Watched Odyssey and... I have thoughts (review containing spoilers)
I will say first... the movie is good. It's not a bad movie and it is something I am glad I saw. But I have issues with it as someone who likes mythology and has been very passionate about it since young age. It is a movie that to me has lots of good things about it and... quite a few bad ones. I will start with the good (also this will be LONG):
*THE GOOD*
And to me I think good place is to start is most of the effects (and believe me I will go to the pretty bad one as well). The movie definitely looks quite great, at least from directional standpoint. Nolan is someone who you know can direct and his shots mostly look quite great. The way he frames shots is very good...when it's not in dialogues, but I will get to that too. I especially enjoy the direction with stuff like Circe, Cyclops and the talk between Antinoos and Penelope. I also respect his direction with Sirens... to some extent.
But either way he works well with direction as we all know. I also really appreciate how much practical effects this movie has. I appreciate how many things are actually there like the armored giants who were actually that tall played by 7ft tall actors against 5ft tall doubles.
And I also enjoy stuff that was done partially with CG again like with Cyclops and Circe. Cyclops especially turned out very well from both visual and sound standpoint. His design while weird I do like. I like how deformed he is. That he is not just a big man with one eye. I still like Harryhausen Cyclops more from Sindbad, but this one is very good.
And sound is definitely main star here. The sound of the waves. The clashes. The thunder of Zeus and roar of the Cyclops. That last one deserves an ovation honestly because that was harrowing scream. It was GREAT. It really made you feel the pain that thing was going through.
And some of the casting turned out very well. Robert Pattinsons steals the show honestly as Antinoos. He captures perfectly that slimy, manipulative coward. And Anne Hathaway as Penelope does a very good job as well... which is a problem somewhat because of another actor, but I leave that for later. You can definitely feel and see all the pain and sadness with her and you can definitely feel the warmth of hers as well. She is played very well. And one more standout to me was honestly Eurylochos played by Himesh Patel. I definitely felt for him the most through the entire movie. I liked his relationship with Odysseus and how much he felt like a proper equal to him through this movie. Even if he made his own mistakes.
And I think ideas here are interesting with connecting sacking of Troy with destruction of values of the Greek World. How this is the tipping point to the end of an era, but that honestly feels better as an idea than execution cause umm....
*LE BAD*
Yeah. Let's go to bad.
I will say this right now. Most of the characters in this movie are not that interesting. It's not a hit against the actors cause they all do a passable job, but man. I can't remember almost anyone from this movie and if I do it's either those standouts above or for completely wrong reasons... or because it's Odysseus cause yeah.
I think one of the biggest problems with me in this movie is Odysseus himself. He does NOT feel like Odysseus at all. Matt Damon is playing here a very brooding, sad character with little to no personality beyond "home" and "Troy". That stands out to me because Odysseus while is very dedicated to going back home, he is not boring at all. He is a deeply flawed prick with ego problem. His ego being driving force behind his own disaster of a return. Someone who has very quick wit, sharp tongue and knows he has both.
I do not feel that with this version of the character. He is mostly just brooding and sad. I don't think I saw him smile once in this movie and you may say (well what is there to smile about), but I think it is important to give him a bit of humanity which I think this version is lacking. Matt Damon often times feels like he is kind of phoning it in. His line delivery in many places is quite monotone and his expressions often times leave a lot to be desired. Except Sirens scene. There he played it GREAT. You could tell all the emotions going through Odysseus as he heard them and then how painful it was to leave them. But other than that... could have been better.
Not to mention removal of the famous 'Nobody' line. I know Nolan said he couldn't make it work, but I think it should have been left in because of how much it both says about Odysseus when he comes up with it and gives it up and what it says about being a nobody as well and about ego.
And honestly I do not think Noland "could not make it work" because this pun is not translated well. Let me explain this in this section which will definitely feel the most like a rant.
This version of the Odyssey feels the most Americanized. Now what do I mean by that? Well I want to first say a small thing I know from production of another kind of well known movie, you may have heard about it called Avatar. Where James Cameron funded his crew the most alien sounding music imaginable for his movie and when he heard it he immediately threw it away and told to make some alien "amazing grace" cause he wanted his movie to be understood by all the down south americans.
This movie feels like that. With it's inaccurate costumes, the ships, the fact that Odysseus kneels to Agamemnon which I am pretty sure Ancient Greeks never did before Kings. The fact that it's so grey and lifeless and feels like it could be set ANYWHERE but Greece. Calling Hades HELL when it's NOT HELL AT ALL, portrayal of Gods to be more in line with Christian view of God than actual Greek myths and removal of the line.
And why do I think that? Because this is one of those moments where Odysseus is without any doubt a total unlikeable jerk. And Nolan has that thing where he will say there is nuance to his characters, but then he will make it so things look juuuuust favorably enough to the characters actions so that their brooding comes off as deserved, but you cannot ever truly fault them for their actions. Not completely. Like with Batman in Dark Knight where his love makes him choose wrong, but it's still presented as a good choice he made if Rachel was in the spot Joker told Batman she was in.
Because in this version the reason why Odysseus is punished by Poseidon is blinding Polyphemus. And yeah. If you were typing angrily about me not knowing those names, please stop. I know them. It's just that this movie is not interested in them. And we know it's that because Polyphemus prays to him after he is blinded. That one arrow Odysseus shoots after I do not believe is the reason for punishment cause Polyphemus already whined to his dad. Not to mention that arrow shot either way is far more justified, where the audience doesn't have to question Odysseus's actions as much as they should and find him unlikeable. Also with how the last fight goes.
I like the final fight, but I find some things lacking there. Like Odysseus going completely berserk on EVERYONE there which honestly makes Penelope leaving that traitor maid in there feel pointless cause I do not believe she even died there. She just disappeared from the movie after that... or maybe I missed something. But anyway this feels like a very whitewashed view of Odysseus so audience can feel comfortable with him.
And that to me feels very forced. Because big part of Odysseus's charm is that he is VERY flawed, that he is quick witted strategist, but also a painful narcissist who needs to be humbled. And this movie dumbs that down to it's audience.
And speaking of characters. Hai Agamemnon. Yeah. He is... yeah. He is pretty nothing in this movie honestly. He is just there to aura farm and spout exposition in Hades. And that exposition. Mainly his final word I think is the best encapsulation of Nolan's character writing. His last word being
"assess"
That's it. Assess. And that to me speaks volumes of one thing. Nolan doesn't see his characters as characters. He sees them as exposition/theme machines. Some actors with how good they are can break through that wall and become something great, but not because of Nolan's writing. It's mainly with how the actor plays said character. Like Heath Ledger with Joker. Cillian Murphy in Oppenheimer or Pattinson in this movie. But his characters when they are not carried by GREAT acting often times fall very flat. Kind of tells you a lot why the only thing people talk about in Dark Knight are Dent and Joker.
Entire speech of Agamemnon about his fate honestly just feels phoned in. It feels like exposition. I thought of how I would somewhat write it. It's not much, but I came up with it now
"I came back a hero, but what welcomed me was sadness and hate I sowed when I sailed to Troy. I came back to ruin like the one I left back in Troy... Do not make my mistake Odysseus. Do not come back a hero lest what welcomes you is ruin."
Something of the sort. Where it is not telling us every detail, but giving us enough information to feel what he felt. Where you can tell all the regrets and sadness over his choices and how his words can influence Odysseus's actions. Also if Nolan wanted with his honestly ill fitting voice to show how he was just a normal man beneath the armor then I say he should have showed him without the armor. Where Odysseus at first can't recognize him, but then he sees not a great King, but a small, pitiful man. Also I am not a fan of him just straight up telling what Odysseus has to do in Ithaca.
Which is ironic cause one thing I think this movie should leave in was someone telling what Odysseus has to do. With Scylla. And yeah. Scylla looks TERRIBLE. The CG on her is just bad. You can tell Nolan did not want to make a movie with her at all. That whole scene besides having awful looking monster also lacks emotional weight it should have. In the poem it's not a long section either, but you can feel all the pain Odysseus goes through as he sees his finest men devoured like it's nothing. Where despite being told he cannot fight it he still readies himself to save them, but cannot. A tragedy of helplessness that is missing from this version.
Not to mention how little impact it leaves because right after in the poem on the Helios island his crew partially gives in to eat the cows BECAUSE OF grief over Scylla. Also fun fact about that island. In polish subtitles they FIXED THE GOD THIS ISLAND BELONGS TO. Crazy right? They do not add Apollo into the dialogue, but add Helios later. That is hilarious and shows how... honestly little Nolan seems to care about mythology.
Which sadly you can tell. Because he is definitely way more in love with Troy and Ithaca than anything in between. He loves his dialogues which to me have way too fast cuts, sometimes it feels very rushed how things go in this movie. And this movie just doesn't look like it takes place in Greece at all. Especially with some cast members who look whiter than snow on Laestrygonian island. Honestly I am surprised some weirdos say how this movie is woke when it pretty much whitewashes greece so much.
I know other versions of this story do that too that were put to screen, but it's 2026. I think Nolan could risk it with new talent.
Oh and speaking of Laestrygonians. What was up with that girl and that armor? That looked honestly pretty stupid. Way more silly than the armors from Bronze age that Nolan rejected. Why did he do that? I don't know.
And boy is this a long review. There is so much in it, but I think you get the picture, but I will end it on the other scenes I like and I want to talk about. Something of a stand out section. Let's call it that.
*STAND OUTS*
Obviously one of my main ones is Robert Pattinson, but my favorite scene with him is when he talks to Penelope. Honestly I do think that scene is genius because it not only feels natural unlike so many other dialogues in this movie, but it's honestly a GREAT representation of Siren Song. But in this case for Penelope. Antinoos here being the Siren that wants to seduce Penelope into giving up her devotion and love which contrasts with Odysseus's own scene right after with Sirens. It's a great scene that I think adds a lot of weight to sirens as well.
But Sirens themselves are kind of disappointing. I get what Nolan was going for with not showing them or let us hearing their song, but man it goes over too fast, monologue at the end is distracting and I am sad we do not get even a glimpse of them being avian in nature. Hell just have wind blow one giant feather on the ship to show what kind of monster tries to lure them in. SOMETHING.
Sorry. Sorry. Back to stand outs. Cyclops scene. It removes quintessential line, but from the mood standpoint, the direction and both character and sound design it is amazing. I loved the scream of that thing in the theatre. Granted I did not see it in Imax (thanks Nolan), but it was still great. But it falling asleep after munching on two guys is a bit silly. At least he was just blackout drunk in original.
Also Circe, her scene was amazing from how the effect of the transformation was handled. It was grotesque, horrific and goddamn awesome. It was a great representation of her powers. I just wish she was a bit prettier like a witch from Greek Myths should be and for her crashout to feel more earned because it just sounds like she is ranting at them for no reason.
Also the Zeus punishment scene. That scene I say is underrated. It is mostly dark, but you can feel all the anger Zeus has towards that crew, all that spite and murderous rage as those lightnings flash and complete despair of the crew. THAT scene was good. It felt powerful. But it had a start that felt a bit comedic. With that cutaway to disaster. But it is a great and underrated scene in my opinion.
But there is more than one kind of standout. And this one... is the DUMB one. And I talk here about Odysseus talking about how he ended Bronze Age...
I have so many issues with that line. It's cheesy, it makes no sense (it's like them saying it's 3000 year bc or some other BS like this) and it's so damn stupid. Nolan. I get it. I get what you are going for. But at this point you are using a freaking Jackhammer for that nail. STOP IT!!! It was like one line I was very loud at over how stupid it was. End of Bronze Age just... shut up. Anyway. Moving to finishing thoughts cause... Bronze age. I dunno.
*FINISHING THOUGHTS*
The movie is good. I have LOTS OF issues with it as a mythology nerd and also someone who likes good stories and interesting characters, but overall the movie is NOT bad. I am just seeing lots of flaws in it that irk me and may not feel like much, but they do stack up for me into a pretty weird looking pile. But I can tell why people say it's great. I cannot tell why people say it's utter trash. And I do agree with those that say it's okay, but is very flawed and NOT one of Nolan's best. It's not. And it's okay.
7/10. Glad I watched. I will rewatch some scenes on youtube at most. If I pissed you off with this review I am sorry and that's my opinion. If you agree cool. If you like the movie that's good. If you think it's a masterpiece. I don't agree, but I am glad you are happy.














