There's an anti radqueer subreddit I was stalking.
Tw: Radqueer transIDs mentioned, specifically transage, transracist, and transnazi. You have been warned.
--------------Screenshot--------------
--------------Screenshot End--------------
Maybe. This is a good thing? That people would be uncomfortable with transadults? Do you wanna know why?
BECAUSE. MINORS. CANNOT. TRANSITION. TO. ADULTHOOD.
You grow up. That's what you do, you grow up. But you are still a minor even if you want to grow up faster. You are still a minor even if you were forced to mature faster. You know why? Because your literal physical brain has not yet developed enough to be an adult. You are still not developed enough to be an adult.
This is so so so dangerous because transminors are going to start grooming kids and transadults are going to start falling victim to grooming. Transage is not real.
--------------Screenshot--------------
--------------Screenshot End--------------
Why DO you need to say this? It's. It's almost like a group of people are. Are claiming to transition to nazism.
If you label yourself as transnazi, you are a neo nazi. No questions asked that's what I am going to assume you are. Because you cannot transition to the "concept" of nazism and say that you are against the idiology.
A hyperfixation is not a transition. I'm hyperfixated on radqueers and disorders, don't mean I want to transition to having DID or Schizophrenia or NPD. I have atypical dysphoria but I'm not transitioning to a genocidal idiology. You are a neo nazi who wants to pretend you ain't.
--------------Screenshot--------------
--------------Screenshot End--------------
I- what?? By the way transID language works, transracists absolutely identify with """cis""" racist ideals. You cannot call yourself transracist and be expected to be given any sort of respect. You are a racist. Fuck off. No one is going to feel safe around you, especially not racial minorities. If you call yourself transracist, you will be treated like the scum you are.
Honestly the audacity of these people. You expect people to respect your transIDs but openly claim to identify with genocidal ideologies and defend it. I understand atypical dysphoria, I really really do, but I cannot fathom anyone with a shred of sentience willingly labeling themselves as a nazi because of said dysphoria. If you genuinely call yourself transnazi or transracist, get the fuck out of the radqueer community and seek help.
To identify as transage means you identify as an age that is different from the one you currently have. Most commonly, it is younger.
Many radqueers defend this identity by explaining that age in of itself is a social construct and therefore can be changed however they so see fit. However this doesn't account for the fact that just because something is a social construct doesn't mean it isn't valuable or in place for a reason.
Age exists to keep track of time, and track how old someone is getting or how young they are. It has many uses. One of them is to determine whether someone is of the age and emotional maturity to which they can consent.
So ... Why do we know kids can't consent?
This one's quite simple, actually.
One of the biggest reasons is the mental toll it takes on kids. Children who are involved with sexual relations with adults or with other kids often develop PTSD, depression, anxiety, or hypersexuality. Their ability to trust adults may dwindle, or they may only be attracted to adults.
They also might develop body dysmorphia or dysphoria (not to be confused with gender dysphoria). Often, children who are involved with sexual relations often describe their body as hurt or dirty or even engage in self harm activity without realizing its significance.
A common idea that runs with pro-contact paraphiles is that these effects only show on kids who aren't consenting, but this isn't true. No matter what the child's stance on this, they both show the same symptoms.
[source]
[source2]
Got it. So what's the point of being transage anyway?
Someone might identify as transage for many reasons.
Commonly, adults who identify as minors are age regressors, meaning they can slip into a headspace that is childish in nature often for coping purposes. This is not always the case but it is the most common reason. Nothing is wrong with age regression as long as it is used healthily and for one's benefit.
However, most age regressors do disagree with the idea of transage.
This is because people who identify as minors will often try to date (actual) minors. This is still the same as grooming though, as the adult's mind is developed enough to tell right from wrong (with the exception of severe illnesses, in which you should be regulating that with care anyway.)
Or, on the other side of the coin, a minor might identify as an adult. This is almost always a reflection of traumatic experience or grooming.
Trauma in children can sometimes show as acting older or more mature then is normally expected of their age, and often, they are praised for this by other adults. This can sometimes make them feel as if they are meant to be adults, despite the fact their body is not.
In terms of grooming, sometimes a child may choose to identify as an adult if they feel that they are developed enough to consent.
Transage is a complicated topic, and these definitions likely do not fit every single identity in it. That's because it is not supposed to, rather, it is to give a general overview on the concept and why it happens. Stay educated.
Yo, idfk why but you're in a blocklist, im sorry to share this to you.
oh lol, it’s because we’re chronosian
kinda weird to get lumped in with a bunch of “transabled” peeps since we literally have a genetic disability, and MAPs since we’re bodily a minor, but whatever i guess.
we don’t use the term transage for ourselves anymore and actively haven’t for awhile, we’re uncomfortable with it’s associations but also can’t change something that’s literally been engraved in us via trauma, as much as we’ve tried.
okay, i know i don't usually post stuff like this but i used to follow a mogai coining blog called macbre-maws (the reason why i followed it was because it seemed like a very cool unproblematic person who coined cool horror-y genders) and I noticed it reblogging a ton of stuff from proship blogs and at first i was very confused because i remember it also interacting with antiship mogai blogs
and yeah.. it's just been straight up violating people's DNIs
Proof:
So yeah, i recommend blocking it that way it can't violate other people's DNIs(I know i only put one person's DNI that it broke but there's probably other people's DNI that it broke)
I sadly can't block the person as this is a sideblog
Hi, I just wanted to ask you for help on what transid and transx means and why they are problematic/bad, since someone asked me about it and I'm not good at explaining -White Lily
okie
Edit : one, so sorry this is so disorganized like 4 different alters wrote different parts of this and it’s written out of order too. Two, adding on, most of these things, honestly all of them, but some more than others, are major struggles for those who actually have/are these things. What I mean : a “trace” white person claiming to be trans Native American has NO idea the true struggles of being Native American. A neurotypical transdisordered person claiming to have DID, OCD, autism, etc has no idea how hard it is to deal with those things and does not have to deal with most, if any, of the symptoms. So it’s incredibly fucked up. Imagine being someone who has struggled with horrible PTSD watching some 20 something year old on TikTok claiming to be “trans trauma” and “transdisordered” claiming to have ptsd from the trauma that never happened. It feels like mockery, and sometimes it is just straight up mockery and is done pretty much for roleplaying or shits and giggles. Now, for some, there’s a disorder or disorders causing them to feel that way. Even then, they need to get help for whatever is wrong and stop causing harm to those who are struggling. Whether they mean to or not and whether they realize it or not, they are causing harm
Edit 2 : also, I realize that there’s a handful of people who actually have whatever or are whatever and say that they’re ok with transid individuals. But that does not mean everyone is. The vast majority, I’d estimate well over 95%, of people who are whatever or have whatever do not support transx/transid individuals.
transid is an umbrella term short for transidentify. Some people claim that transgender falls under this umbrella, however most trans people, myself included, do not think it does and do not want to be associated with “transid” individuals.
now, everyone’s opinion on stuff is different. Some individuals claim certain things fall under that umbrella and some don’t. And some are comfortable with some stuff (such as transspecies) but aren’t comfortable with transdisordered people.
tbh, if they aren’t causing any harm, spreading any misinfo, taking resources away from those who need it, etc. basically if they are causing zero negative things, I don’t really care. But the vast majority of them do, whether they realize it or not. And the vast majority of the stuff is caused by some disorder or trauma or something. Which, if that’s the case, then they likely need some sort of meds, therapy, and/or coping mechanisms to help them. I don’t support transid/transx as I find it harmful. However, most transspecies people I’m ok with and most chronosian people I’m ok with. As long as they aren’t hurting anyone and as long as they are taking care of themselves. However, transdisordered, transrace, etc? Fuck no I don’t support that that’s harmful af and has caused me personally issues as well.
transid & transx are where someone who does not have something or is not something wants to be said thing or believes that they should be that thing, in a non-disordered way, so they claim they are trans-whatever
the whole thing makes life significantly harder for both trans people and those who actually are those things.
people claim to be transrace (aka trace). An example would be a white person claiming that they are black even when they are not. Or an Asian person claiming to be Native American. It can be anyone of any race claiming to be any race or races. This could be considered racism, cultural appropriation, and/or etc
people claim to be trans-[insert disorder here]. They do not have the disorder, but for whatever reason, they want it or believe that they should have it. This is incredibly harmful for those who actually have said disorder or disorders. It makes it harder for people to believe those with the disorder, it makes recieving help and treatment harder, it causes a lot of misinformation to be spread (some major examples are those transx/transid individuals who claim to have DID, OSDD, Tourettes, Autism, and cluster b disorders. They cause further misinformation to be spread and think that they have a say in things when they don’t.)
Transx/Transid individuals claim to be trans-anything. Trans-disabled, trans-autistic, trans-paralyzed, trans-NPD, etc. it makes everyone else look like a joke. They speak over those who are transgender and over those who have or are actually whatever. Like I said, it causes a lot of misinformation, a lot of separation, and a lot of issues for those who are actually whatever.
article about transrace
being aldernic, xenogender, etc is different from being transx/transid. And some people may have a disorder that causes they to believe that they are something or have something that they aren’t. They could have a personality disorder, a dissociative disorder, some type of dysphoria or dysmorphia, BIID (body integrity identity disorder), ptsd causing them to want to be something they aren’t or causing them to believe that they are something they aren’t, etc
another thing is transage. Transage is associated heavily with MAPs because they often try and use it as an excuse to be in relationships with minors. And you can’t transition to a different age or literally be a different age. You can mentally feel a different age, sometimes or all the time, for various reasons. A lot of people do feel this way. But that does not make them transage and they don’t have to use any sort of term for it. There is a term known as Chronosian. “Chronosian is a term for those who perceives their age in a way that differs from their body / legal age. It is not a transid term, nor is it pro-transid / transx.”
here’s a post about chronosian
some people like and use the terms or are ok with them. Some aren’t because they still feel like it’s considered transage. Ultimately, like any term, it’s up to each individual to decide if they’re comfortable with it or not
also, here’s a carrd explaining transid bc I unfortunately can’t find any better thing that has all that info on it. I couldn’t even go through the whole thing and it’s got so much misinfo and is so messed up. But there, to show you their explanations of stuff.
i have to stop looking at the transabled tag i found a blog run by someone who identifies as a fucking 9 year old completely seriously and wouldnt give their real age so probably an adult and posted about considering plastic surgery to make their face look younger
