Tags: [mlw] [angst] [hurt/comfort] [Marauders era] [friendship] [hidden pain] [self-worth issues] [reader-insert] [found family] [slight fluff ending]
The Marauders were loud. They were reckless, wild, and altogether too much. They were the brightest light in any room, a force of nature that nothing—not professors, not rules, not even the war brewing outside the walls of Hogwarts—could seem to dim.
And yet, in the middle of it all, there was Remus.
Remus, who laughed along with them but never quite as freely. Who let himself be dragged into pranks but was always the first to pull back. Who, despite being surrounded by warmth, still looked like he was standing just a little too far from the fire.
And tonight, you could see it clearer than ever.
You weren’t sure when you’d started noticing. Maybe it had been years, maybe it had only been months. But somewhere along the way, you had learned to read the shift in him, the way his mask would slip when he thought no one was looking.
The Gryffindor common room was filled with its usual chaos—James was dramatically reenacting his latest Quidditch goal using a pillow as the Quaffle, Sirius was sprawled on the couch, lazily tossing popcorn into Peter’s open mouth, and somewhere in the corner, Lily was attempting (and failing) to focus on her Arithmancy homework amid the noise.
And then there was Remus.
He was seated by the fire, a book open on his lap, but he wasn’t reading. He wasn’t even pretending to. His gaze was distant, lost in the flames, fingers curled tightly around the edges of the pages as if anchoring himself to something.
The full moon had passed just two nights ago, and though he had done his best to clean himself up, to smooth out the evidence of what it had taken from him, you saw the exhaustion in his frame. The slight tremor in his fingers. The way the sleeves of his sweater were pulled down just a little too far, hiding whatever wounds hadn’t yet faded.
“Moony,” James called, plopping down next to him, disrupting his staring contest with the fire. “Come on, mate, you’ve been quiet all evening. We’ve all taken a vote, and it’s been decided that you must participate in our highly important discussion.”
Remus arched a brow. “Which is?”
“Which professor would survive the longest if Hogwarts was suddenly taken over by a herd of angry Hippogriffs,” Sirius supplied from his position on the couch.
Remus exhaled a soft laugh, shaking his head. “This is what you lot do in your free time?”
“You love it,” Peter said with a grin.
Remus smiled—one of those small, quiet ones that never quite reached his eyes. But before he could reply, James threw an arm around his shoulders, shaking him slightly.
“Come on, Moons,” James said, playful, but laced with something more—something knowing. “You can’t sulk all night. You’re among friends. No brooding allowed.”
You watched as Remus hesitated, his expression shifting for a fraction of a second before he plastered on something that looked close enough to amusement.
He was going to let them believe it. He was going to pretend, to act like everything was fine, because that was what he did. What he always did.
You weren’t going to let him.
Later that night, after the common room had emptied, you found him on the Astronomy Tower.
The wind was biting, but he didn’t seem to care. He stood by the railing, staring out at the sky, hands gripping the stone like he was trying to ground himself.
“You know, I might start charging you for these late-night visits,” you said lightly, stepping beside him.
Remus huffed a soft laugh but didn’t look at you. “And here I thought you just enjoyed my company.”
“I do,” you admitted. “But I’d enjoy it a lot more if you weren’t wearing that ‘I’m fine’ face.”
“I’m fine,” he said automatically.
You gave him a look. “Try again.”
He sighed, running a hand through his already-messy hair. For a long moment, he didn’t speak, and you let the silence settle between you, waiting.
“I hate this,” he murmured.
Your chest tightened. “What?”
“This.” He gestured vaguely to himself. “Me. The way I feel after every full moon. The way I pretend it doesn’t hurt. The way I make them laugh, so they don’t notice that I’m—” He cut himself off, shaking his head.
“That you’re breaking?” you finished softly.
His jaw clenched. “I don’t get to break.”
You took a step closer. “Why not?”
“Because—” He exhaled sharply, his grip on the railing tightening. “Because I have to be the responsible one. The level-headed one. I can’t afford to be a mess.”
He turned his head, finally meeting your gaze, his amber eyes tired, guarded.
“I’m so bloody tired,” he admitted.
You reached for his hand. He let you take it.
“You don’t have to do this alone, you know,” you said softly. “You have them. You have me.”
You squeezed his hand. “You are allowed to fall apart, Remus.”
His breathing hitched, and for the first time, his guard cracked. Just a little.
And you held on, grounding him, reminding him that he wasn’t alone.
You didn’t say anything else. You just stood there, holding his hand as he quietly tried to put himself back together. It wasn’t much, but it was something.
And yet, despite the moment of honesty, despite the fact that he had let you see a glimpse of what he carried, nothing really changed.
Because the next morning, Remus was right back to pretending.
The bags under his eyes were darker, his movements slightly slower, but he still smiled, still went along with James and Sirius’ ridiculous antics, still answered Peter’s questions about Transfiguration, still did his best to act like nothing was wrong.
And, soon enough, so did the others.
James noticing that Remus had been skipping meals more often, shoving food around on his plate but never really eating.
Sirius catching him dozing off in the library with his notes sprawled around him, ink smudged on his cheek.
Peter asking him something during a group conversation and realizing, for the first time, that Remus hadn’t actually spoken in over an hour.
Little things. Things that, when pieced together, painted an entirely different picture.
And, somehow, James was the first to confront him.
“You look like shite, Moony,” James said bluntly, dropping onto the couch beside him in the common room.
Remus glanced up from his parchment, unimpressed. “Charming, really.”
“I mean it,” James pressed, nudging him with his shoulder. “You’ve been pushing yourself too hard.”
James frowned. “That’s bollocks.”
Remus sighed, rubbing his temple. “James—”
“Don’t ‘James’ me.” The usual playfulness was gone from his voice, replaced with something more serious. “We’ve all noticed it, you know. You’re exhausted.”
“You also have a stomach that needs food, and a body that needs sleep, and—”
James scoffed. “Right, because that’s clearly working out for you.”
Remus clenched his jaw. “I don’t need you to mother me.”
James stared at him for a long moment, then sighed, shaking his head. “You stubborn arse.”
And though Remus went back to his essay, pretending like the conversation was over, the weight of James’ words lingered.
Sirius, of course, took a different approach.
“Alright, this is ridiculous.”
Remus barely looked up before Sirius plopped down dramatically across from him at breakfast.
“You.” Sirius grabbed a piece of toast and waved it in his face. “Eat.”
Remus gave him a flat look. “I’m not hungry.”
“I don’t care.” Sirius pushed the plate closer. “Eat.”
Remus sighed heavily but grabbed the toast, if only to shut Sirius up.
Sirius grinned. “See? That wasn’t so hard, was it?”
Remus shot him a glare but took a bite anyway.
Peter, being Peter, was quieter about it.
He didn’t push. He didn’t tease. He just… helped.
When Remus forgot to grab extra parchment for class, Peter had already borrowed some for him.
When his hands were too shaky from the full moon to write properly, Peter quietly passed him a quill with a better grip.
When they all walked back from Hogsmeade in the cold, Peter made sure he ended up with the extra scarf Sirius had been carrying around.
Things Remus never thanked him for, but always noticed.
Despite all their efforts, Remus still wasn’t letting up.
He still studied late into the night, still woke up before everyone else, still tried to keep up with every single responsibility that came with being Remus Lupin—reliable, intelligent, well-mannered, responsible Remus.
And then it all came crashing down.
It was late. Too late. Even the common room fire had begun to dwindle into soft embers, casting long shadows across the floor. You and the Marauders had long since turned in, but when you woke up in the middle of the night, an uneasy feeling settling in your chest, you found yourself wandering back down the stairs.
Still at the table by the window, hunched over his notes, the candle beside him flickering unsteadily.
You had seen this before—the way his fingers trembled slightly as he wrote, the way his shoulders curled inward, the way his head drooped lower with every passing second. But this time was different. This time, his exhaustion wasn’t just pressing against him—it was crushing him.
And then, just as you took a step closer, you saw his hand tighten into a fist.
“Remus?” you called softly.
For a split second, he looked up at you, and that’s when you saw it—the sheer, overwhelming weight of everything he had been carrying. And before you could say another word, before you could tell him to just stop, to just breathe, he let out a shaky exhale—and the dam broke.
His quill snapped between his fingers.
His other hand, the one resting on the table, gripped the edge so tightly his knuckles turned white.
And then, suddenly, violently, he shoved everything off the table.
Ink splattered across the floor. Parchment scattered in every direction. His textbooks hit the ground with heavy, final thuds.
Remus was never like this. He never let his emotions get the better of him, never lashed out like this.
But right now? He was breaking.
And the worst part? He didn’t even look angry. He just looked… tired. So, so tired.
You rushed forward, hesitating only slightly before kneeling beside him. “Remus—”
“I can’t,” he rasped, voice raw. “I can’t—I can’t do this anymore.”
Your heart twisted painfully. “Moony…”
“I’m trying.” His breaths were coming faster now, uneven and ragged. “I’m trying so hard to keep up, to be okay, to be normal, but I—I don’t think I can do it anymore.”
The words shattered something in you.
Because this—this was Remus at his most vulnerable. The Remus who spent so much time holding everything together for everyone else that he had nothing left for himself.
You reached out, hesitantly at first, before gently taking his shaking hands in yours. “You don’t have to do it alone.”
He let out a sharp breath, one that almost sounded like a sob, but he squeezed his eyes shut before anything could escape.
“I don’t know how,” he admitted quietly.
And for a moment, you just sat there. Holding onto him, grounding him, staying with him.
The door creaked open behind you.
You turned, finding James, Sirius, and Peter standing there, their faces etched with worry. None of them said anything, but as soon as Sirius saw the ink staining Remus’ hands, saw the scattered pages around him, his expression softened into something heartbreakingly gentle.
James moved first, kneeling beside Remus, not saying a word before pulling him into a firm, steadying hug. And that’s when Remus broke completely, shoulders shaking as he buried his face into James’ shoulder, gripping onto him as if he were the only thing keeping him tethered to reality.
Sirius sat down on his other side, resting a hand on his back, rubbing slow circles there. “You’re allowed to be tired, you know,” he murmured. “You’re allowed to need help.”
Peter sat down too, silent but solid, a quiet presence that meant more than words ever could.
Because that’s all he needed right now—to know that, no matter how heavy the weight on his shoulders got, he wouldn’t have to carry it alone.
A/N GUYS! if you have any ideas please let me know, and if you want to be tagged to a particular type or all of my posts, just comment or message!