wait okay so this is lowkey kinda random but like I've seen a lot of your posts that end up mentioning how marvel refuses to write peter as anything but straight - which I definitely see, especially bc as literally like THE most popular character of the universe they wouldn't want to make him controversial in that way (🙄) but it's really funny to me bc there's this huge divide between marvel itself and the fandom; bc like I feel like of all the fanonized characters, peter is so often just agreed to be bi, more than almost any others, even characters that have actual hinting about it. there's even memes about how he's just like really shippable lol anyways I'm not entirely sure where I was going with this but I was wondering what your take is on why the dynamic is like this?
So yeah, I think for me at least, when I talk about this, there's three things happening here. And this is just how I look at it when I'm talking about things, not really how I think anyone else should treat them. The first is that I like to be really clear about what is and isn't actually canon, because I think in something like long running superhero comics, it is very easy to present non-canon information in ways that can be mistaken for canon information, and to obscure, whether intentionally or unintentionally, fanon from canon. I'm in a position where I'm very familiar with canon, so I always try to be clear -- it's why when I talk about Johnny's situation, I mention that he exists in a grey area, where he has had an author-confirmed sexual relationship with a man (Akihiro), and where he has been the victim of a fairly explicit gay bashing incident (Dark Reign: Zodiac #1), but where he is not, according to Marvel, anything other than heterosexual at the time of my writing this post.
The same works for Peter -- I can write all the fanfiction I want, and I can have my thoughts on his relationships, but he is not canonically bisexual. As in, Marvel does not consider him bisexual, at the time of writing this post. For me, it's important to keep that distinction when I'm discussing the actual canon. It doesn't mean I can't pick apart subtext or apply motivations to certain relationships, but that's me bringing things to the table.
So that's the first thing. The second thing is that I am an advertiser's daughter, so one of the things that I'm personally always looking at is what is something selling, because I guess my dad did irreparable damage that way. And that doesn't necessarily have to be a physical product. A story needs to sell itself, too -- and if we're selling, who are we selling to? Who is the most desirable audience? So obviously, I know looking at Spider-Man that I am not its most desired audience. Spider-Man as a property doesn't really care about what I want, because it's not -- I don't want to say it's not "for" me, because I decide what's for me, but I am not the target audience. So what I want and what I see in the text is not guaranteed to line up with their priorities. We'll use Spideytorch as an example, which is something I don't actually think should be main comics canon, but whatever, it works as an example. It doesn't serve the series as a whole to make it canon to make a small group of people who ship it happy, because it would make the larger target audience unhappy. It's something that wouldn't really matter, by comparison, for Johnny, who is not one of the biggest pop culture figures in the world -- if they wrote Johnny as canonically bisexual or confirmed that he has canonical romantic feelings for Peter, a bunch of people on social media might whine and stomp their feet and threaten to stop buying all the Fantastic Four comics we all know they weren't buying, but the press they would get as a result would probably swing in their favor. You can use controversy to your favor, but it has to be worth it for the company. I don't see it happening any time soon. There is also the fact that at this point it would feel inorganic for Marvel to pursue in the long term a Spider-Man romantic relationship that is not with Mary Jane. So any relationship with a man would have to be short term -- something I'm theoretically interested in, but which would in practice look like Peter dating the male version of one of his recent temporary flings. I do think it would be really interesting to do a big AU canon, like Ultimate, where Peter is a relationship with an established male character, like Harry or Johnny. I think that could be done with less like, comic book guy-type Spider-Man fans rioting in the streets.
I also don't think Marvel is particularly interested in making Peter canonically bisexual. In conversations like this, it's easy to bring up certain things, like Stan Lee's comment about one sex being enough in his day, or the Sony leaks with their contract about how Peter could only be portrayed as straight, and kind of let Marvel off the hook, but Marvel is not the brave underdog in this fight. They don't want to do it, either. (I do think they're going to continue to do things like have lines like "do you have a girlfriend or a boyfriend" because that is like an incredibly easy way to curry favor with a fanbase desperate for representation without ever having to actually commit to anything.)
So the third thing for me is also separating how I feel about the body of canon from how I look at shipping. Do I personally write Peter as a bisexual man? Yes. Am I particularly invested in some of his relationships with other men as depicted in canon? Yes. Do I think the chemistry between them was written with subtext in mind? Not always. I'm glad that you brought up Peter's shippability, because for me Peter is such a charismatic, dynamic character that I think that's where things factor in. The thing is, it's fun to watch Peter in relationships. He's this really dynamic, interesting, romantic character and he thrives in a love story. He thrives when he cares about other people, when he's going to the ends of the earth for them. He's just so fun in relationships, so I always love seeing him with someone who can match him step-for-step, whether that's Mary Jane or Felicia or Gwen or Harry or Flash or Johnny. When he has history and connection, it's such a great setup for romance, because he has so much romance in him.
But I also think he's very shippable because he's one of the biggest pop culture figures in the world. I talked about this before, but it ties into the idea of Peter's reputation preceding him. Everyone knows Spider-Man, even if they haven't read his comics. People aren't shipping Peter with Danny Phantom or Jason Todd or whoever because they have amazing chemistry in any existing body of canon. They're doing it because they like the idea of it. Which is fine, you have to do what makes you happy in fandom. But it's fundamentally a very different model of shipping than looking at his decades of history with MJ or Harry. So partly he's shippy because he has great chemistry with people, and partly it doesn't take that much for an online fandom with a vested interest to declare a character bisexual, regardless of your reading of the canon, and partly he's shippy because people like Spider-Man and want to make their dolls kiss. Not a condemnation. I am also making dolls kiss. But for me, I think, there's just a lot kind of going into that idea of him being uniquely shippy, and with so many different characters.












