Some thoughts on Kuroshitsuji
Lately I’ve been rereading the most recent chapters and, as inspired by bururaven’s brilliant theories, I also have been developing more into common ground, pushing away through the idea that Our Ciel’s name might be related to the Celtic Mythology, more specifically the Irish one, and I’ve also been trying to find a reason for Our Ciel to take his brother’s place. In this article, I’m referring as “Our Ciel” the Ciel we know from the beginning of the manga and as “Real Ciel” his twin brother.
The Earl Ciel Phantomhive
As you might notice, since young both twins had somehow a strong yet sweet and pure personality. That being said, and after the incident that robbed both their families, such purity should have vanished and the sense of individuality should have grown bigger (Our Ciel is a great example for that). That and the fact that true twins hate to be compared with each other (believe me, I know what I’m talking about XD) must have been enough reason for Our Ciel to maintain his true identity. However he didn’t. I have been thinking of some reasons for such, and after reading chapter 133, the most recent one at this time, I stumbled across this panels:
Vincent, apparently, didn’t believe that his younger son would be able to rule the Phantomhive Estate if the Real Ciel died, preferring to renounce to the family title as well as to donate everything to the British Crown. Although I don’t quite believe that much of his believes behind such decision, I do think that the Queen would beneficiate a lot from such. Afterall, the Phantomhives were an influential family and they know lots of dark secrets about the royal family. Erasing such people would be an advantage for her. Now, what if Our Ciel knew it? As we see, in this chapter Our Ciel listened in secret to Frances and Vincent talking about such matters and I’m sure that Vincent should put something important as that in his testament.
This way, I do believe the Queen knew about such, so she probably tried to erase the Phantomhives, burning down their mansion. After coming back, knowing from his father will, Our Ciel adopted his brother’s identity, so that way he could continue with the Phantomhive Estate and the Queen could do nothing about it, since it was legit.
@bururaven suggested that Our Ciel’s name would be based on the Celtic Mythology, probably something connected to “light”. Afterall, sky (“ciel”, in French) and “light” are somehow synonymous, especially in religious terms. I do think that such assumption might have came from the diverse clues that are given to us, for example when Our Ciel named Finnian after one of the most famous heroes from the Celtic (Irish) Mythology book “Fenian Cycle”, as seen in chapter 91 (Greenwitch Arc) or in the cover of chapter 132, when he see the twins reading the same book with their father.
Even though Vincent claims he didn’t named his children (Rachel did), I do consider that he had, at some point, an opinion about the matter, at least when naming Our Ciel. He even claimed that traditional English names:Said that, I do think that Our Ciel’s name could be the one from some character from the “Feninan Cycle”, since ancient Irish Celtic names would obviously fit the criteria Vincent and/or Rachel used.
“But what the hell is the Fenian Cycle actually?”, you might be wondering. Well, Celtic Mythology is divided in 4 major cycles, being the one of the most important ones the Fenian Cycle. It tells the story of Fion mac Cumhaill and his group of soldiers, the Fianna. Such group was formed by the union of two noble families, the Bascna and the Morna. The Morna betrayed the Bascna, killing its leader. Fion was born in the Bascna family and after obtaining revenge on such atrocity, he tasted the Tuna of Wisdom and gets admitted to the court of the king in Tara, where he achieves great things. One day, when hunting, he spotted a fawn, however his hounds didn’t let him killing it and he took it home with him, Turns out the faw was Sadbh, a woman that was transformed in faw by a druid. After some time, Fion had to go outside of his lands, to fight against invasors and Sadbh stayed alone at home, The druid transformed himself in Fion, assuming his identity (just like Our Ciel) and temped the woman outside, where the spell was active. Fion never saw his wife again, but when he tried to search for her, he found that the woman had a son with him, named Oisín (this is supposedly the author of most Fenian Cycle stories).
This whole cyle is quite long, but at the end Fion and the rest of the Fianna die in battle, surviving only two characters, Oisín (Fion’s son) and Caílte (Fion’s nephew – note the similarities with Ciel’s name), probably a connection to the Phantomhive twins. The last one is quite the protagonist in the Acallam na Senórach, the most important text of all the Fenian Cycle. However, this character is portrayed as a fast runner, good at storytelling and had the ability to speak with animals. None of these characteristics resemble Our Ciel.
Analysing Oisín’s story, I do guess we can somehow make some more reliable approaches. After the battle both survived, Oisín felt in love with a fairy, going with her to Tir na nÓg, where he had his famous son Oscar. He then came back to his father’s land, but when he came back he realized that 300 years had passed (3 years passed since the incident that took Our Ciel away from his house). His wife also informed him that he could not touch the soil with his feet, having to walk around by horse always (Sebastian is sometimes referred in the manga as a loyal chess horse, that never leaves its king). However, Oisín ends up touching the ground, becoming an old man and dying.
As you can see, the Fenian Cycle theory still has some flaws, but I do believe that, as such book is shown a lot in the manga it might have some deeper meaning. What do you think? Do you like Celtic Mythology? Could you tell us more about the Fenian Cycle? What do you think of such? Please, tell us! (^-^) See you! o/