Here is Every TASM!Peter/Male MJ Fic I’ve managed to unearth from the depths of Ao3 tagging hell
(There is a reason no one can find these and it’s because they’re all tagged with inconsistent pairings and characters which makes finding these so much harder than it needs to be lol)
**Please note I have not read/pre-screened the WIPs yet
Worth the Risk by Agent of Nothing (Barnable) aka @sugarskies (1k)
MJ decides to ask Peter-Three whether he’s ever met his universe’s MJ. He has, of course, but it turns out they have very different opinions on the matter.
His MJ by Eya_Silvers aka @elenafisher-wong (WIP)
“It doesn’t have to be Mary-Jane. Or Michelle Jones, for that matter. It just has to be a person to hold on to.“
or Peter Parker thinks back to his alter ego’s words, and decides that he does deserve better.
and the universe said… by @plupluplu (1k)
“Hey, Gwen.” He grins tiredly, placing a flower he had picked on the way onto the headstone. “I did something new, you’ll never believe it, but I made two new friends today.”
It’s a Strange Way of Saying that I Know… by merpiplier (WIP)
Peter 3 gets back to his own universe and immediately looks into what’s changed; a lot has, some stayed the same, and around the corner Peter finds his new beginning, his older variants words ringing in his head.
I Watched It Begin Again by immortalpramheda (2k)
Peter returns to his universe after fighting alongside the other Peter Parker’s. He’s still haunted by Gwen’s death and trying to come to terms with everything he’s gone through.
And We will Try Again by @vibesandwonders (1k)
“I realize I didn’t get your name.” Peter says, after they talk for far longer than he’d originally planned. May is gonna be pissed.
“Dr. Mahendra Jadhav Wadhwa PhD.” The Stranger cuts across smoothly, reaching out a hand in a belated greeting. “Don’t worry Peter Parker,” He says smiling, broadly at whatever he reads in Peter’s expression. “Friends call me MJ.”
Self-Acceptance by galaxiesreader (0.5k) - not MJ slash just bi Peter
Peter fidgeted with vials and bottles to disguise nervousness as busyness. "So just—just girls then?”
Or, Andrew!Peter reveals his status as a disaster bisexual and is curious whether sexuality transcends the multiverse.
face it, tiger by Rest (3.5k)
The piece is going to be a profile on Michael Jordan Watson, a senior and the rare frat president who actually cares about the service aspect of Greek life. This weekend, he and the rest of his frat are doing Habitat for Humanity stuff in a part of town that even Peter, a lifelong New Yorker and Spider-Man, feels nervous in.
So yeah. Take pictures of some bros, and then more of one bro in particular, and head home. Very routine. Except for how his brain sort of stumbles when MJ strides over and introduces himself. And in this context, "stumbles” means that Peter stumbles over his own feet, his words, and his train of thought.
MJ is… well. Peter doesn’t know what he is. He is shirtless. And sweaty. Not gross sweaty, he just… has a sheen, sort of. Peter honestly has no idea what he even says before he ducks behind his camera.
What Makes You Real by SHCombatalade (4k)
He’s already halfway up the stairs but MJ’s response has him drawing up short, doubling back with disbelief because there is no way, no way, that ‘cover for me’ means ‘He’s off to don his spandex and save the city’ like MJ says. “What the f-oucault pendulum,” he admonishes; it’s not what he wants to say, not even close, but Aunt May is standing there all of five-foot-two with an eyebrow raised warningly.
“Oh,” MJ snorts over a forkful of potatoes, “you really think she didn’t know?” And yeah, he really really did.
we are the outsiders by apollothyme (6k)
Coffee Shop!AU with no superpowers where Peter is a tired college student who is in love with double espressos and has a crush on ‘MJ Watson - aspiring actor and gorgeous part-time worker at the dingy coffee shop near Stark Tower’. Peter’s very own words.
Genderbend where MJ is a guy and looks exactly like Michael B Jordan.
mary jane’s last dance by connorswhisk (1k)
But - but MJ, where’s MJ? The others had had one, older Peter knew a Gwen and an MJ, and yeah, things aren’t gonna be the same across the verses, but Peter has this feeling, this gut feeling that MJ is like Uncle Ben, that MJ is like With great power comes great responsibility; that MJ is a constant presence in the life of one Peter Benjamin Parker.
I’m also including the famous fan-written TASM 3 Screenplay including bi Peter Parker and Male MJ which is a MASTERPIECE and I highly encourage you read the preamble before diving into the pdf
Please please please feel free to add onto this post if there’s any other fics you find that I’ve missed, and if one of these fics is yours please message me and I’ll tag you.
