-_- So you know that I’m not saying that the way misandry is used and has been historically used is bad, right?
I thought I was done with this drama. I thought I could move on.
But I swear to fuck that I would never have thought that it would be necessary to make a post clarifying what I meant by “misandry is real”.
Misandry, as a phrase used by men to criticise feminism, is not a valid concept. It’s a phrase whose etymological and historical roots lie in criticism from the 19th century against first wave feminism, more specifically against the suffragette movement. I agree with this stance. I support this stance. I am myself fairly hostile to cis guys on principle because they’re kinda dickish. I consider myself a feminist.
This does not mean that when you say “misandry isn’t real” that I’m not going to get my tits in a knot because the way in which the message was delivered was broadly applied in such a way that it threw transmascs under the bus.
I am not transmasculine. I am not a flavour of nonbinary either, although one of my headmates is (Lowe uses She/They). I am, however, conscious of the fact that transmasculine and trans masc people within the overall trans community are often overlooked, treated as secondary, and constitute a superminority of our overarching minority. Statistically and representationally they are often screwed over and it is boneheaded blanket statements like the one issued by the official HDG server that contribute to this erasure of those people.
As a result of overly defensive responses to my callout post, I have received a fair amount of backlash. I do admit that I did not respond to a lot of this with the greatest grace or maturity, for which I apologise. I am only human, don’t jump me for being a bitch on the odd occasion.
However, I am also being targeted as if I am defending the concept of misandry as perpetuated by the MRA movement that is currently the most aggressive users of the phrase. This is an unfair assertion. Admittedly, it is my fault for being an aggressive reactionary and for immediately getting as vitriolic and combative as humanly possible in the face of criticism. However, anyone who knows me should be aware that this is a fucking Tuesday for me. I am a combative, fairly hotheaded individual who does not react well when I experience pushback, and I will add that I do not consider this a healthy behaviour of mine and am stricing to fix it.
but it’s kinda out of line to treat me as if what I’m saying doesn’t carry any sort of weight, especially since the overwhelming response to criticism by the clerks and the HDG discord server higher ups has been to double, triple, and quadruple down on the implications of transmisandry by frequently referencing Whipping Girl as if Whipping Girl is a perfect text that universally addresses the issues of feminism and intersectionality without having had to have several revisions and an admission by the author of being unintentionally biased towards a white transfemme perspective. Which is admittedly the author’s own and sole experience, but as an asian transfemme it is distinctly uncomfortable to see this being touted as wholly reliable for an argument about misandry sparked by a post which didn’t need to be made to begin with.
Like, I have to make this clear, as an author in the HDG community I have seen zero evidence to suggest misandry was being levelled at or against the HDG community, or that MRA influences were creeping into the metafiction as a whole. This post was made in such a way that it was both alarmingly ignorant of the fact that there are more than just transfemme voices in the community, but also seemingly made because apparently we as a niche kink fiction community need to be taking political stances. I read and write HDG to escape from the corpofascist bullshit of the real world. I do not need it encroaching on the community surrounding the stories.
We’re all in this together, folks, maybe we shouldn’t be throwing each other under the bus or making unnecessary political statements that literally nobody was discussing three days ago.