just a little mix of the previous post
1st time writing smut with @d1losercore so wish us luck!!
proofread by me (worst writer in the world bc i didn't listen to my english teachers 🥀).. mostly written by @d1losercore cause she doesn't have her compuhter </3 (bum)
He hadn't even known why he'd agreed to this.
A few hours ago, you had shown up to his door, like usual. The two of you, just.. hanging out and having a good time- ENTIRELY NORMAL. He had no clue what had sparked the idea in the first place, maybe it was him falling off the map in Mariokart- falling into the water and leading Lakitu to save his ass.
Whatever it was; it had given you a brilliant idea.
He could only really imagine what his face looked like when you popped the question, I mean, you KNEW how much he hated water- and still you uttered the idea: "Hey, Ben..maybe we could go to the lake or something? I could teach you how to swim?"
Half of him felt so stupid for agreeing, while the other half was too excited at the simple idea of seeing you in a bikini to think straight. I mean, he was jittery even thinking of it now- but with the edge of the water rippling by his feet, he was starting to have doubts.
And just as so, he started bitching: "Uh..(Reader)? Are you....sure we really have to do this? I know I agreed and all, but it just looks so...deep. And gross! Can't we start at a shallower end or something..?"
He had to stop himself from swallowing the mere words- I mean; wimping out like this in front of a friend he'd been crushing on for weeks? There's no way he could fumble like this, he knew he couldn't turn back, so maybe you'd go easy on him?
But what was he thinking? Knowing you, he'd be black and blue by the end of his sentence.
"Or not? I mean either way I'm--"
He couldn't even close his mouth before the sharp pain of your palm hitting his cheek seared through him
"Seriously Ben!? This is like- the fourth time you've done this shit! For god's sake, do you know how much spray deodorant and dry shampoo you take up alone just because of your silly little fear of water? I mean, come on! We packed floaties for you last time and you still wouldn't even touch it! I doubt you'd be able to this time either with all that nasty ass oil in your hair- when was the last time you even showered!?"
You just started chewing into him, this wasn't the first time he had pulled this stunt, but you'd be sure it was the last. After all, Jeff had said if you won this little ongoing bet he'd take your next 2 missions; but you weren't stupid- you knew he and Nina had been trying to set the two of you up for a while. It was stupidly obvious how into you he was.
You were aware of his little plan to see you in your bathing suit, he was always rearing to go along with anything if there was a chance for you or another girl to flash him. Fucking pervert. But it's not like you didn't get a bit of glee to see him stare, even if you still wanted to beat his face in.
However so, you couldn't help but feel a little pang of guilt- even disappointment- to watch his face twist in betrayal, eyes watering with the thick blood that you'd come to know him for.
He was touching his cheek, the same spot you had slapped him. His fingers trembled as he grazed the spot, already blotching with pigment following the harsh assault of your palm. The way he stood frozen for that moment was...pathetic really.
It only took a moment for the blood from his eyes to spill into deep tears, a slight huffed whimper escaping his lips from the outburst, eyebrows furrowed into what looked like a mix of anger and shock. You could see the cogs turning behind his eyes, and you knew he was going to pull something.
After all, you'd recognize that expression from anywhere.
In just a moment (2 screen refreshes if he were to say it) BEN had bolted- or at least tried to.
You had grabbed him by the scruffy back of his hair, tufting it between your fingers as you harshly yanked him back. His flimsy body stuttered back, crumbling in on itself in response as you dragged his sorry ass alongside you and into the water.
It rippled around your calves, the sheer cold of the lake snapping your mind back to the goal- getting BEN to swim.
Of course, his constant thrashing and pleading made it no easier as he desperately struggled against you and the water.
At some point, he just looked like he was shadow-boxing..
With whatever his flailing form was attempting, it proved futile. You both trudged deeper and deeper into the lake, his head bobbing between under the surface as he quickly realized he could no longer reach the bottom. That only freaked him out more.
You heard his gargled whimper as he fought to reclaim air into his lungs, splashing out of the water and climbing up the side of you; "PLEASE! Please-(Reader)-pleasepleasepleaseplease- can we go back!?? Please...I-I can't do it!! Please! (Reader)....please..." He begged in his whiny, obnoxious voice; but it still rang deaf on your ears.
And with that, he had only really pissed you off even more. How much of a pussy could this guy get?
Your hands snarled through his hair as your fists clenched, peeling him off of you like a soggy shirt before you dunked him below the freezing rapids.
You couldn't exactly hear the shrill scream he let out, but you could sure see the bubbles it left behind.
He kicked and clawed at the water and you held him down, repositioning him in between your thighs; belly down so you could pull on his hair with easy access. You saw the murky water mix with the eternal sludge mopping down his eyes, a cloud of vermillion painting the water before you tilted his face back to the surface.
Again- you listened to his sheer cries and begging, loud sobs escaping his throat as he hacked up mouthfuls of water.
"NGhhh..HCKK..PLEase. Pplease-!! (Reader) d-don't do th..HHICK..hhiss!! AGhhhgnnngHHNNg..H-HICK.....nnnmm..." He sobbed and whimpered incoherently, occasionally interrupted by stark hiccups as he gagged out both water and his words.
The sound of his sobs was like music to your ears- you'd never have imagined hearing him beg would make you feel this type of way...and you were nowhere close to stopping.
By the time you'd plunge his head back down, you felt a pit forming in your abdomen, propelled by the squirming he exceeded beneath you.
You yanked his scalp backwards again, liquid flinging out from his hair as he immediately vomited up more water. You felt the quick and heavy rise and fall of his chest as he gagged in huffs of air like his life depended on it...because it did.
You couldn't put into words the sick pleasure you got from seeing him like this, even if you knew it meant he'd stay far away from you afterwards; but deep down....you knew it was worth it.
"aaauUUHHhhnnn...AuhhhAuuhhaHHh...NghhgaagaAUGHhh..hnnn" You craved the heavy whimpers he was pouring out to you, like nobody else in the world could hear it. You squeezed your thighs tighter around him, watching as his panic grew.
His legs kicked frantically as he blurged out more water, spraying from both his mouth and nose as he made a pathetic sort of sound. It only pushed you further, pulling him up by the hair so that his back arched prominently. You heard a fearful hiss of air come from him, he was no doubt wearing the same scrunched up fearful face he'd get whenever Jeff was about to hit him, like a sort of flinch that included a brief shiver.
With that, you wanted to try something. Nina had told you once that elf ears- like those of BEN or Jack- were far more sensitive due to a bundle of nerves near the tip that was originally meant to prevent frostbite by providing early detection; yet it came at the cost of hypersensitivity of the area.
Blow in his ear...it was like there was an evil little devil on your shoulder, rubbing its hands together like a fly before giving you these torturous ideas. And so- you did.
You felt as a jolt went through him, clearly not expecting the moment as he tensed and started jittering- it perplexed you to see, after all, you'd wanted him to yelp or start kicking again, not gyrate.
"(R-read)-" Your name partially scrambled out of his mouth before you jerked him back under the water, invoking the reaction of fighting that you had craved beforehand. You had no clue what the hell that was, but it seemed to make him struggle even harder...
When he suddenly stilled under the water, it had been a few rounds of this back-and-forth, you plunging him underwater and making him a sobbing whiny mess. Your heart skipped a beat, expecting the worst as you pulled him back up.
He was trembling, shaken and betrayed like before, but something was off. You found his pupils blown out, ears tinted pink even though you hadn't yanked them at all. The sensitive way his eyes rolled up to meet yours was just...infuriating. You felt like he'd started to like this in a way, and that simply took the fun out of it.
You hesitated with the idea of dropping him and leaving for good, but the tiny whimpers that escaped him were only making you (and your anger) burn hotter and hotter.
Flipping him so that his back was now facing downwards, you grappled his neck, desperate to elicit more begging from this now broken boy-toy, but it was like his speech was just drowned out.
With this new hold on him, you doused him back under, the muscles in your forearms rippling alongside the water as you watches satisfying little bubbles rush to the surface.
That's when you felt it- a firmness in his trunks.
You didn't believe it at first, thinking it could've been a fish or something.
You groped at it, keeping him submerged under the water whilst a rough spasm shook through him.
He arched up, bucking into your hand whilst clawing at the other one trapped around his throat.
You were perfectly okay knowing that you yourself felt pleasure from this, but having to picture him also getting some was...bewildering to say the least.
Watching his eyes widen in horror under the muck, you lifted your other hand back to his throat, roughly resurfacing him with enough force to give him whiplash.
"W-waittthnn-HICK--hhhUHhhhaiiitt!! Ittshnn'ssnn....shno-aauoot wh-hah-what it l...loo...nhhghNNh.." He sputtered, tripping over his own words as he writhed under you, like a lizard trying to swim away.
Admittingly, it was a little funny to watch him sink and scramble, yet that didn't stop you from making your way back to the mansion; the little freak deserved it.
At this time you didn't know if he'd come back, didn't really care either. You didn't hear splashing behind you so you just assumed he was done for.
Arriving back at the mansion, Jeff was there to greet you, interrogating you to figure out where BEN had gone.
He seemed shocked once you told him, and in a rare empathetic side of him, chose to go looking for him.
"Whatever, as long as you do the missions," you had replied, and that really was the truth.
Sure, BEN was your friend...
But being an asshole just... got you off so well
And you didn't doubt that he'd probably have done the same to you.
Shitshitshitshitshitshitshitshit-!
He spasmed in the depths of the water, both shame and pure fear surging through him. His lungs felt tight, suffocating, familiar.
Adrenaline surged through him as he caught on what seemed like a rock or branch- it didn't matter. He knew he wasn't that deep underwater, but it terrified him nonetheless. Scrambling around near the bottom, he pushed towards the direction he thought was the shore- left? RIGHT? He only felt his panic rise and his heart rate quicken, pushing up from the bottom of the lake and finally breaching the surface.
He took in a large gasp of fresh air, sputtering out some more water like a broken faucet. He heard continued galumphing through the trenchlike flooring of the lake, a pang of guilt and anxiety rushing through him.
Oh my god she's gonna tell everyone
He could feel himself tearing up again, feebly paddling against the now stilling current. Pulling himself up again, he hobbled through the water and miraculously was able to find the shore.
He didn't feel joyful about this though, too ashamed at what had happened to even consider it. Remorse flooded through him like venom, he wouldn't go back home- couldn't, not after what had just happened.
He was convinced that you'd have told the whole mansion about it at that point, aware that you had likely already made it back already as he struggled in the murky waters.
He stumbled away from the lake, wind feeling chilly against his soaked form. He slumped down a nearby tree, holding his abdomen like it would stop the rush of heat he was all too familiar with.
It was disgusting. He knew it.
How something that had killed him turned into this, impossible, he thought. But here he was, grappling with an unexplainable situation, the previous fear turning to only build on the shame.
He felt like he was spiraling, stuck between wanting to vomit or chase after you. As much as he'd hate to admit it, to feeling of you degrading him; hitting him even, he couldn't get enough of it.
Just- your hands. Nobody else's, just YOURS.
He didn't know why but it riled him up just thinking about it, hips stuttering up as if he could force it into existence. Of course, this only made his ears burn hotter, even after what you just did- what you always do, he just keeps coming back.