Last Night at the Telegraph Club by Malinda Lo, Narrated by Emily Woo Zeller
This queer historical romance takes place in the mid-1950s in the Bay Area of San Francisco, California, following World War 2 and the rise of McCarthyism in the US. Lily is trying to get through her senior year so she can study rockets when budding queerness and a new friend named Kath disrupt Lily's plans of remaining her family's good Chinese daughter. It's a patient and honest bildungsroman full of life and newly discovered joy alongside poignant discussions of sexuality and intersectionality.
I bought this book back before it was awarded the Michael L. Printz Honor. It also won the National Book Award, the Stonewall Book Award, and the Asian/Pacific American Award for Youth Literature. I only know I bought the book prior to these prestigious awards because my copy has no such details of its prominent success. This novel is extremely well-regarded and for good reasons. I ultimately chose this book because of the Printz Honor and the fact that I had this book on my shelf. The timing couldn't have been better because I recently got this book back from a friend who took it with her to college and returned home only months ago. I listened to just about a third of the audiobook, and then finished it physically. This book was chosen to fulfill the Michael L. Printz Honor requirement.
The big question of queerness, specifically lesbian identity, is explored with such ferocity, full of bouts of tension and the physical need to be close to another; and yet so much care, with both Lily and Kath never pushing a boundary and constantly being so aware and careful with one another. This big unanswerable question for Lily shows up in the first chapter where Lily tears the ad for Tommy Andrews, male impersonator, out of a newspaper, stashes the image, and then frantically washes her hands of the evidence (Lo, 2021, p. 17). Immediately there is this internal turmoil with the protagonist, understanding there is a reason for her behavior, but unsure what it could be. There's a great final line to the second chapter: Lily looking at her amassed images of more masculine women and feeling "a hot and restless urge to look--- and, by looking, to know" (Lo, 2021, p. 23). There is little doubt what the question is, and as the story progresses, the more unapologetic Lily feels about her queerness, even while she remains ever-anxious about being seen by residents of Chinatown while she's attending the Telegraph Club or with Kath. She's letting herself be herself, even while scared. Even when everything falls apart and Lily is being sent away, she tells her family very plainly "'[she] didn't make a mistake'" (Lo, 2021, p. 376). The big question of what queerness is to Lily is deeply intriguing in the way Lo tells the story, with tons of historical details and with a clear look into Lily's lovestruck and frantic mind.
The setting is one of the most impressive aspects of the novel. There are timelines throughout the book's parts, dictating exactly when in history the plot's events are occurring. It is genuinely difficult to explain just how much detail and research clearly went into this novel. The "Author's Note" section (Lo, 2021, pp. 397-405) is paragraphs of information of the era this book takes place in, alongside the "Select Bibliography" with books, articles, and documentaries Lo used in her research (Lo, 2021, pp. 407-408). I have never seen a fictional novel with this much presented research, and I find it awe-inspiring and downright incredible. Amongst the pages of the actual novel, long lists of region-specific Chinese cuisine with specific addresses, locations, and clothing engulf the book in such an atmosphere of the era, and it feels perfect.
This is an extremely well-rounded piece of literature. Even if the reader isn't a fan of one aspect of the story, there is so much more that the reader can pull from. There is the political climate threatening Lily's family, particularly her father, and her need to avoid anyone who is affiliated with communists. There is the romance between Lily and Kath, starting from nothing and slowly blossoming into something bigger than they could've imagined. There is the historical lens on queer culture and how those who were out and attending public queer spaces were operating during this moment in history. There are the cultural struggles of Lily being a person of color in 1950s America. The amount of elements and concepts presented thoroughly and carefully make this novel well-rounded and full of potential discussion.
I gave this book 4.25 stars on StoryGraph because the romance is adorable and done well inside this beast of a historical fiction teaming with life and character. A great recommendation I can provide is The Last True Poets of the Sea by Julia Drake is a coming-of-age novel about protagonist Violet attempting to find a historical shipwreck that haunts her family whilst also attempting to navigate her queerness.
Drake, J. (2019). The last true poets of the sea. Hyperion.
Lo, M. (2021). Last night at the telegraph club. Dutton Books.
Lo, M. (2021). Last night at the telegraph club (E. W. Zeller, Narr.). [Audiobook]. Books on Tape.
*originally posted 04/17/2025*