lickksss tha screen.,. whos your favorite of the eltingville club and why.,. also whos your least favorite too rolls around
ooo good question!
honestly they low-key have different personalities (not by a lot) in different media (comics and the pilot) so I'll split it up into two!
BEWARE RANTS AHEAD!
WELCOME TO ELTINGVILLE
Peter "pete" dinunzio
i chose him as my first because he honestly has so many funny moments, yes the others do also have funny moments but his are just top tier, also love the accent its absolutely spot on to how I voiced him when I read the comics so thats a plus as well, I cant really get deep into why I like him or why I chose him for first but in my mind he just deserved it for being hella funny, for it being a pilot it was pretty spot on with him so that's another plus, deff my number one in the show
2. William Alan dickey or bill
honestly bill is my favorite for one reason, he's a asshole and I love that, though he wasn't as big of a asshole as he was in the comics he's still pretty close, all of his scenes make me giggle and laugh and squirm while I fangirl, I'm kinda sad that they chose "the head of boba Fett" as the pilot because there are better storylines , but I love how he's more calmed down it adds a little cuteness to him that is very rare in the comics. also the deeper look into his home was another plus!
4. Jerry T. Stokes and Joshua "Josh" levy
honestly in the pilot they were kinda underwhelming I didn't want to put Josh at the bottom though because I love him as a character as well as Jerry, anyways in the pilot they were very underwhelming and didn't have as many memorable moments (except for Josh and bills trivia off and Jerry's multiple lines feeding into Pete or just saying something Jerry coded), anyways they both are great characters but they were just soooo underwhelming to me in the long run
THE ELTINGVILLE CLUB
they are all my favorite!
i love Pete's deep obsession with horror, I also love how it switches from movies and werewolves and things like that to snuff films and torture porn and other deprived things that just adds to the reason why he stays in the club in the first place, i also love his comedic moments in the different issues of the comics, he's very passionate about what media he consumes and he's gonna show it, he's not quite as involved in my opinion as the other three but when its time to shine oh boy does he do it!.
i love bill being a asshole, how he always is so against women, and how all of us as a community all thinks at the same time "I can change him", he spends his everyday hating on everyone around him, he's mean and he's not ashamed about it, not one bit, I mean he literally caused two men who quit being in fandom get back into to it with only being a asshole, is that dedication or what?, anyways his character is so duche bag incel that I just lean towards him overall.
i love how Josh is way sweeter in the comics, still a weirdo like his friends but he's just way more pitiful, feeling like he's getting bullied and other things that just make me wanna give him a big hug, he just has so many problems you audibly just say "aww", he's also bi-curious I think so HAPPY PRIDE MONTH!, anyways just so much depth to his character and the fact that he stole from that store just to get that card to overpass bill really shows his mindset, I love characters like these because you feel sad for them but they are total assholes
i love how jerry tricked everyone into thinking he's this perfect little innocent boy, even though he's in the eltingville club, I love how he's always the voice of reason in every situation and I love how he's just such a cutie, even though he still takes part in the club bullying and activities he's still the only one who stayed alive and changed for the better (Evan dorkin said everyone else died horrible deaths), love how he's into magic the gathering and has his own oc (I also embark in these activities) i honestly love his character and its always so fun to make senarios about him because he's prob just as much as a perv prob even a bigger one than the others and that's just so exciting to me.
thanks for asking!
SUNNY OUTTTT
