what do you see when you look at this tintype?
if you're like 99% of the internet, the answer is "Victorian witches."
this picture has been making the rounds for years, usually as "Victorian witches c. 1875," or "women dressed as witches c. 1875." it's available as canvas prints, framed wall art, decorative pillows, posters...you name it. I still can't find how it first got online or where the original might be, but it's spread like wildfire
but what's fascinating to me is that they're not even dressed as witches. indeed, there's really nothing to suggest that they're witches at all
the woman on the left appears to be wearing a tall, pointed hat at first glance- but she isn't. she's standing in front of a tree on the painted backdrop that perfectly aligns with her hat to make the crown look tall and pointed. none of them are wearing "witch hats," but once you think you see that first one- if you're like me -you imagine that the broad-brimmed hat worn by the woman on the right might be hiding a tall pointed crown because of the angle of her head. even though nothing about it confirms that idea
and look! she's holding a broom! witches! ...but the woman on the far right is holding a dustpan and a feather duster. suddenly the theme is less "witches" and more "cleaning supplies."
so no pointy hats and a broom clearly contextualized as just for sweeping. not sure what's up with the taxidermied bird in the middle, but at once the photo seems a lot less witchy (I don't know what it actually depicts, but I've seen at least one other photo of well-dressed women holding cleaning supplies- some sort of club, perhaps?). all because of elements that are clearly visible in plain sight
people are very, very good at seeing what they want to see