No, this is a terrible take and I am beyond tired of seeing it.Â
Itâs ultimately pretty classist, ableist, and also says a lot about what people think of artists.Â
Seriously, we need to unpack this. This is how people wind up feeling guilty for anything that brings them joy. It cultivates the cultural idea that people with disabilities or who are poor donât deserve and canât create nice things.Â
I have been Bullet Journaling on and off since 2014. I know because seeing the original video was memorable for me - I think it might have been a lifehacker article that linked me to the website heâd thrown up for it back then. Literally that night, I drove to an office supply store and bought a grid paper notebook because thatâs all there really was for it in those days. It is a tool Iâve gone back to over and over because it really is just that damn good.Â
I say all this to say that Iâve been in and around the bujo community for a long ass time.Â
Naturally a lot of those original creators who were gracious enough to share their Bullet Journaling practice were also neurodivergent. A lot of them also happened to be women, often with creative practices (something neurodivergent folks are often good at and drawn to) that they managed through and later combined with their bullet journaling - because they enjoyed doing that work.
What OP has done is reinforced the idea that ADHD looks a certain way - like their specific tastes and limitations - and that people who are the least bit capable are assumed neurotypical. Thatâs ableist. Stop.Â
If you look at a gorgeous bullet journal spread and think âthat person is neurotypicalâ that says so much more about your internalized ableism than that person youâre judging.Â
Fact is so many of the top bullet journal creators on YouTube and Instagram have openly talked about their struggles with trauma, ADHD, Autism, eating disorders, OCD, chronic fatigue, etc. Ryder Carrollâs own book on his method includes many of these more artistic examples and their stories to encourage people to find what works for them personally. On story shared talked about how including art in their bullet journaling made them want to journal more and that journaling helped them recover from a skin picking disorder.Â
Art is healing. Art is something we all need. Whether you include it in your practice is optional. But including it in no way denotes class or disability holy shit.
Bullet journaling is at itâs heart a journaling system - a way to reflect and refine your thoughts and actions. Art journaling has been a long standing practice often used by neurodivergent people who arenât always the best with words. It is fucking natural that many people wanted to both Bullet Journal and art journal in the same journal. Ryder Carroll has openly talked about itâs a flexible system that can incorporate a lot of different styles of reflection - art is one of those.
You know who tend to art journal - artists and art students. Two groups of people who are very often not middle class. Many are just as in debt any of the rest of us. Many work their art job and their making-ends meet job. They have access to the materials to do these things not because they are super comfortable but because their income relies on it.Â
Would you tell a carpenter or an electrician they must not be disabled or poor if they build their own bookshelf from scraps or wire in a nicer lighting fixture they thrifted? And hell those trade actually pay more. So really this just seems to speak to the very weird ideas people have about art.Â
You share responsibility for the ideas you formulate based on social media. How are we in 2022 and people are still not getting that social media is a curated snapshot and demanding anyone hey find to educated them fully about a topic theyâve not investigated.Â
If you look at someone having a nice time drawing in their bullet journal and being proud of what they made and think I have to do that - that is a you issue, not a content creator issue. Â
But seriously yâall - the funniest thing about this whole thing to me is just how many people are outing themselves for having formed passionate opinions on this and not just googling âbullet journalingâ. Ryder Carrollâs work has consistently been on the front page for years. You not taking the time to read it is not the part of some woman with some fine liners drawing flowers on her cover page for the month.Â
TL;DR - Poor people and neurodivergent folks deserve and can make beautiful things. Assuming that majority of creators making beautiful spreads are middle class and able bodied pretty much solely on the fact theyâre taking the time to make something beautiful for themselves - is itself pretty classist and ableist.Â
Creators sharing their personal practice do not have to educate you.
You are responsible for your assumptions. Google is right there.Â