. That pressure made him more of the man he was, not less. He stayed the line even when he strayed a little. Liz, on the other hand, went FAR afield. And that was great for their friendship because then he had support and lack of judgement when he pulled himself back. But as romance? No. I felt Liz was NOT a good and healthy match for him. She would wreck him, and at her leisure and without much thought about it, too. Red could take that and push back and remain as he was (he SOMEHOW got over her faking her own death, fcol), but Resslerā¦would eventually resent her. So for the Keenler angle, yeah, I could see them sleeping together in the heat of the moment - that is actually kind of canon for him - but not a true lasting romance.
And, I would have accepted the Keenler falling into bed angle if it was genuine, but it wasnāt. It was just sh*t-stirring by the creators/writers. Iām actually surprised that fans of his character werenāt more offended by this, by Liz using him like that and him letting her. If I were less focused on the core characters of the show (Liz and Red) and more about the tertiary characters, this wouldāve pissed me off. But what was beyond the pale for me was the show jumping off into taking the second point seriously: Redarina.
This so-called theory gets me so angry and stirred up for so many valid and reasonable reasons that Iām not even going to get into it. Itās well rebuffed in many a Tumblr post. I will simply state that itās ridiculous and wrong for so many reasons just like Daddygate was but far more objectionable. And every time Liz was baited by the writers by such things, I lost more and more respect for her character and her original abilities as a profiler, as well as my faith in the writers/creators of the show.
The bottom line is they took a strong, beautiful, brilliant, moral, compassionate character, who was light and life to Red and RUINED HER, all to toy with the audience/fandom. And, make no mistake, the writers/creators thought it was FUNNY to toy with the fans, to set them one against another over the most ridiculous ideas instead of doing their JOBS by writing clever and compelling characters and storylines that hid the truth in the scripts. It seems that once the fandom worked out FRed the writers decided they didnāt want to be clever anymore. No. I lost faith in them long before this ending.
Lizzington will always be real to me. But IF I were to remain in this fandom (lets be clear: writing Lizzington or doing art, NOT watching the show), most of season 5 and the whole of the rest of the series would have to be rewritten and would go AU. To me, that is almost an insurmountable amount of Fix-it. Which is sad. I miss the heyday of TBL, when we could discuss honest theories based on clever clues folded in by talented writers who respected the audience to be more than a mob. That said, Iāll still give a like to #Lizzington if it pops up on my dash. Why wouldnāt I when Iām such a sucker for #RarePairings, which, after all, is what Lizzington has turned out to be.