The culinary traditions of Italy are vast and influential, but there are few as unique and truly irreplaceable as the nation’s cocktail culture. A long-standing favorite of mine and many is the Negroni; a classic combination of one parts each gin, Campari, and vermouth. The ingredients come together as a pungent, bitter potion of complex and delicious flavors. Perfect for settling a stomach bursting full of hard cheese and pasta, the Negroni’s stomach-calming properties have earned near mythical status. It’s like Pepto-Bismol in ruby-red slippers.
For many, the signature bite of Campari can be a bit much. It’s alluring red color makes sweet promises of cherries and grenadine, but that first sip instead storms the palate with earthy notes of gentian and bitter orange. It can be a fun game at cocktail parties to watch as the face of an Amari virgin transforms into a knot of disbelief after their first sip of a Negroni.
Despite her refined palate, H is not a Campari lover. Being the Negroni enthusiast that I am, I sought out ways that she could enjoy the cocktail with me. A common tradeoff is subbing Campari for its softer, more orange like brother, Aperol. It’s a great substitute, though much of the signature bitterness is lost in the conversion. Here’s where we come to the oh-so-cleverly named Montenegroni, a concoction H and I collaborated on to bring some signature bitterness back to the Negroni, while doing something interesting with the flavor.
Montenegro is a delicious Amaro with a spicy, clove-like flavor. Lovingly known as Monty to those who enjoy it (side note: Monty is also the name of our adorable orange tabby cat, so bonus points for Montenegro there), it is an incredibly agreeable amaro to most people, even those who aren’t big fans of bitter drinks. That clove flavor makes it a natural pair for the orange forward Aperol. For the Montenegroni, mix equal parts Montenegro, Aperol, and Gin in a mixing glass, then pour into a rocks glass with ice, or serve it up in a coupe if you prefer. Normally I like a few dashes of orange bitters in my Negronis, but in this case, I feel the Aperol takes care of that flavor profile so any orange bitters I add just get lost. Feel free to toss some in if you want though.
This Negroni-like concoction opens with a fragrance of sweet citrus, clove, and a hint of cinnamon. The flavors scream Christmas to me, but I’m not sure if that’s a universal feeling. On the tail, you’ll get a gentle, stomach-calming hug of bitterness from the Montenegro and Aperol, but it doesn’t hang on past its welcome. I hope you enjoy this one, I certainly do, and it is as tasty as it is simple.
Montenegroni Recipe
1oz Aperol
1oz Montenegro
1oz Gin (We used Bombay Sapphire)
Place all ingredients in a mixing glass and stir with ice. Using a julip spoon or hawthorne strainer, strain into a rocks glass with one large ice cube, or serve up in a coupe. Garnish with a twist of orange.