"Punishment works!!!" We're drowning in three to four generations of people so pants-shittingly terrified of ever being wrong that half of everyone has constructed a worldview wherein they never even consider the possibility that they could be wrong and the other half behaves like one wrong move will make anything or anyone explode violently into a million irreperable pieces. I don't think it works guys
I know this might be a bold take but maybe teaching everyone from a young age that ever making a mistake will be met with unimaginable pain and misery doesn't actually encourage learning or correct behavior. If anything it creates a sense of terror so powerful it completely suffocates curiosity and exploration, thus leading to people knowing absolutely nothing but whatever is brought directly to them, which is a big problem in a world where information is so tightly controlled that a very small number of very powerful people basically have complete power over what people see and hear on a day-to-day basis when not actively seeking new and rigorously verified information from diverse and trustworthy sources.
if any of this sounds like you, start by looking up the definition of words you've heard and are pretty sure you know what they mean, but haven't actually double-checked for yourself. Just like, whenever it occurs to you. Great first step
This post goes out to the "we need to bring back bullying" crowd. Just because you aren't hitting someone physically doesn't mean you aren't being punitive. Maybe it isn't actually healthy to believe it's necessary to harass and humiliate anyone who makes you upset or uncomfortable. That sounds like a you problem actually.
Anyways, breaking the cycle of abuse starts with you and how you treat yourself. You have to give yourself grace and room for error or you'll never be able to cultivate a healthier mindset than your trauma left you with. It's not easy, but you have to trust yourself that whatever seems kinder than however you usually treat yourself is probably a good enough start.
Okay, so...
Storytime
(I promise I will definitely overuse this. XD)
Recently a community my spouse has been part of for several years almost literally imploded, led by the example of that community's leader. (For the sake of privacy, none of the names shared here are real.)
The leader, Dave, was a pretty nice guy. Established a community around a fandom he loved and saw decent success at content creation in that fandom. Even got sponsorships and could quit his day-job to become a full-time content creator. So far so good. But every 3-ish years, the mask would slip.
His wife Susan was also a part of the community, and while somewhat inconsistent in her contributions, was well-loved by all. Then she moved out. No warning, just packed her bags, and told Dave as she was walking out the door that she was moving out.
Over the last three days, the Whole Story has spilled, throwing the community into chaos, and dividing it into two camps:
Camp 1 says "Susan felt unsafe and had the right to leave when she didn't like how she was being treated."
and
Camp 2 says "It's not abuse! He never hit her."
🚩🚩🚩
Now, I definitely shouldn't need to spell this out, but fellas - the phrase "physical abuse" exists because there are in fact many kinds of abuse, and not all of it is physically violent.
"Abuse" is in fact a synonym for "maltreatment," which means "to treat (someone or something) badly, or to cause harm or injury."
If the defense of a pattern of behavior is "well, I never punched you in the face," that's not a defense. That's an admission. "Sure, what I did was bad but it wasn't as bad as it could have been."
This ^ is bullshit.
You do not have the need or the right to punish the people around you. If you feel punishment is necessary, please interrogate that - it usually means that you're attempting to control things over which you have no real authority.
The science has consistently shown that positive reinforcement (the addition of pleasant things to a person's situation as a reward for desirable actions) is significantly more effective than either negative or positive punishment (the removal of pleasant things or the addition of unpleasant things in response to undesirable actions). This is true in raising children, training animals, and leading communities.
PUNISHMENT is not only ineffective, but abusive.






















