Dr Who AU - Every 3 Years
So this is a crazy idea I floated a while back that I'm enjoying tinkering around with, but what if each actor who played the Doctor only did three years each (i.e., the 'Troughton rule'). Now, I'm not saying this timeline is 'superior' to reality or anything, but it's fun coming up with an alternate history for the program...
William Hartnell 1963 - 1966 Patrick Troughton 1966 - 1969 Jon Pertwee 1970 - 1972 Ron Moody 1972 - 1975 Tom Baker 1975 - 1978 David Collings 1978 - 1981 Peter Davison 1981 - 1984 Colin Baker 1984 - 1987 Sylvester McCoy 1987 - 1990 Paul McGann 1996 Christopher Eccleston 2005 - 2007 David Tennant 2007 - 2010 Matt Smith 2010 - 2013 Peter Capaldi 2013 - 2016 Jodie Whittaker 2016 - 2019 Jo Martin 2019 - 2022 Ncuti Gatwa 2022 - 2025
AU History below:
Hartnell and Troughton eras remain largely the same, except - in the interest of giving each actor three seasons exactly, some stories get moved around. 'The Tenth Planet' is now the Season 3 finale, and 'Power of the Daleks' becomes the Season 4 premiere. Two stories from S3 get pulled into S4 (I chose The Gunfighters and The Smugglers) and become 2/Ben/Polly stories before getting back on track with The Highlanders (and Jamie).
Pertwee now does Seasons 7 - 9, all of which remain exactly the same, save for the Season 9 finale, which is now a regeneration story. Either we move The Three Doctors to the S9 finale, or some other story entirely is created - in either case, the exile storyline still ends here with the Doctor regenerating in the presence of Jo, Benton and the Brig, and the Time Lords restore his ability to pilot the TARDIS with a new dematerialisation circuit, and the Third Doctor's last words are, "Well, that's something to look forward to." Why Pertwee leaves is anyone's guess, but perhaps he gets a movie offer that he decides to take up (*coughcoughWillyWonka*).
Faced with having to recast the part, Barry Letts decides to go back and try offering it to Ron Moody again, who had been his first choice but had turned it down saying he didn't want to work on a children's programme. It's a decision he always said he regretted, so when offered the part again, he agrees. His Fourth Doctor is more of an absentminded professor (on the surface) who sings while he works and continues to help out UNIT whenever he's on Earth. He sees of Jo and meets Sarah Jane (and maybe Harry), and he encounters the Master, Linx, and Davros before finally meeting his end in Terror of the Zygons, with Moody deciding to leave to get back to doing films.
Tom Baker is now the Fifth Doctor, making his debut alongside Sarah Jane in Planet of Evil. Seasons 13 - 15 go much the way they did in real life, with him travelling with Sarah Jane, and then Leela and K9. His reasons for leaving are more unfortunate as he finally pushes producer Graham Williams too far and gets sacked, with the ending to Invasion of Time being reshot with a body-double in his costume and a brown curly wig collapsing to the floor (a la Time and the Rani), and a figure in a white dress enters the console room to turn him over as he regenerates into...
David Collings as the Sixth Doctor. I've had him in this role before, so nothing too different from my earlier AUs. He acts alongside K9 and both Romanas, he undergoes the stresses of the Williams era before JNT takes over, with him now being the first Dr to don the dreaded question marks and get a set costume. He departs after Season 18, merging with the Watcher at the end of Logopolis, citing creative differences with JNT.
Peter Davison is now the Seventh Doctor, and his era, much like Hartnell and Troughton's, is almost identical to our reality, with two minor differences -- the 20th Anniversary special is now The Seven Doctors (Hartnell is said to be trapped in a time eddy alongside Tom Baker, and Troughton, Pertwee, Moody and Collings all return with Susan, the Brig, Sarah Jane and Romana respectively) and The Caves of Androzani is now the S21 finale (as it should've been), and the penultimate serial an extra story with Peri, preferably The Rogue TARDIS (and NOT The Twin Dilemma).
Colin Baker is now the Eighth Doctor, with Attack of the Cybermen now his debut story. His era is (sadly) largely unchanged, hiatus and all, but he is successfully able to convince the higher-ups to let him do S24. Mel gets a proper intro story, and he regenerates at the end of Dragonfire.
Sylvester McCoy is now the Ninth Doctor, and he is now a machiavellian Chess Master from the start, with Seasons 25 & 26 otherwise unchanged. JNT is able to keep the series afloat for exactly one more season with Season 27. The finale is the unmade serial Ice Time wherein Ace is written out, with a few dangling plot threads just in case, but the Doctor simply sails off for more adventures, allowing McCoy to be the face of the franchise during the 'Wilderness Years'.
The TV Movie is the same as in our reality, with Paul McGann now the Tenth Doctor.
Big Finish would still make its audios, with Davison, C Baker, McCoy and McGann being joined by Moody and Collings as their respective Drs (Baker still holds out until 2012), allowing many more adventures with their various companions until their deaths in 2015 and 2020 respectively.
Granted, this is all much easier with Classic Who than with NuWho, but for the sake of the experiment, lets continue.
Eccleston is now the Eleventh Doctor, and he would still undoubtedly have his troubles BTS with RTD & co. However, let's surmise that they have him under a three-year contract instead of a one-year, and despite some attempts to get out of it, they keep him on. Perhaps having more time in the role helps him deal with whatever problems he had (unlikely, I know, but still), and he ultimately regenerates at the end of Voyage of the Damned.
Tennant is now the Twelfth Doctor and plays the part from Series 4 thru 6, with a full Series 5 in 2009 instead of a year of specials (maybe Lady Christina as his companion). Series 6 sees him joined by Amy and Rory, much like Moffat's original vision for a series with Tennant, with his Dr regenerating at the end of The Big Bang.
Matt Smith is now the Thirteenth Doctor, and he plays the part from 2011 to 2013, again with a full series every year. He gets a year with Amy and Rory, then a series with a new companion, and then is joined by Clara in his final series - which includes The Day of the Doctor, with Tennant and (hopefully) either Eccleston or McGann (no room for John Hurt, I'm afraid).
Peter Capaldi is now the Fourteenth Doctor, and his first two series are the same as his actual ones. His third series airs in 2016, and he (hopefully) still travels with Bill and Nardole with much the same ending we got.
Jodie Whittaker is now the Fifteenth Doctor, with her first series in 2017 - which I like to think could mean she gets a series with Bill and Nardole (I love the idea of her Doctor continuing giving lectures at the University as if nothing changed). In 2018, she meets Ryan, Graham and Yaz, and we get what we got in our reality into 2019, with her regenerating at the end of The Timeless Children into...
Jo Martin, the Sixteenth Doctor. Maybe her predecessor subconsciously chose to regenerate into her forgotten self in tribute or something. In any case, I love Martin's Dr (or Doc Martin lol) and want to give her a proper era. So she gets a full proper series that airs in 2020, then 'The Flux' in '21, and then one more series in '22 that ends with her regenerating on a clifftop overlooking a sunset...
At last, Ncuti Gatwa as the Seventeenth Doctor, who gets a proper series in 2023, which sees a proper 60th Anniversary special with a few returning Drs, and then gets a series each with Ruby and Belinda as in our reality before regenerating at the end of The Reality War... :P
And that's my latest Who AU. Not remotely likely, especially the NuWho part, but it was fun to put together.



















