very strange cottage industry on youtube of giving exhaustive "critiques" of harry potter that amount to things like "the magic school is dangerous and that's bad!!!" and treating that with equal severity as the fatphobia or the slavery apologia, then patting themselves on the back as if this amounts to some kind of praxis
cinemasins is not praxis lol. how about materially supporting and protecting trans people from joanne and forgetting about her wizard books
I loved harry potter growing up. it made me feel seen as an abused and closeted kid. I idolized and looked up to joanne, wanting to become an author like her
then she started funnelling all her wizard book money into destroying the rights of my people and I resolved not to give her any more of my money
I didn't have to reevaluate the quality of her writing to do this. whether she's good at keeping her worldbuilding consistent or whatever has nothing to do with my decision to boycott her work. who cares how good or bad her writing is. she's killing trans people
OP, you get it. This is exactly the problem.
I suggest finding a different book at your local library!
Bruh.
I WORK in a library. And I read about twelve books at a time. And I’m drafting a Harry Potter rebound reading list organized by genre and time period.
It isn’t about the book; it’s that once the books meant something about love, justice and courage. It’s a case where what we got out of the art was what we put into it. For some that was making music, for others creating charities and for those like me? Committing to be braver. And now that the art is tainted, no amount of writing quality will change that taint.
That’s why those videos saying the books were “always bad” don’t help. The book quality is the lower priority versus the author becoming Dolores Umbridge!
I was seconding op's point, not trying to tell you to do more. I agree that whether or not the books are good doesn't matter. Your reblog was the one put on my dash so it's the one I reblogged, I'm sorry (genuine).
It’s okay. I’m sorry too; so many people reblog judgmental stuff about HP fans, complete with recommending the books I read as a kid and adult, that I reacted with judgment rather than taking a step back. Definitely agree that libraries should be used more and saved.




















