Toxic Masculinity is an outgrowth of the concept of Manliness as defined by the Consumer Culture, the dominant culture that we live in.
The Consumer Culture promotes Manliness as “appearance”. To be Manly, you must “appear” Manly, which means you must “buy” it.
To be a “Man” you must buy the right clothes, the right car/truck, the right place to live, the right education, the right body (very muscular, in many cases drug induced) and even the right life partner.
The Martial Culture, the culture of the fight gyms, promotes Manliness as “earned”. Fighting produces and nurtures Manliness. Manliness is not about “appearing Manly” but rather the ability and willingness to fight. Appearance is not important at all.
Manliness includes fight skills, a trained and conditioned body and most importantly the Moral Virtues of Humility, Integrity, Selflessness, Self Control and always showing Respect.
Manliness is truly moral.
The Consumer Culture’s version of Manliness has no morals. It is morally bankrupt. This is why it is often labeled as “Toxic Masculinity” because it offers the opposite of the Moral Virtues of true Manliness.
Arrogance instead of Humility.
Lying and fake news instead of Integrity and always seeking the Truth.
Selfishness and self absorption instead of true Selflessness.
Lack of Self Control instead of true Self Control and Discretion at all times.
Constant displays of disrespect instead of always showing Respect for people, places and things.
So, my message to all Men, including trans Men is:
Always seek and cherish true Manliness!