I canāt lie, I have VERY mixed feelings over Jax being transfem.
On one hand, I think itās good representation to have a character thatās transgender but can be defined outside of that as their own person, and when people complain about Jax, including me, it rarely if ever has to do with his gender identity. We mainly focus on how the narrative handles his horrible actions, and thatās a good sign since the issue lies completely outside of gender expression. It also makes sense from a metaphorical stand point representing a journey on gender expression. In
On another hand, itāsā¦confusing, and I personally feel like itās Gooseworkx self inserting, since she said Jax is the character she relates to the most. And if he is transfem then, from the opinions Iāve heard, why is their human counter part not? If the copies can have their own perceptions then how does that work, I have too many questions. Jax being transfem also in a way excuses his abusive behavior towards Gangle, Zooble and Ragatha because you can just defend his behavior with āheās projecting his insecurities about being feminine on themā. The show has a tendency to gloss over his actions which frustrates me because heās not complicated in how you can understand his archetype easily: hurt people hurt people. And this feels like the final nail with how his trans storyline adds another layer to his behavior in targeting the women/non men of the show. I could ramble forever about that but thatās another topic.
It also comes out of no where if youāre not familiar with the trans Jax theory, and the āhintsā they showed before can be easily debunked. Like the maid dress, thatās an anime trope Gangle uses because sheās an otaku. It has nothing to do with gender identity, since she doesnāt even know and Jaxās reaction can also be read through a toxic masculinity or even a cis personās lens. If I was put in a maid dress suddenly Iād be frustrated, that doesnāt mean Iām trans. And Casanova from OHSHC also had a maid dress. Does that make him trans? No, obviously. Itās not handled very well, and if the writer wanted to explore themed of gender identity and trans storylines, ZOOBLE IS RIGHT THERE! But all she ever gets is a background storyline on body dysmorphia that barely gets any focus compared to Jax. Thereās also another issue of how popular trans storylines always explore male to female transitions but almost never female to male/nb transitions and I find that frustrating.
So yeah, my feelings on Jax being trans are incredibly mixed. Itās not bad but itās not good either. Itās both in my eyes. And yes if you like transfem Jax that valid, if you donāt like it thatās also valid. Personally I would prefer if he idealized toxic masculinity beliefs and remained cis but eh, Iām not gonna force any beliefs on anyone.
Iād like to hear some of your thoughts if you have anything to add onto this discussion.














