So Iāve been seeing a post thatās been going around on my dash lately that refutes the existence of Mary Sues entirely. While it makes a lot of good points, what it should be saying is that the term āMary Sueā is thrown around so readily that it doesnāt have the same meaning as itās supposed to, not that Mary Sues do not exist.
Mary Sues exist. That is all there is to it. I will say, yes, the term is thrown around wildly, mainly towards any female character, despite the fact that the male counterpart ā commonly known as a Marty Stu or a Gary Stu ā does exist. But this isnāt a post about blatant sexism.
To give some background information for those of you who donāt know, the term āMary Sueā was coined in 1973 by Paula Smith, in her fanfiction āA Trekkieās Taleā. It actually became quite a huge term and through the 80s and the 90s, female authors would often not include girls in their stories at all out of the fear that their readers would call them a Mary Sue.
āA Trekkieās Taleā was originally satire, but satire has to target something. What is a Mary Sue?
A Mary Sue/Marty Stu is an idealized version of the writer. It is always a self-insert(and yes, it contributes a lot to the hatred of self-inserts), only they are more beautiful and perfect and everyone loves them and they have some sort of deep connection to the protagonist or deuteragonist of a series, whether it be their lover, relative, or apprentice, or whatever else. You can look at some different types here who donāt explicitly fit the definition given right there but are still Sues.
If you would like to encounter a Mary Sue, go ahead and read something like Twilight. And Iām sorry to all Twilight fans, but Bella is a Mary Sue. You could easily get away with reading 50 Shades of Grey to the same effect.
Or you could just go read My Immortal.
(Sidenote: And for those of you who like Kingdom Hearts, Those Lacking Spines is a fantastic satire fic targeting fanfiction tropes of all kinds, focusing primarily on the prevalence of personalities being completely fucked over and ignored for the sake of ~teh yaoizz~, but there is a portion on Mary Sues and itās altogether a pretty enjoyable read.)
Mary Sues and Marty Stus are all over the place, but the terms are used so willy-nilly that not a lot of people know one when they see one. I hope this helps you in identifying a Mary Sue.
For examples of characters who arenāt Mary Sues, please look at the vast majority of every single character out there.
(I can name several off the top of my head that have been called Mary Sues! Lots of characters from Final Fantasy and Kingdom Hearts, I mean. Youāve got Tifa, and Cloud himself, and Kairi. Then Naruto fans like to scream about how Sakura is a Mary Sue just because she likes Sasuke and itās like honey she aināt perfect and he donāt like her back so shut yo mouth. Iāve for some reason never seen a Homestuck character described as a Mary Sue, not even Hussieās self-insert or the Condesce or Bec Noir. Thereās a lot more but this tangent is getting too long and Iām sure you get the idea.)
Also, to wrap it up, not all self-inserts are Mary Sues. I, personally and admittedly, am kind of wary of them because I know from experience how many are, but the biggest reason is that Iām just plain not comfortable bringing my roleplay outside of the land of fiction. But⦠I have seen self-inserts done well, and I do think you should give them a chance or ten before you call it quits.
Same with any other character.
Not everyone is a Mary Sue, though they do exist, and you all are the people who have to know and understand that.
Please be smart with your terminology and donāt throw it around whenever it conveniences you or you donāt like a character. Iāve known so many people who are afraid of making OCs or RPing or writing in general because they donāt want to make a Mary Sue.
And thatās because of people improperly using the term.
Yāall should just fucking relax and have fun I swear to god. Thatās all that fucking matters. If you have fun playing a or playing with a Mary Sue, then cool!! You do that! If you like self-inserts, yeah!! You have fun! If you like anything else, just chill the fuck out and have a good time and stop worrying about shit so much!
But if you wrongly accuse people of being Mary Sues, you are part of the problem, and you need to sit the fuck down.