No title available
art blog(derogatory)
Game of Thrones Daily

blake kathryn
$LAYYYTER

ellievsbear

No title available
tumblr dot com

Product Placement
Noah Kahan
d e v o n
No title available
Monterey Bay Aquarium

No title available

if i look back, i am lost
Aqua Utopia|海の底で記憶を紡ぐ
PUT YOUR BEARD IN MY MOUTH
Cosmic Funnies
will byers stan first human second
"I'm Dorothy Gale from Kansas"
seen from Brazil
seen from Morocco
seen from Ukraine

seen from Bulgaria

seen from Dominican Republic

seen from Malaysia

seen from Germany

seen from Netherlands
seen from Bangladesh
seen from Peru
seen from India

seen from Türkiye

seen from Bolivia
seen from United States
seen from United Kingdom
seen from Belgium

seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom
seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom
@thingswhatareawesome
It's the price people said they were willing to pay for Palestine.
I have to vent here real quick. I am so sick and tired of how antis destroyed fandom etiquette.
My bio on my bsky account says 'anti censorship; anti harrassment'. One day someone commented something nice on my art and I checked their bio and it said 'proship dni'. I replied something like 'hey thanks, that's so nice of you. However I'm proship so I'm gonna block you' and they replied 'you probably should state that in your bio then'.
I get so mad bc tell me you don't even understand what proship is and where it came from without telling me. Seriously, it feels like 80% of antis are just fandom youngsters who get peer pressured into defaulting to 'proship bad' without knowing what it means.
Tbh, I sincerely doubt the majority of people using proship dni know what proship is, and I wouldn't be shocked if the majority of them do continue to harass others out of fear that those around them will reject them.
Didn't think that I'd have to post this exact comparison again, didn't even think I'd have to post it once, and yet I stand disappointed again.
On the left: a sign in German on a street in Bavaria, reading: "Jews are unwanted here." Photo taken by an American in 1937.
On the right: a message from a hotel in Bavaria, Zum Hirschen, sent to Israelis who tried to book a stay, reading: "Sorry, there are no Jews allowed in our hotel." June 2026.
Again, the incident has been "handled": Booking.com took the hotel off its platform and the hotel itself was contacted by the Israeli consulate in Munich. The hotel at first denied sending the message, but later stated that it was indeed one of its employees that sent it. It is yet unclear if the case will lead to formal proceedings.
Let me point out that one small detail. They didn't said Israelis weren't allowed, they didn't say Zionists weren't allowed. They said Jews. Now Bavarians aren't new at the scene of antisemitism, in fact they are very experienced, but nowadays, we don't say Jews when we're being discriminatory, no, we say something else. You're not supposed to say the quiet part out loud! (For those in my comments who don't understand sarcasm, that was it.)
This joins many concerning cases across Europe and the UK (not to mention the US!) that reenact the nostalgic scenes of the 1930s and 1940s. (Again, sarcasm). I haven't yet made a post about the spa in Spain that refused a Jewish woman on entry on account of her Magen David necklace. And here Europe strikes again, in the very place the Nazi party rose to power. All those woke westerners that are so proud to chant about punching Nazis, and where are you now? Aren't you ashamed? Wouldn't even recognize one if it was saluting in your face.
Thoughts on this sign from the West Bank?
I love you cherry picking nuanced images you know nothing about without proper context. Let me provide it since I'm sure you forgot.
As with everything that has to do with the West Bank, nothing is what it seems on the surface, and everything is complicated, tense, and intense. I like to joke that it's not the West Bank, it's the Wild West. The West Bank is decided as agreed upon in the Oslo Accords into three areas. Area A is assigned to the Palestinians and is governed by the Palestinian Authority, Area B is for both Israelis and Palestinians, and Area C is for Israelis alone and is governed by Israel. At the entrance to any Area A section is a sign that looks like this:
Looks familiar? Now doesn't that scream apartheid? In truth, it isn't. Not only Israelis are forbidden to enter by law, do you see the part where it says that the entrance for Israeli citizens is endangering their lives? That is there for a reason. Look up the Ramallah Lynching of 2000 (and use a RELIABLE source). That's what happens when Israelis enter Area A by accident. It is THAT dangerous. (Fun fact! The photo that would show up of Aziz Salha is the base for that oh so popular red hand pin. Actually that's a not so fun fact, because you virtue signaling good hearts are using a pin that idolizes the symbol of Israeli blood on Palestinian hands. Not so peaceful.)
Now let's look at the photo you shared. This sign was placed at the entrance to Yitzhar, an Israeli village on Area C, a bit south of Nablus, which is in Area A. The locals of this village are religious Jews, and it is unfortunately located in a VERY tense area of the West Bank. A lot of terror attack took place around there both by Palestinians and Jews. Here is a good example (out of a very long list of shootings, stabbings lootings and fire settings).
September 13th 2008. A 17yo Palestinian lit a family house in Yitzhar on fire, where young children lived, as well as stabbed a 9yo several times.
The next morning, a group from Yitzhar went to seek revenge in the Palestinian village of the 17yo. They destroyed property, and attacked and wounded a few Palestinian locals. The Israeli PM at the time, Ehud Olmart, condemned that reaction strongly.
That cycle of attacks and vengeance seems like it is neverending and runs very deep. That people at Yitzhar have a deep distrust of Palestinians and Arabs, as well as the security forces that enforce the area. Now, my personal opinion is that vengeance only adds fuel to an already scorching fire, and I expect Jews who are so close to the religion to act way more peacefully, but this is the Wild West, and I can honestly cannot speak for the people of Yitzhar, who suffered as much violence as they delivered.
On to the sign in the photo. During covid, in 2020, a health industry covid test administer seeked to enter the settlement and deliver the tests, and the people of Yitzhar blocked his entrance, per their illegal but unenforced "no entrance for Arabs" policy (he was an Arab Israeli citizen). IDF officials instructed the locals to change of the illegal policy and allow entrance for the covid checker.
In protest, the locals put up that sign in the entry road to the settlement. It is NOT an official Israeli policy, and it is NOT a legal policy. It is a protest.
Is it right? In my opinion, no. It is illegal. Do I understand the frustration of the people? Also no. It is nuanced and incredibly complex. Now, full picture, what are your thoughts?
saw a reddit post about a trans woman applying to be moved to a woman's prison and even ignoring all the transphobic shit in the comments. like half the people were talking about the assault and rape of prisoners as if it's a good thing, that they deserve it for being "violent criminals"
idk maybe i just thought "people shouldn't be raped and abused for breaking a law" was a take most people agreed with but i guess im just naive
like how the fuck are we meant to get anywhere if when you mention v-coding the overwhelming response is "well if they didn't wanna get violently raped they shouldn't have broken the law"
Especially when that law is something like "Don't be trans." Or just a good prosecutor taking over a case and making their money's worth from whoever has a bone to pick with some random trans woman.
*Hitting the "Prisoners are people too" button with increasingly angry frustration*
Rape should not be a punishment. It should not be expected in any situation. It's never okay.
There are times when killing a person is justified—if someone is attacking you, and you Jill them in self-defense, that's understandable. There's no circumstance where rape or sexual assault is necessary or excusable or okay.
Prisoners are human beings and they don't lose their humanity no matter when they're done.
instead of obsessing over the possibility of a dead jewish child being queer, maybe read the actual sapphic love poems written by revolutionary poet, thinker, feminist, and jewish activist Emma Lazarus that she was unable to publish in her lifetime
"Assurance by Emma Lazarus
Last night I slept, and when I woke her kiss Still floated on my lips. For we had strayed Together in my dream, through some dim glade, Where the shy moonbeams scarce dared light our bliss. The air was dank with dew, between the trees, The hidden glow-worms kindled and were spent. Cheek pressed to cheek, the cool, the hot night-breeze Mingled ouir hair, our breath, and came and went, As sporting with our passion. Low and deep Spake in mine ear her voice: "And didst thou dream, This could be buried? This could be sleep? And love be thrall to death! Nay, whatso seem, Have faith, dear heart; this is the thing that is!" Thereon I woke, and on my lips her kiss."
— Rwanda, Israel and the Inversion of ‘Genocide’
mamdani is like the kid who's elected class president and realizes he's actually not allowed to make recess longer or get rid of homework except he already promised everybody he would do that
I also have the theory that nobody talks about Putin because Zelenskyy is Jewish. Who cares what Russia is doing to Ukraine, because obviously Ukraine is a ((Zionist)) psyop
Before the American Left Made Palestine Its Revolution, Japan Did It First
Kōzō Okamoto is dead.
He was not Palestinian, Arab, Muslim or a refugee. He had never lost a home in the Middle East. He was a 24-year-old Japanese botany student from a respectable family headed by a school principal.
Yet in 1972, he travelled thousands of miles to murder strangers at Israel’s international airport in the name of “freeing Palestine".
Okamoto died in Beirut at 78. The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine - the Marxist-Leninist terrorist organization that planned his operation and protected him for decades - eulogized “Ahmad the Japanese” as a model of sacrifice who “never compromised nor faltered”.
His story is a warning about what fringe movements built on hatred, dehumanization and revolutionary absolutism can eventually produce.
Okamoto did not begin with a rifle.
He began with attending a university.
During the 1960s, Japanese universities were convulsed by protests against the Vietnam War, America’s military presence, the US–Japan Security Treaty, capitalism and Japan’s alleged subordination to American “imperialism”.
A radical minority concluded that protest and reform were useless. If the system itself was violence, they reasoned, then violence against the system was justified.
The Red Army Faction formally declared war on the Japanese state in 1969. Its members attacked police stations, robbed banks and sought foreign bases from which to ignite a worldwide communist revolution.
The ideology spread through university organizations, friendship networks, political meetings and revolutionary art. One of Okamoto’s earliest known activities was arranging a screening of Red Army/PFLP: Declaration of World War, an agitprop film portraying Japanese communists and Palestinian militants as soldiers in one international army.
First came the images and slogans. Then came Lebanon.
Okamoto’s older brother, Takeshi, was already involved. In 1970, he joined eight other radicals in hijacking Japan Airlines Flight 351 to North Korea, where the surviving hijackers received asylum.
Meanwhile, a related but organizationally separate faction, the United Red Army, was torturing and murdering its own members. Fourteen radicals were killed during an internal purge for alleged ideological weakness before the group’s survivors were captured following the televised Asama-Sansō siege in February 1972.
The revolution in Japan was collapsing into paranoia, criminality and death.
Fusako Shigenobu decided that the answer was not to abandon the revolution but to export it. She moved to Lebanon in 1971 and joined forces with the PFLP, associated with George Habash and Wadie Haddad’s campaign of international hijackings.
To these radicals, Palestine was never about improving Palestinian lives. It was just the “weak link” through which the entire Western order might be broken. Zionism, capitalism, America, the Japanese government and the police were presented as components of one global system.
“Free Palestine”, they said and you could begin to “free the world”.
This alliance was not accidental. Palestinian revolutionary organizations actively cultivated foreign radicals because they supplied new recruits, international legitimacy and operatives who could evade the scrutiny applied to Arab militants. The communists received training, weapons, protection and a global stage. The PFLP received expendable foreign soldiers.
That arrangement brought Okamoto to Lod Airport.
On May 30, 1972, Okamoto and two other Japanese Red Army members - Tsuyoshi Okudaira and Yasuyuki Yasuda - arrived on an Air France flight from Rome.
They looked like ordinary Japanese travellers. Their weapons were concealed in violin cases and luggage. Airport security was watching for Arab attackers, not Japanese communists.
After collecting their bags, the three removed Czech assault rifles and grenades and opened fire indiscriminately.
26 were murdered and approximately more 80 injured.
Seventeen of the dead were Christian pilgrims from Puerto Rico. One was Canadian. Eight were Israelis, including the internationally renowned biophysicist Aharon Katzir.
They were pilgrims, scientists, airport employees and passengers standing beside a baggage carousel.
Two attackers died. Okamoto was wounded and captured.
He reportedly told a Japanese diplomat that he had nothing personally against his victims. He had merely fulfilled his duty as a “soldier of the revolution”.
That is the power of ideological brainwashing: it removes the need for a personal grievance. The victim ceases to be an individual and becomes a “Zionist”, “settler”, “colonizer”, “imperialist” or “class enemy”. Once people have been replaced by categories, killing them can be presented as virtue.
Okamoto would later express sorrow for the victims, but he never renounced the attack or accepted that it was terrorism. In 2017, he still described the massacre as “armed struggle” and praised such violence as effective propaganda. In 2022, he appeared at a Beirut ceremony commemorating the attack, laid a wreath for the other gunmen and gave supporters a victory sign.
He died without repenting for what he had done.
That is what successful indoctrination looks like: 54 years after opening fire on strangers and murdering many, the murderer can still see himself as the hero.
Fortunately, those around him did not.
Japan reacted with shock, shame and fury.
Delegations, many composed of young people, visited the Israeli Embassy in Tokyo to apologize. Japanese ambassador Eiji Tokura addressed Israelis on television in halting Hebrew, apologized for the crime committed by Japanese nationals and broke down in tears.
Foreign Minister Takeo Fukuda called the massacre a dishonor to Japan. Education Minister Saburō Takami apologized for failures in the educational system. The president of Kyoto University, attended by two of the perpetrators, was summoned to the Education Ministry and publicly expressed his shame.
Japan sent a special emissary and offered approximately $1.5 million in compensation to the wounded and the families of the dead.
Most strikingly, Okamoto’s father wrote to Golda Meir and asked that his son be executed after a full investigation.
His father did not call him a resistance fighter. He did not argue that Israel had forced his son to fire into a crowd. He understood that no grievance or revolutionary slogan could absolve the deliberate murder of innocent people.
But the consequences did not remain in Israel.
The Palestinian alliance helped transform the Japanese Red Army into an international terrorist network, and Japanese citizens and institutions soon became targets and bargaining chips.
In 1973, JRA and PFLP operatives hijacked Japan Airlines Flight 404 and demanded Okamoto’s release.
In 1974, JRA members seized the French Embassy in The Hague.
In 1975, they took more than 50 hostages in Kuala Lumpur, occupying facilities that included the American and Swedish diplomatic missions.
In 1977, they hijacked another Japan Airlines flight to Dhaka, forcing Japan to release imprisoned radicals and pay a ransom.
In 1988, a JRA member bombed a USO club in Naples, killing five people.
Palestine had provided the revolution with its first foreign battlefield, but the revolutionary campaign was aimed at the wider democratic order. It eventually came home to Japan through hijacked Japanese aircraft, Japanese hostages, political coercion and decades of international police work.
The promised liberation produced corpses, prisoners, fugitives and broken families. It freed nobody.
Shigenobu was arrested in Japan in 2000 and dissolved the Japanese Red Army from prison in 2001. After completing a 20-year sentence, she acknowledged that she had hurt innocent people by placing “the struggle” above them.
Okamoto never reached that reckoning.
Israel had sentenced him to life but released him in the 1985 Jibril prisoner exchange. After passing through Libya and Syria, he settled in Lebanon. Lebanese authorities arrested him and four other JRA members in 1997 for forged documents and immigration violations. Four were eventually deported and taken into Japanese custody.
Lebanon (under the influence of the PLO, Hezbollah and Syria) protected Okamoto, granting him political asylum because his massacre was classified as “resistance”. Japan repeatedly requested his extradition; Lebanon repeatedly refused.
The PFLP protected him until his death.
Today, Palestinian political networks and Western socialist organizations are again building mutually useful alliances.
DSA publications describe Students for Justice in Palestine and the Palestinian Youth Movement as “grassroots partners” (paid by the biggest tyrants in the world). DSA’s own statements speak of “comrades in Palestine” and promise to “break the gears of the US imperial war machine”.
The Palestinian cause supplies Western radicals with a morally intoxicating global struggle. Western radicals supply Palestinian movements with brainwashed foot soldiers, political influence, institutional access and useful mob to recruit even more lost youth.
At a City College encampment in 2024, an organizer told a YDSA publication: “We’re going to free Palestine, and we’re going to free the world too”.
The organizer connected Palestine to free tuition, capitalism, campus police and the American university system because “they’re all connected”. The same interview called for escalation and argued that working within the political system was ineffective.
The "omnicause" tends to radicalize people in this way, and that is remarkably close to the Japanese Red Army’s revolutionary synthesis.
Palestine stops being one conflict. It becomes the master explanation for every grievance and the imagined detonator for a wider war against capitalism, America, police, borders, universities, Jews and Western power.
This is why the encampments should not automatically be treated as benign expressions of youthful idealism. An encampment must be judged by what it teaches, tolerates and produces.
When organizers insist that every grievance is part of one revolutionary struggle; call for ever-greater escalation; describe Israeli civilians as “settlers” without civilian rights; romanticize “armed struggle”; punish dissent; attack Jewish students and professors on campus, and teach students that political opponents are outside the moral community, the tents are not benign. They are functioning as radicalization spaces.
A YDSA proposal for a national student strike explicitly called for “upending the very social fabric” of campuses and “weaponizing” students’ numbers against universities.
This is how the threshold moves:
A political opponent becomes an oppressor.
A disagreement becomes complicity.
A defensive missile system becomes “barbaric”.
A murdered civilian becomes a “settler”.
A massacre becomes “resistance”.
On October 7, DSA’s national statement said the attack was “a direct result of Israel’s "apartheid" regime” and “was not unprovoked”. It did not name Hamas. It ignored every fact on the ground, and its immediate instruction was for socialists to organize against Israel and American support for it.
The following day, a Times Square rally promoted by NYC-DSA and organized with other radical groups took place while Israeli families were still discovering who had been murdered and kidnapped. A speaker joked approvingly that the “resistance” had arrived by paraglider and captured people at the Nova festival. The crowd laughed.
Maurice Isserman, a historian and DSA member for 41 years, resigned. He had belonged to Students for a Democratic Society during the 1960s and watched tightly organized revolutionary factions capture it before the Weathermen took their “armed struggle” underground.
As an historian, he recognized the pattern: ideological factions intolerant of dissent capturing a wider movement, imposing purity tests and moving its moral boundaries toward violence.
At its 2025 convention, DSA adopted “For a Fighting Anti-Zionist DSA”, reinforcing anti-Zionism as an organizational requirement and treating some affirmations of Israel’s right to defend itself as potentially disciplinary matters.
The Japanese radicals also treated disagreement as betrayal and ideological weakness as corruption. Their purity system culminated in internal tribunals, torture and 14 murdered comrades.
That history should be read as a warning, not after the next Okamoto appears, but before.
There is one crucial difference between Japan then and the West now.
Japan’s political establishment drew a moral boundary. Its ambassador wept. Its government compensated victims. Its police pursued the perpetrators.
Today, parts of the European political class and elements of America’s Democratic Party increasingly echo the movement’s accusations, terminology and political demands. Instead of confronting radicalization, politicians calculate how many votes can be won by flattering it.
Ro Khanna’s July 2026 Judea and Samaria trip illustrates the incentive. While considering a presidential campaign, and after supporting a Nazi candidate that then also turned out to be a rapist, Khanna chose an exclusively Palestinian-led itinerary, refused invites from the Israeli government, called Gaza a “genocide” and Judaea and Samaria “apartheid”, and converted a disputed road confrontation into a national political spectacle. Khanna then (surprise, surprise) announced that the experience had made him more determined to consider running for president.
Political leadership once meant resisting a mob when it abandoned basic principles. Increasingly, it means studying the mob’s slogans, repeating them and hoping the performance converts into votes.
That collapse in standards matters. Fringe movements become more dangerous when elected officials validate their moral framework and reward their escalation.
The lesson of the Holocaust cannot merely be that the world should hold ceremonies after millions have been murdered.
The lesson must be to recognize radicalization and dehumanization before it reaches its final destination.
The Japanese Red Army remained small. It did not need millions of members. The PFLP needed only a handful of thoroughly indoctrinated young people willing to replace human beings with ideological categories and someone else’s war with their own identity.
It found them.
Today, no one needs to fly Western students to a training camp in Lebanon. Propaganda reaches them through social media, university organizations, activist toolkits and political networks. It offers belonging, absolute certainty and permission to hate while calling that hatred justice.
That is why the answer begins with refusing to erase people.
Palestinians are human beings, not revolutionary props.
Israelis are human beings, not symbols of “settler colonialism” (nor they are colonialists).
Jews are not a metaphysical stand-in for capitalism, imperialism or the West.
Before anyone convinces himself that killing Israelis is liberation, he should come to Israel and see the people the slogans have erased.
Visit the kibbutzim attacked on October 7. Meet the families of the murdered and kidnapped. Walk through Israeli hospitals where Jewish and Arab doctors treat Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Druze and Bedouin patients. Meet Israeli Arabs, immigrants, refugees and foreign workers. Then meet Palestinians, hear their experiences and see their humanity too, and how they are being oppressed by Hamas.
Reality is more difficult than revolutionary propaganda because reality contains people.
People complicate hatred.
That is precisely why the ideologues replace them with labels.
The Japanese Red Army believed it would free Palestine and then free the world. It freed nobody. It helped Palestinian terrorists internationalize their war, inflicted violence far beyond Israel and left families across several countries to bury the results.
Kōzō Okamoto never truly repented because he never escaped the ideological machinery that turned murder into heroism.
We should not wait for another massacre - and certainly not for another catastrophe on the scale of the Holocaust - before admitting that the machinery is being rebuilt.
See the signs now.
Stop excusing dehumanization.
Stop treating radicalization as harmless campus theater.
And stop teaching young people that any political cause can make the murder of another human being righteous.
facts about
"oh, I live in a desert and-"
"wow that must be so terrible" "deserts are so ugly" "I would never want to live in a wasteland like that" "it's just empty nothingness"
wishing 10,000 exploding hammers upon you
behold New Mexico
[ID 1: tall, snowcapped rocky mountains rising above a plain filled with desert scrub
ID 2: brightly colored banded cliff walls of several mesas climbing their way into mountains
ID 3: a desert prairie
ID 4: colorful hoodoos against a twilight sky
ID 5: white sand dunes as far as the eye can see
ID 6: a collection of hoodoos against a stormy sky at sunset
ID 7: a juniper tree standing with a cliff wall in the background
ID 8: several juniper trees on a rocky landscape]
this post and all its wonderful additions (look in the notes) is circulating again. these photos and many of the ones added in the notes come from the US Southwest.
right now the trump administration is attacking the public lands in the Southwestern US. most recently (July 2026), in Utah the Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments have been cut by over 90% to allow for mining. these lands are sacred to multiple Native nations in the area and contain irreplaceable archeological sites. additionally, the commission of Native representatives who aided in management of these lands has been dissolved leaving Native people without a voice in caring for the remaining land. (read more here)
here in New Mexico, the 10 mile buffer zone surrounding Chaco Canyon preventing oil and gas drilling is under attack. Chaco Canyon contains incredibly old and incredibly fragile archeological sites sacred to Pueblo people. these sites are threatened by mining and drilling. (read more here)
The attack on the Chaco buffer zone is currently in a public comment period open until July 29. PLEASE leave a public comment to save these irreplaceable places.
Godzilla
Just leaving these here and letting the hit dogs holler:
Midwest Poultry Services has recalled nearly 1.6 million white and brown eggs due to potential salmonella contamination.
To their credit, nobody has gotten sick from it as of posting this. They found out through their own monitoring and this is a voluntary recall. That said:
The recalled eggs were sold in Kroger stores in Texas and Louisiana, Brookshire Grocery stores in Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, New Mexico and Mississippi, and at other smaller retail outlets, according to the recall report. The eggs were also shipped to food service and retailers in Texas, Oklahoma and Louisiana, the report states.
Be safe!
Don't try to give me that "Oh, the reason we care so much about Israel and not other human rights violators is because Israel is a a US (or UK, or European) ally and we send them weapons and tax money!" You know who else is a US ally we send money to for security cooperation? Fucking Pakistan. You got anything to say about them sending thousands of Afghan refugees back over the border to starve under the Taliban? Or their blasphemy laws? No? We don't give aid to the UAE or Saudi Arabia because they sure as shit don't need it, but we do sell them weapons and cooperate with them on intelligence and security. Any thoughts on the Saudi bombing and blockade of Yemen that was creating the world's biggest humanitarian crisis a few years ago? Or the UAE funding and arming the RSF's civil war in Sudan, including their Darfur genocide (the sequel), which has now overtaken it? Not to mention the abuse and enslavement of migrant workers! You want to set up an encampment at your university demanding they divest from the UAE or stop taking money from Qatar? It's all dirty fossil fuel money anyway! Don't you want to harass your political representatives and threaten them with death if they don't promise never to take money from Gulf Arab interests, and always to vote against weapons sales to them?
Yeah, I didn't think so.
People love dead Jews but they also love dead Black Civil Rights leaders because if MLK hadn't been assassinated, the white left would be treating him like they treat Jim Clyburn right now.
California’s privacy obstacle course
Hey, UK folks! Waterstones is having a 3-day pre-order sale that includes the UK paperback of Enshittification (which drops on Sept 1). Use SUMMER26 to get 25% off.
Data brokers are a cancer. There's a direct line from the unrestricted collection, retention and processing of our data to a host of evils, from deepfake porn to phishing scams; from racial discrimination in hiring to ICE roundups of migrants; from targeted election interference to identity theft:
https://pluralistic.net/2023/12/06/privacy-first/#but-not-just-privacy
Why do data brokers exist? Because we let them. Congress hasn't passed a new federal consumer privacy law since 1988, when they made it illegal for video stores to disclose your VHS rentals. All other acts of consumer surveillance are legal. Data brokers spy on us for the same reason your dog licks its balls: because they can, and we don't stop them:
https://pluralistic.net/2026/03/10/ice-tech/#foreseeable-outcomes
Getting rid of data brokers wouldn't solve all our problems, but it sure would go a long way to solving many of them. Rather than legally requiring platforms to spy on kids (to exclude them from being targeted by platforms' algorithms), we could prohibit platforms from spying on anyone, including kids, meaning kids couldn't be identified (much less targeted) by algorithms or ads:
https://pluralistic.net/2026/06/23/destroy-the-village/#to-save-it
Data brokers produce mountains of raw material used for every form of scam and torture. It's data brokers who power the gig economy's "algorithmic wage discrimination" system, where nurses and other workers are offered less pay based on how much credit card debt they're carrying:
https://pluralistic.net/2024/12/18/loose-flapping-ends/#luigi-has-a-point
Banning data brokers would make great sense, which is why Biden's CFPB banned data brokers (only to have Trump un-ban them):
https://pluralistic.net/2025/05/15/asshole-to-appetite/#ssn-for-sale
So the feds (both Congress and the executive branch) have surrendered, and that leaves states alone on the battlefield fighting the privacy wars alone. State legislatures have taken some big steps, but – crucially – they've stopped short of banning data brokers from operating within their borders. Having taken a ban on data brokers off the table, states are left with complex, often unworkable "compromises" that go nowhere.
This is where DROP comes in. DROP stands for "Delete Request and Opt-out Platform," and it's a new phase of California's privacy regime that kicks off next month. Under DROP, you fill in some paperwork and then the state requires every data brokerage operating in California to delete your data, as well as any inferences they've made about you based on that data:
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/07/what-you-need-know-about-californias-drop-tool
Implementing DROP is nowhere near as good as banning data brokers. The idea that data brokers should be able to collect, retain and process your data unless you tell them not to implies that everyone starts off wanting to be spied on, and therefore data brokers should assume that unless they hear otherwise, we're delighted to be the subject of commercial surveillance. This is an incredibly stupid supposition, contradicted by all available evidence. For example, when Apple offered iPhone owners a one-click option to block Facebook from spying on them, 96% of iPhone owners clicked the button:
https://applescoop.org/story/facebook-must-inflict-pain-on-apple-says-mark-zuckerberg
Indeed, given this fact, one wonders why Apple bothers with the "don't spy on me" button at all. Why not have a "do spy on me" button that is unchecked by default, and leave users to dig through their settings to find the option to opt in to being surveilled? Of course, then it would make the fact that Apple spies on its customers and uses the data to target ads (with no way to opt out) a little awkward:
https://pluralistic.net/2022/11/14/luxury-surveillance/#liar-liar
In the absence of a ban on surveillance without explicit, opt-in consent, we are left with the bizarre fiction that most of us want to be spied on, a fiction that pervades the DROP process, making the entire procedure nearly impossible to complete.
This is why I’ve been saying internet law is behind the times. So very, very behind the times. There was a time when we didn’t know what the outcomes of this or that business type would be. We know now, and it’s time to knock this nonsense off.
insane goodwill pickup