How to Be a Witch or Pagan Without Falling for Conspiracy Theories and New Age Cult Stuff
Witchcraft and paganism offer beautiful, empowering ways to connect with the world, the divine, and yourself. But let’s be real: the spiritual community can sometimes feel like navigating a metaphysical minefield. From “lizard people control the world” conspiracies to the pervasive influence of New Age cults, finding your way as a witch or pagan can feel daunting. So, how can you embrace this path while keeping your wits about you? Let’s dive into it—no tinfoil hats required.
1. Know Thyself and Do Thy Research
One of the most powerful tools for any witch or pagan is knowledge. Before diving headfirst into spiritual practices or belief systems, ask yourself:
What am I looking for in my path?
What resonates with me spiritually and ethically?
How can I learn more from credible sources?
Avoid treating every book, blog, or TikTok video as gospel truth. Instead, prioritize research from reputable authors and scholars. Look for historical, cultural, and anthropological contexts behind practices and beliefs. For example, if you’re exploring Norse paganism, read the Poetic Edda, but also check out scholarly works like Hilda Ellis Davidson’s writings.
💡 Pro Tip: If something sounds too fantastical or claims to have “secret knowledge,” approach it critically. “Ancient Lemurians built the pyramids” is not archaeology—it’s a conspiracy theory.
2. Critical Thinking: Your New Familiar
While spirituality embraces the unseen and mysterious, it doesn’t mean suspending all logic. Here’s how to keep critical thinking in your witchy toolkit:
Fact-Check Everything: Whether it’s a viral claim about moon water curing all ailments or a new trend like “quantum jumping,” take a moment to verify its origins.
Ask Questions: Who benefits from spreading this belief? Are there ulterior motives, such as selling courses, books, or products?
Beware the “Cult of Personality”: Be wary of influencers or leaders who discourage dissent or demand unquestioning loyalty. Spirituality thrives on diversity of thought.
3. Beware of Spiritual Bypassing
Some New Age ideas encourage bypassing real-world issues in favor of “high vibes only.” While positivity is great, ignoring trauma, systemic problems, or mental health struggles in the name of spirituality is toxic. True witchcraft and paganism embrace balance, acknowledging both the light and the shadow.
✋ Red Flag: Anyone who tells you to “just manifest” your way out of hardship or suggests that you’re attracting negativity because of bad energy. Life is more complex than that.
4. Stay Grounded in History, Not Appropriation
A common pitfall in modern paganism and witchcraft is cultural appropriation masquerading as spirituality. Using sacred practices or symbols from cultures you’re not part of without understanding their context can be harmful.
If you’re drawn to a practice, research its origins and ensure you’re honoring it respectfully.
Consider focusing on traditions tied to your own ancestry or exploring paths open to everyone, like modern witchcraft.
🌿 Example: Smudging is a specific Indigenous practice. Instead of co-opting it, explore alternative smoke-cleansing methods with herbs like rosemary or lavender.
5. Cult Warning Signs: Spot Them Early
Not all cults look like Hollywood’s hooded figures chanting in candlelit basements. In spirituality, cult-like behavior often hides under the guise of community.
An authoritarian leader or group demanding absolute loyalty.
Isolation from family, friends, or outside perspectives.
Fear-based control tactics, like threatening spiritual punishment for leaving.
Heavy financial exploitation (e.g., expensive courses or “required” donations).
💡 Remember: True spiritual communities empower you to think for yourself, not rely on a single leader or system.
6. Separate Science from Spirituality
You can be a witch or pagan and still respect science. Magic doesn’t have to contradict reality—it works alongside it. For example:
Herbs like chamomile and valerian have scientifically proven calming properties, but that doesn’t mean they’re a cure-all.
Astrology can provide insight into your personality, but it’s not a substitute for therapy or medical advice.
🌙 Balance: Use spirituality as a tool for meaning and connection, not as a replacement for critical thinking or evidence-based practices.
7. Build Your Own Practice
You don’t need to follow every trend or adopt someone else’s path. Witchcraft and paganism are deeply personal journeys. Create a practice that aligns with your values and beliefs, free from the noise of conspiracy theories or cult-like pressures.
Learn about local folklore or the natural cycles in your area.
Experiment with simple rituals, like lighting a candle with intention or journaling under the moon.
Create an altar with objects that resonate with you—crystals, photos, or even trinkets that make you smile.
🌟 Most Importantly: Trust your intuition. If something doesn’t feel right, it’s okay to say “no, thanks.”
8. Community: Seek Connection, Not Control
Connecting with other witches and pagans can be enriching—but choose your circles wisely. Look for communities that:
Encourage discussion and critical thought.
Respect individual paths and practices.
Avoid fear-mongering or elitism.
👀 Where to Look: Online forums, book clubs, or open public rituals are great starting points. Just remember to maintain healthy boundaries.
9. Grounding Techniques to Avoid Falling for the “Woo Woo”
When exploring spirituality, it’s easy to get carried away. Grounding yourself regularly can help you stay centered:
Meditate or practice mindful breathing.
Spend time in nature, whether it’s a park or your backyard.
Write down your beliefs and revisit them regularly. Are they still serving you?
10. Be Open-Minded, Not Gullible
It’s okay to explore the mystical and unknown, but there’s a difference between curiosity and naivety. Stay open to new ideas, but don’t abandon discernment. Your path should feel empowering, not overwhelming or manipulative.
Witchcraft and paganism are all about connecting with nature, yourself, and the divine in ways that feel meaningful and authentic. By staying grounded, informed, and true to yourself, you can embrace this path without falling prey to conspiracy theories or cult-like traps.
Remember: You’re the captain of your own broomstick. Fly wisely.
💜 Love the blog? Subs on Ko-fi & Patreon (18+) get to see posts before they go live on Tumblr! I also offer readings and spells in my Ko-fi Shop!
