I guess I'm watching the Cocteau Beauty and the Beast tonight.
Somehow, in all these years of knowjng about this film as one of the classics of fairy tale films, I somehow missed the fact that it was in French?? Did I know this at one time and just forgot?? Utterly baffled at how I missed this.
Writing the opening credits on the chalkboard, that's pretty cool. (Maybe this is something a lot of old movies do, idk).
Seven minutes in and I'm bored. Who cares about Beauty's sisters?
Beauty genuinely thinks her sisters are more beautiful. It's a common-enough trope in retellings, but she manages to sell it. She's not lamenting over it or pitying herself, she's just matter-of-fact about it.
It turns out that what every Beauty and the Beast adaptation needs is for Beauty to have a brother who defends her from scoundrels. Even in just this one moment, it's a nice dynamic that I wish I'd see used more often.
Beauty plans to stay single for her father's sake? Interesting way to show their bond. (Though idk if she wants to or just thinks her father expects it)
Gosh, her sisters are annoying.
Oh, her brothers are idiots, too!
The forest is nice and moody. I kind of wonder if the animated film borrowed some shots here.
In motion, I like how the "invisible servants" thing just makes it look like the castle is haunted.
I'm loving the creepy atmosphere of the castle in general. This movie is working best when people stop talking and they let the visuals immerse you in the fairy tale atmosphere.
Aw, the Beast is all fuzzy!
I like how the theft of the rose is portrayed as one of your typical fairy conditions. You could have taken anything else, but stealing a rose leads to death, because that's the rule, no further explanation needed.
Nice that her father intended to go back.
Loving the dreamy imagery of Beauty exploring the castle.
So you were totally fine with the furniture talking to you and the statues and blankets moving on their own, but the appearance of a big fuzzy guy is what you faint over? Okay.
I know the Beast usually wears human clothes, but it's striking me as funny right now. Just imagining him putting on his little boots and his big old lace ruff is amusing.
What's with the Beast flailing around like he's drunk?
Okay, she's got an Evil Queen dress now.
"Will you let me watch you dine?" Was there no other less-creepy way you could have phrased that?
Idk man, I just can't get over this Beast's voice. And he's acting way too creepy for me to buy the whole "he's good-hearted, just ugly" thing.
Like, dude, I don't think your ugliness should be her main concern here. I'm much more concerned about the fact that you live in a creepy haunted castle with human hands and eyes sticking out of the walls and furniture.
I can see why this is so influential, though, because this imagery is amazing, and I want to steal half of it.
Why are his hands smoking? Did I miss something?
Right on for yelling at him for being in your room, girl.
Oh, he drinks like a puppy! Cute!
And he's actively fighting a beastly nature?
Idk, man, I find it kind of repulsive that she lets you drink from her hands. There was zero reason you couldn't take two steps and drink from that fountain yourself. Or drink from your own hands.
Oh, we're going full crazy bloody wolf-man now. I love how Beauty refuses to put up with his shit. Like, "So you're cursed with a supernatural bloodlust. Get a hold of yourself, loser."
The comedy of the moneylenders taking away the brothers' chess table midgame was a welcome relief.
Oh, this version does a forbidden room thing, too? But Beast is also forbidden from it?
This is the first retelling I've seen where it really feels like the Beast is her unattractive arranged-marriage husband. Sending her home is like the wife wanting to return to her father's house. Her deciding to leave him would kill him.
He literally tells her that if she doesn't come back, he'll die and she'll get all his riches. And he gives her the key to his magic! He's handing her the means to kill him and become a wealthy widow, solving all her problems, but he trusts her to come back. I'm obsessed.
Her speech to her father about how she's noticed all these layers in the Beast and feels sorry for him is a good one. It would make me believe in this romance if any of it was shown rather than just told.
How long is she supposed to have been gone? Like, she's surprised that the laundry's been done.
Tears turning into magic diamonds that cure her father? Okay, sure, why not?
And now they're planning to murder the Beast for his riches. Beauty needs a better family.
He trusted you with the key, and you just left it sitting out on an open table?
Why does the Gaston guy seem to be living with her family?
As despicable as her family is, at least they're doing something. Being active in the story.
The magic mirror breaking as a sign of danger is a nice touch.
For all the fairy tale melodrama, there's just enough comedy and worldbuilding and plot expansion to keep it a bit grounded.
The guy breaking into the treasure house gets killed and turned into a beast at the same moment the Beast turned back into the prince, which implies that it wasn't love that saved him at all, it's just that some other hapless victim took his place.
This prince guy is just as melodramatic as the Beast.
"I don't mind being afraid, as long as it's with you." Cute. And a necessary line to make me believe in a happy ending after she seems so disappointed by losing the Beast.
When he said they could fly to his kingdom, I didn't think he was literally gonna fly in the air like Superman! I lost it. Dissolved in giggles as the movie fades out.
Overall, a compelling adaptation (in a classic foreign movie way) with great imagery, an unconvincing central relationship, and some good (and some confusing) plot choices. Glad to have finally watched it. It feels like a major hole in my fairy tale experience has been filled in.